TalentJR apps
Textbook: English Yuvakbharati – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 87–90
A witty satirical poem by the 18th-century English poet William Cowper. The Nose and the Eyes go to court to decide who owns a pair of spectacles; Tongue argues as the lawyer and Chief Baron Ear is the judge. The verdict is absurd — and that is the point. Story in simple words, satire on the legal system, personification, inversion, irony, rhyme scheme, legal terms, idioms of the senses, a model appreciation and answers to every activity.
A strange quarrel breaks out between the Nose and the Eyes over a pair of spectacles: which of them should own them?
The case goes to court. Tongue is the lawyer, clever and wearing a learned wig; Ear, famous for careful judgement, is the Chief Baron (judge).
Tongue argues for the Nose: the Nose has always worn the spectacles, which means possession since time immemorial; their bridge is shaped exactly to sit on the ridge of the Nose like a saddle; and if a face had no nose, nobody could wear spectacles at all. So the spectacles and the Nose were made for each other.
Then, as lawyers do, Tongue switches sides and argues for the Eyes — but nobody remembers what he said, because the court did not think those arguments as clever.
The judge gives a solemn, firm verdict with no 'ifs' or 'buts': whenever the Nose wears the spectacles, by day or by candlelight, the Eyes must be shut — a ridiculous ruling that defeats the whole purpose of spectacles.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nose versus Eyes” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Justify (or criticise) the verdict delivered in the poem.
Answer: From the court's point of view the verdict follows the arguments heard: (a) the Nose had always held the spectacles, so it had possession; (b) their shape fits the Nose perfectly; (c) without a nose, spectacles could not be worn at all. But by common sense the verdict is absurd: spectacles are useless with the Eyes shut, since their real purpose is to help the Eyes see. Cowper uses this ridiculous decree to mock courts that follow technical logic and ignore real justice.
Pick out an example of inversion and rewrite it in normal order.
Answer: 'Between Nose and Eyes … arose' → A strange contest arose between Nose and Eyes. (Also: 'his arguments few people know' → few people know what his arguments were.)
| Word / phrase | Meaning | In the lesson |
|---|---|---|
| dispute | a disagreement or quarrel | Over the spectacles |
| spectacles | glasses for clear vision | The object of the case |
| wig | artificial hair worn by judges and lawyers | Tongue's 'wig full of learning' |
| Baron | a powerful noble; here, a judge's title | Chief Baron Ear |
| discerning | showing good judgement | Ear's famous talent |
| time out of mind | for longer than anyone remembers | The Nose's possession |
| straddle | the part that stretches across | The bridge of the spectacles |
| saddle | a seat on a horse | How the spectacles sit on the nose |
| visage / countenance | the face | A face without a nose |
| condemn | express disapproval of | The court will never reject the reasoning |
| decreed | officially ordered | The judge's verdict |
| solemn | serious and formal | The judge's tone |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Ice Breaker: Complete the table of legal terms with their descriptions.
Answer: Affidavit — a written statement confirmed on oath, used as evidence. Argument — reasons presented by a lawyer to support a case. Consent — permission or agreement. Counsel — a lawyer who advises and pleads in court. Judgement — the court's decision with reasons. Trial — the formal hearing of a case in court. Verdict — the final decision on the issue, e.g. guilty or not guilty. Contempt of Court — disobeying or showing disrespect to a court. Notice — a formal written information or warning. Stay order — a court order that stops an action for a time.
2. Ice Breaker: Name the five sense organs with an idiom for each.
Answer: (a) Ear — to turn a deaf ear (ignore). (b) Eyes — to see eye to eye (agree); an eye-opener. (c) Nose — to poke one's nose into (interfere); to follow one's nose. (d) Tongue — to hold one's tongue (keep quiet); a slip of the tongue. (e) Skin — to have a thick skin (not easily hurt); to save one's skin.
3. A1 (i), (ii): True or false; match the expressions.
Answer: (i) (a) True — the Nose wears them. (b) True. (c) True — Ear is Chief Baron (judge). (d) False — according to the verdict the Eyes are shut whenever the spectacles are worn, but in reality spectacles are meant for the Eyes. (ii) 1 — (b) the hearing organ had to give the verdict; 2 — (c) spectacles are meant for none but the nose; 3 — (a) the Eyes are kept from using the spectacles; 4 — (d) the judge gave a firm verdict without any doubt.
