The Method of DeductionClass 11 Logic Chapter 4 Notes – Maharashtra Board

Textbook: Logic – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 46–63

A truth table can test any argument, but with many letters it grows huge. The method of deduction proves validity step by step, like a chain where every link is a rule. Learn what deductive (direct) proof is, the nine rules of inference (M.P., M.T., H.S., D.S., C.D., D.D., Simp., Conj., Add.), the ten rules of replacement (De M., Com., Assoc., Dist., D.N., Trans., Impl., Equiv., Exp., Taut.), and see all 60 proofs from Q.10 and Q.11 written out with the rule at every step.

🎧 Listen to the summary

Summary: The Method of Deduction

Logicians use two kinds of method: decision procedures (like the truth table) and methods that are not decision procedures. Deductive proof belongs to the second kind: it is reliable and finite but not mechanical, because choosing which rule to apply needs intelligence. It proves that a valid argument is valid (or that a form is a tautology); it cannot show that an argument is invalid.

Deductive proof has three types — direct, conditional and indirect. Direct proof derives the conclusion straight from the premises through a chain of elementary valid arguments, without making any assumption. Conditional and indirect proof can also prove tautologies.

A formal proof is written by numbering the premises, writing the conclusion after a slash on the last premise line, and then adding new numbered lines, each with its justification on the right: the line numbers used and the rule applied. Use one rule per line. When the conclusion appears, the proof is complete.

The first nine rules are rules of inference — elementary valid argument forms: Modus Ponens, Modus Tollens, Hypothetical Syllogism, Disjunctive Syllogism, Constructive Dilemma, Destructive Dilemma, Simplification, Conjunction and Addition. They apply only to whole lines.

Because the nine rules are not enough (for example to get D from A • D), the rule of replacement (principle of extensionality) is added: any expression may be replaced by a logically equivalent one. It gives ten more rules — De Morgan, Commutation, Association, Distribution, Double Negation, Transposition, Material Implication, Material Equivalence, Exportation and Tautology — which work both ways and may be used on part of a line.

Key points to remember

  • Deductive proof: reliable and finite but NOT mechanical, so not a decision procedure
  • Three types: direct, conditional, indirect; this chapter = direct proof
  • Direct proof proves validity of arguments only; it makes no assumption
  • Each new line = statement + line numbers + rule; one rule per line
  • Nine rules of inference: M.P., M.T., H.S., D.S., C.D., D.D., Simp., Conj., Add.
  • Rules of inference apply to whole lines only
  • Ten replacement rules: De M., Com., Assoc., Dist., D.N., Trans., Impl., Equiv., Exp., Taut.
  • Replacement rules work both ways and on part of a line (principle of extensionality)
  • Simp. gives only the FIRST conjunct — use Com. first to get the second
  • D.S. needs the denial of the FIRST disjunct — use Com. if the wrong one is denied
Want a teacher to explain The Method of Deduction?

Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “The Method of Deduction” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.

Get a tutor for this chapter →

👩‍🏫 Class 11 Logic classes — live online, request a call back

Prefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.

Live online classesSmall groups or 1:1 with a teacher, from home, any city.
We call you backOur team asks what your child needs, then shares timings and fees.
Home tutor?We are still building our list of home tutors — ask on the call if there is one near you.

Keep learning