TalentJR

Tribal Verse – Class 11 English Chapter 24 Notes & NCERT PDF

Class 11EnglishChapter 24NCERT book: Woven Words (Elective) - English Class 11

Notes and a simple summary of Chapter 24 of the NCERT Class 11 English book, with the official chapter PDF, flashcards, an MCQ quiz and an AI tutor for your doubts.

🎧 Listen to the content

Chapter 24: Tribal Verse (Essay with Tribal Songs)

About the Author

G.N. Devy (born 1950), formerly professor of English at Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda, is the Founder Director of the Tribal Academy at Tejgarh, Gujarat and Director of Sahitya Akademi's Project on Literature in Tribal Languages and Oral Traditions. He won the Sahitya Akademi Award for After Amnesia and the SAARC Writers' Foundation Award for his work on the 'denotified tribes'. The chapter contains an extract from his 'Introduction' to Painted Words and three tribal songs.

The Chapter's Introduction

India's literary roots lie in the oral literatures of the tribes/adivasis — songs and chants expressing the close contact between nature and tribal life, transmitted orally across generations. Many are already lost because they were never written down. Urbanisation, print culture and commerce have marginalised these communities, their languages and literatures. Most tribal societies — Munda, Kondh, Adi, Bondo — are bilingual. Santhal and Munda groups also played prominent roles in socio-political movements (e.g. Birsa Munda, 1874–1901, fought colonialism and exploitation of labourers). Translation into English loses some flavour, but without preservation and translation these works would be lost completely.

Summary of Devy's Essay ('Introduction' to Painted Words)

Tribal world-view

Tribal communities live in groups that are cohesive and organically unified, show little interest in accumulating wealth, and see nature, human beings and God as intimately linked. They live more by intuition than reason; space is sacred rather than secular; time is personal rather than objective.

Tribal imagination — "hallucinatory"

Tribal imagination is "dreamlike and hallucinatory", fusing planes of existence: "oceans fly in the sky as birds, mountains swim in the water as fish, animals speak as humans and stars grow like plants." Emotion is linked to narrative motif — stars, seas and mountains can be angry, sad or happy.

Memory over imagination; time over space

Tribal artists work more from racial and sensory memory than cultivated imagination. The tribal mind has a sharper sense of time than space: realising that "domination over territorial space was not their lot", they turned to "gaining domination over time" — e.g. rituals of conversing with dead ancestors through terracotta or carved-wood objects. Memory built complex systems of classifying natural objects.

Literature is more than writing

Many Indian languages remain only spoken, so their compositions aren't considered "literature" — a "feast for the folklorist… but, to a literary critic… nothing". Nomadic communities survive through their oral epics. Devy says: "I, for one, can no longer think of literature as something written… unless we modify the established notion of literature as something written, we will silently witness the decline of various Indian oral traditions."

Features of tribal arts

  • A very flexible 'frame' — boundaries between art and non-art become almost invisible; epics begin from trivial events; paintings merge with living space.
  • No deliberate sequence — "In a tribal Ramayan, an episode from the Mahabharat makes a sudden and surprising appearance."
  • "The syntax of language and the grammar of painting are the same, as if literature were painted words and painting were a song of images."
  • Strict ordering principle: convention — every performance has a previous one behind it; creativity lies in "adhering to the past while… slightly subverting it."
  • Playfulness is the soul of tribal arts; the sacred is present, but the tone is rarely serious or pretentious; heroes are not spared humour.
  • Not created for sale — no competition between patron and artist, so the arts are "relaxed, never tense".
  • They are dynamic, not frozen: experimentation is seen when they are approached as performing arts.
  • Bilingualism lets tribal communities assimilate outside influences; linguists who miss this dismiss tribal languages as dialects.
  • Calling Indian writing 'new literature' was "comical"; adivasi literature is not a new trend — "most people have simply been unaware of its existence". "Every written piece of literature contains substantial layers of orality."
  • The Three Songs

    1. A Munda Song: Song of Birth and Death (from Mundari)

    "My mother, the sun rose / A son was born. / My mother, the moon rose / A daughter was born. / A son was born / The cowshed was depleted; / A daughter was born / The cowshed filled up."

    Cattle go out to pasture in the morning (sunrise → son, cowshed empties) and return at sundown (moonrise → daughter, cowshed fills). The daughter is the more precious asset, probably because Munda women play a dominant role in economic, social and ritual life. Munda facts from the note: live in Jharkhand, West Bengal, Assam, Tripura, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa; also called Horohon or Mura (headman); Encyclopaedia Mundarica (16 volumes) by Rev. John Baptist Hoffman; Tamar insurrection 1819–20; millennial movement under Birsa Munda.

    2. A Kondh Song (death song)

    "This we offer to you. / We can, / Because we are still alive… We give a small baby fowl. / Take this and go away / Whichever way you came… Don't inflict pain on us / After your departure."