4. A2 (i), (ii): Tongue's arguments for the Nose; a phrase on the Nose and the Eyes.
Answer: (i) (1) The Nose has always worn the spectacles — possession since time out of mind. (2) Their straddle matches the width of the Nose's ridge, built to sit on it like a saddle. (3) If a face had no nose, nobody could wear spectacles. (4) So the spectacles and the Nose were made for each other. (ii) Nose — the proud, possessive winner who holds the spectacles but cannot use them. Eyes — the true users, wronged by a court that never heard their case properly.
5. A2 (iii) and A3: Justify the Shakespearean advice about listening more and speaking less; pick out examples of inversion.
Answer: (iii) The advice means: listen to everyone but speak your mind to only a few. Listening helps us understand all sides and judge wisely, while careless talk can mislead or hurt. In the poem the Tongue talks cleverly and wins a foolish case; a truly wise Ear would have listened to both sides equally before judging. A3: 'Between Nose and Eyes … arose'; 'his arguments few people know'; 'So Tongue was the lawyer'.
6. A4 (ii), (iii): Compose two lines on a sense organ; defend the Eyes as their lawyer.
Answer: (ii) Sample: The ear hears whispers soft and low, / And tells the heart what it should know. (iii) Sample: My lord, the learned counsel speaks of possession, but the Nose merely holds the spectacles; it is the Eyes that use them. Spectacles are made with lenses, not with nostrils — their only purpose is to help the Eyes see clearly. The Nose is just a stand, as a table holds a lamp without owning its light. If the Eyes are shut, the spectacles are useless. A blind person with a nose does not need spectacles, but a person with poor eyes cannot do without them. I therefore pray that the court award the spectacles to the Eyes, and let the Nose continue to support them as a faithful servant.
7. A5 (i): Write an appreciation of the poem.
Answer: Sample: 'Nose versus Eyes' is a humorous satire by the 18th-century English poet William Cowper, who had studied law. The title, written like the name of a court case, tells us at once that there is a legal battle. Theme: the Nose and Eyes go to court over a pair of spectacles; lawyer Tongue argues cleverly for the Nose; Judge Ear rules that the Eyes must be shut whenever the Nose wears them. The poem mocks a legal system that values clever words over common sense. Style: six quatrains rhyming abab with a lively, galloping rhythm and mock-serious legal language. Devices: personification of body parts, inversion ('Between Nose and Eyes … arose'), simile (like a saddle), a rhetorical question, alliteration and irony. Special feature: each organ gets a fitting role — the Tongue speaks, the Ear hears. Message: justice needs fairness, empathy and common sense. I enjoyed the poem because it makes us laugh while making a serious point.
8. A5 (ii): Write a summary of the poem.
Answer: Sample — Nose versus Eyes: This is a light-hearted satirical poem by William Cowper. The Nose and the Eyes quarrel over a pair of spectacles and take the matter to court, where the Tongue is the lawyer and the Ear the judge. The Tongue argues that the Nose has always worn the spectacles, that they fit it like a saddle and that without a nose nobody could wear them. His arguments for the Eyes are ignored. The judge solemnly orders that whenever the Nose wears the spectacles, the Eyes must be shut. Through this absurd verdict the poet laughs at courts that lack common sense.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. 'Nose versus Eyes' was written by…
Answer: B. An 18th-century English poet.
2. The dispute is over…
Answer: C. Who should own them.
3. Who acts as the lawyer?
Answer: C. The tongue speaks.
4. Who is the judge?
Answer: B. Famous for discerning judgement.
5. 'Possession time out of mind' means…
Answer: D. The Nose has always worn them.
6. The spectacles are said to fit the nose like a…
Answer: D. A simile.
7. The final verdict is that…
Answer: C. An absurd ruling.
8. Why is the verdict ironic?
Answer: C. It defeats their purpose.
9. The poem is mainly a…
Answer: C. It mocks blind justice.
10. 'Between Nose and Eyes … arose' shows…
Answer: C. Unusual word order.
11. Giving Nose, Eyes, Tongue and Ear human roles is…
Answer: D. Body parts act like people.
12. 'Countenance' means…
Answer: D. Visage or countenance — the face.
13. The rhyme scheme of each stanza is…
Answer: B. e.g. arose/knows, wrong/belong.
14. What does Tongue do after arguing for the Nose?
Answer: D. Lawyers can switch sides.
15. A 'verdict' is…
Answer: C. Here, the Eyes must be shut.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nose versus Eyes” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Nose versus Eyes the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 25 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nose versus Eyes” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Nose versus Eyes.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Nose Versus Eyes” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.