TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 1–11
What exactly does a logician study, and how is a 'valid' argument different from a 'true' statement? This chapter traces where logic began (India, Greece, China), gives Copi's definition, explains argument, premise, conclusion, form and content, and sets deductive arguments against inductive ones — with every exercise answered.
Logic grew up independently in three ancient traditions — India (Nyaya, plus Jaina and Buddhist logic), Greece (Aristotle, called the father of logic) and China (Mozi and the Mohist school). Aristotle's system, also called traditional logic, shaped the rest of the world; after a long decline it was revived in the nineteenth century and turned into modern symbolic logic with help from thinkers such as Boole, De Morgan, Frege and Russell.
The word logic comes from the Greek 'logos' (thought), so it was once defined as the 'science of laws of thought'. That definition is too wide: thinking includes remembering, imagining and day-dreaming, and the process of thinking belongs to psychology. Calling logic 'the science of reasoning' is also too wide. The accepted definition is I.M. Copi's: logic studies the methods and principles we use for telling good (correct) reasoning from bad (incorrect) reasoning.
An argument is a set of propositions where one (the conclusion) is supported by the others (the premises). Every argument has content (what it is about) and form (its pattern). Propositions are true or false; arguments are valid or invalid — never the other way round.
A deductive argument claims that its premises give sufficient evidence. If it is valid, the premises imply the conclusion, so true premises guarantee a true conclusion; the conclusion is certain, adds nothing new and validity depends only on form (formal validity). A valid deductive argument with true premises is called sound.
An inductive argument's premises give only some evidence, the conclusion goes beyond them and is always probable. Its worth depends on content (material validity) and is judged as good or bad, better or worse, by experience and experts rather than by rules of logic — but induction is what adds new knowledge about the world.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nature of Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Pick out the premises and conclusion: 'Every mango tree in this orchard is grafted. This tree is a mango tree in this orchard. So this tree is grafted.'
Answer: Premises: 'Every mango tree in this orchard is grafted' and 'This tree is a mango tree in this orchard'. Conclusion: 'This tree is grafted'.
Write the form of: 'All poets are sensitive. All sensitive people are kind. Therefore all poets are kind.'
Answer: All X are Y; all Y are Z; so all X are Z. Any argument that fits this pattern is valid, whatever X, Y and Z stand for.
Classify: (a) 'Either the shop is open or it is Monday. It is not Monday. So the shop is open.' (b) 'The last six monsoons brought floods to this village, so this monsoon will too.'
Answer: (a) Deductive (and valid — it is a Disjunctive Syllogism). (b) Inductive — its conclusion is only probable.
| Point of comparison | Deductive argument | Inductive argument |
|---|---|---|
| Evidence given | Claims to be sufficient | Gives only some evidence |
| Premises and conclusion | Valid ones: premises imply the conclusion | Premises never imply the conclusion |
| True premises | Valid ones: conclusion must be true | Conclusion may still be false |
| Nature of conclusion | Certain | Probable |
| Goes beyond premises? | No — implicit in premises | Yes — says something new |
| Kind of validity | Formal (decided by form) | Material (decided by content) |
| How judged | By rules and methods of logic | By experience and experts |
| New knowledge? | No — only what the premises imply | Yes — expands knowledge of the world |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (15 items: father of logic; logic that influenced the world; author of the Nyaya Sutras; proposition established; proposition stated in support; pattern of an argument; what is valid or invalid; deductive evidence; inductive evidence; valid ___ argument with true premises; material validity depends on; deductive conclusion is; validity decided by rules; correctness decided by experience; conclusion that does not go beyond premises).
Answer: 1 Aristotle. 2 Aristotelian. 3 Gautama. 4 Conclusion. 5 Premise. 6 Form. 7 Argument. 8 Sufficient. 9 Some. 10 Deductive. 11 Content. 12 Certain. 13 Deductive. 14 Inductive. 15 Deductive.
2. Q.2 True or false (15 statements).
Answer: 1 False — logic is a branch of philosophy, not psychology. 2 True. 3 False — the Nyaya School represents Indian logic; Jaina logic is a separate strand of Indian logic. 4 True. 5 True. 6 True. 7 False — an argument is valid or invalid; propositions are true or false. 8 True. 9 True. 10 False — formal validity is decided by form; content decides material validity. 11 False — an inductive conclusion is always probable. 12 True. 13 False — if a valid deductive argument has true premises, its conclusion must be true. 14 True. 15 True.
3. Q.3 Match the columns: Nyaya, Aristotle, Mohist school, Nagarjun, Argument, Statement, Deductive argument, Inductive argument — with: sufficient evidence, Mozi 'Master Mo', some evidence, valid or invalid, Greek logician, Buddhist philosopher, Akshapad Gautama, true or false.
Answer: Nyaya — Akshapad Gautama; Aristotle — Greek logician; Mohist school — Mozi 'Master Mo'; Nagarjun — Buddhist philosopher; Argument — valid or invalid; Statement — true or false; Deductive argument — sufficient evidence; Inductive argument — some evidence.
4. Q.4 Give logical terms: (1) study of methods and principles to tell good from bad reasoning (2) proposition stated in support of the conclusion (3) proposition established (4) argument claiming sufficient evidence (5) argument giving some evidence (6) argument whose validity is fixed by its form (7) argument whose validity is fixed by its content.
Answer: (1) Logic. (2) Premise. (3) Conclusion. (4) Deductive argument. (5) Inductive argument. (6) Formally valid (deductive) argument. (7) Materially valid (inductive) argument.