    Sung at a death, it begs the spirit to stop troubling the living. Kondhs believe souls love their homes so much they are reluctant to leave the hearth; spirits, though generally kind, can become harmful. The living can make offerings only because they are still alive. 'Kondh' probably comes from the Dravidian konda (hill); no dowry system, but a bride price.

    3. Adi Song for the Recovery of Lost Health (in Miri Agom)

    "Oh my beloved one / If you lost your health due to ill luck / I come forward here to save you / With this Emul… I tie this Ridin creeper / To fasten your soul to your body. / Follow the footprint of this cock."

    A mantra chanted by the maternal uncle to lure the spirit of good health back into the sick body. Emul = healing amulet; Ridin = medicinal creeper; a cock is offered. The Adi use Adi Agom for conversation and Miri Agom, a rhythmic ritual language, for chanting; they live mainly in East and West Siang districts of Arunachal Pradesh and believe every object has a spirit.

    Themes

  • Orality as literature; the danger of losing oral traditions.
  • Tribal world-view — unity of nature, humans and God; time over space.
  • Respect for the girl child (Munda), the dead (Kondh) and health/spirit (Adi).
  • Bilingualism and translation.
  • Literary Devices & Style

  • Devy's essay uses argument, contrast (tribal vs. secular imagination) and striking images ("oceans fly in the sky as birds").
  • The songs use repetition and parallelism (Munda), direct address/apostrophe (Kondh to the spirit, Adi to the beloved/spirit), and symbols (sun/moon, cowshed; Ridin creeper; cock's footprint).
  • Word Power

  • marginalisation — pushing to the edges of society (हाशियाकरण)
  • canonized — accepted as standard/authoritative (मान्य)
  • repository — store (भंडार)
  • cohesive — closely united (संगठित)
  • itinerant — travelling from place to place (घुमंतू)
  • hallucinatory — dreamlike (स्वप्न-सदृश)
  • subverting — undermining, turning around (उलटना)
  • bilingual — using two languages (द्विभाषी)
  • propitiate — win favour of a spirit (प्रसन्न करना)
  • insurrection — uprising (विद्रोह)
  • Exam Focus

    Q. What distinguishes the tribal imagination from the secular imagination?

    Outline: secular — creator replaces God, self-conscious; tribal — dreamlike, hallucinatory, fuses planes of existence and time, links emotion with motif, based on memory; sacred space, personal time.

    Q. How does the Munda song show a different attitude to the girl child?

    Outline: daughter linked with the moon and a cowshed that fills — prosperity; son linked with depletion; women dominant in Munda economic and ritual life.

    Q. How does the Kondh song reflect the urge to dominate time?

    Outline: the living converse with the dead through ritual song and offerings — relationship with ancestors continues across time.

    Common Mistakes

  • Saying the son is valued more in the Munda song — it is the daughter.
  • Mixing up Adi Agom (conversation) and Miri Agom (ritual chanting).
  • Thinking Devy rejects written literature — he accepts it but wants literature redefined to include orality.
  • Assuming tribal arts have no rules — convention is a strict ordering principle.
  • 💡 Key Learning Points

    • ✓Devy argues that literature must include oral tradition, or India's tribal literatures will decline.
    • ✓Tribal imagination is dreamlike, based on memory, and gives time more importance than space.
    • ✓Tribal arts have flexible frames, playful tone and strict convention, and are not made for sale.
    • ✓The Munda song values the daughter; the Kondh song asks the dead spirit to leave; the Adi chant calls back lost health.
    • ✓Most tribal communities are bilingual, and the Adi use a special ritual language, Miri Agom.

    👨‍🏫 Teaching Tips

    • →Begin by asking students to recall songs sung at births, weddings or deaths in their own families — oral literature they already know.
    • →Make a two-column chart contrasting tribal and secular/modern imagination using Devy's phrases.
    • →Read the Munda song aloud and map its symbols (sun–son–empty cowshed; moon–daughter–full cowshed) on the board.
    • →Discuss translation: what might be lost when a Mundari song becomes English?
    • →Use a map of India to locate the Munda, Kondh and Adi communities from the notes.
    • →Organise a mini-project to record an oral song or story from a grandparent and translate it.
    • →Debate: 'Tribal arts are not meant for sale — does this help or hamper their preservation?'

    📋 Assessment Questions

    1. Can the student state Devy's argument about literature and orality?
    2. Can the student list distinctive features of tribal arts?
    3. Can the student interpret the symbols of the Munda song and the purpose of the Kondh and Adi songs?
    4. Can the student explain the tribal sense of time over space with the ancestor example?
    5. Can the student explain the two Adi languages and what they show about language sensitivity?

    👩‍🏫 Class 11 English classes near you — online or at home

    Prefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India and visit homes in selected cities. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.

    • Live online classesSmall groups or 1:1 with a teacher, from home, any city.
    • Teacher at homeA TalentJR teacher visits your home (selected cities).
    • At a centreClasses at a TalentJR partner centre near you, where available.