5. Q.5 Give reasons: (1) The etymological definition of logic is not accurate. (2) Deductive arguments cannot expand our knowledge. (3) A valid deductive argument always has a certain conclusion. (4) An inductive argument always has a probable conclusion.
Answer: (1) It is too wide: it hints that logic studies the thinking process (really psychology's subject), and 'thought' includes memory, imagination and day-dreaming, whereas logic deals only with reasoning. (2) A deductive conclusion is already contained in the premises; deduction only brings out what is implied, so nothing new about the world is learnt. (3) In a valid deductive argument the premises imply the conclusion; if they are true it cannot be false. (4) Its premises give only some evidence and the conclusion goes beyond them, so even with true premises the conclusion might turn out false.
6. Q.6 Explain: (1) Truth and validity (2) Form of argument (3) Form vs content (4) Formal vs material validity (5) Deductive vs inductive argument.
Answer: (1) Truth belongs to propositions (agreement with facts); validity belongs to arguments (whether the conclusion follows). They are independent: 'All fish fly; all flying things are green; so all fish are green' is valid with false parts, while 'If it is Diwali schools are shut; schools are shut; so it is Diwali' is invalid even when every part happens to be true. (2) Form is the skeleton of an argument, e.g. All A is B; X is A; so X is B. (3) Form is the pattern, content the subject; like pots of one shape in clay or silver, arguments can share form with different content and vice versa. (4) Formal validity depends only on form and is judged by rules of logic (deduction); material validity depends on the content and evidence and is judged by experience (induction). (5) Use the comparison table: sufficient vs some evidence, implied vs not implied, certain vs probable, no new knowledge vs new knowledge, formal vs material, rules of logic vs experience.
7. Q.7 Answer: (1) Origin and development of logic (2) Short note on Indian logic (3) Define logic; explain argument, premise, conclusion (4) Reasoning, inference and argument (5) Nature of deductive argument (6) Nature of inductive argument.
Answer: (1) Logic arose separately in India, Greece and China. Aristotle systematised it in Greece and his traditional logic spread worldwide, peaked in the 14th century, declined, and was revived in the 19th century; with mathematics and thinkers like Boole, Frege and Russell it became modern symbolic logic, a formal science. China's logic came from Mozi but faded under the Qin. (2) Indian logic is represented by Nyaya, whose core texts are Akshapada Gautama's Nyaya Sutras; Anviksiki and Tarka are mentioned in the Mahabharata and the Arthashastra; Panini's grammar has Boolean-like logic; Jaina logic (6th c. BCE–17th c. CE) and Buddhist logic (c. 500–1300 CE: Nagarjuna, Vasubandhu, Dignaga, Dharmakirti) also belong to it. (3) Copi's definition; an argument is a group of propositions where one is proved from the rest; e.g. 'All metals conduct heat; copper is a metal; so copper conducts heat' — the first two are premises, the last the conclusion. (4) Reasoning is thinking in which inference occurs; inference is the mental passage from evidence to conclusion; an argument is the verbal statement of an inference. The book treats the three as synonyms. (5) and (6): use the deductive/inductive notes and table with an example each.
8. Q.8 Deductive or inductive? 1 bank holiday or open 2 no good players 3 sister's biryani 4 aunty a female doctor 5 Mohan and computer science 6 Meena, Seema, Neena 7 Sunil is smart 8 Nikita will leave 9 Mukesh handsome actor 10 college to good marks 11 Amit and Sumit singers 12 World Bank loan 13 re-examination 14 Suresh taller 15 Mr. Joshi.
Answer: Deductive: 1, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 13, 14. Inductive: 2, 3, 6, 8, 11, 12, 15. (1 disjunctive reasoning; 4 'aunty' already means a female; 5 if–then with the antecedent affirmed; 7 picks one part of a conjunction; 9 joins two given facts; 10 chain of if–then; 13 'if and only if' allows reasoning both ways; 14 'taller than' carries over. 6 is a generalisation, 11 an analogy, 3 and 15 predictions from past cases.)
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. Who is honoured as the father of logic?
Answer: B. Aristotle began logic as a systematic study.
2. Indian logic is represented by the…
Answer: D. Nyaya; its core texts are Gautama's Nyaya Sutras.
3. The Mohist School was founded by…
Answer: C. Mozi, 'Master Mo', was a contemporary of Confucius.
4. The thinking process as such is studied in…
Answer: D. That is why the etymological definition is faulty.
5. According to Copi, logic studies the methods and principles we use to…
Answer: D. It stresses the practical side of logic.
6. The proposition an argument sets out to establish is the…
Answer: D. Premises support; the conclusion is supported.
7. The pattern or structure of an argument is its…
Answer: B. Content is the subject matter.
8. Which of these can be valid or invalid?
Answer: B. Propositions are only true or false.
9. Premises of a deductive argument claim to give…
Answer: C. Inductive premises give some evidence.
10. An inductive argument's conclusion is always…
Answer: D. It goes beyond the evidence.
11. A valid deductive argument with true premises and conclusion is called…
Answer: C. Soundness = validity + truth.
12. Validity decided entirely by content is called…
Answer: D. Inductive arguments are materially valid.
13. Which type of argument gives new knowledge about the world?
Answer: A. Deduction only makes explicit what the premises imply.
14. 'All birds lay eggs; a crow is a bird; so a crow lays eggs.' This argument is…
Answer: A. The conclusion does not go beyond the premises.
15. The correctness of inductive arguments is judged by…
Answer: D. Deductive validity is judged by rules and methods of logic.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nature of Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Nature of Logic the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 35 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Nature of Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Nature of Logic.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Nature of Logic” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.