FallaciesClass 11 Logic Chapter 6 Notes – Maharashtra Board

Textbook: Logic – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 72–83

Some arguments sound convincing but fall apart when examined — these are fallacies. Learn what a fallacy is, why studying fallacies helps, formal vs non-formal fallacies, and Copi's non-formal fallacies: division, composition, accident, converse accident, the six kinds of irrelevant conclusion (ad Baculum, ad Hominem, ad Populum, ad Verecundiam, ad Misericordiam, ad Ignorantiam) and begging the question (hysteron proteron, arguing in circles) — with all 28 arguments of Q.6 identified and explained.

🎧 Listen to the summary

Summary: Fallacies

A fallacy is any error in reasoning: the premises fail to support the conclusion. Copi describes fallacious arguments as ones that look correct but turn out, on examination, not to be. Studying fallacies helps us spot and understand bad reasoning, come closer to the truth, avoid errors in our own arguments and avoid being misled by others. Since fallacies are countless, no complete classification is possible.

Formal fallacies concern the structure of an argument: a rule of deductive logic is broken (e.g. affirming the consequent: p ⊃ q, q ∴ p). Non-formal fallacies concern content and arise from misleading use of language: irrelevant conclusions, ambiguous words, confusing collective with distributive terms, and misusing rules in exceptional cases.

Division goes from the collective use of a term to its distributive use (class to member, whole to part); composition does the reverse (member to class, part to whole). Accident applies a general rule to a special case where it does not fit; converse accident turns a special or exceptional case into a general rule.

Ignoratio elenchi (irrelevant conclusion) is a group of fallacies whose premises are beside the point: appeal to force or fear (ad Baculum, 'might is right'), personal attack (ad Hominem), emotional appeal to people (ad Populum), appeal to improper authority (ad Verecundiam), appeal to pity (ad Misericordiam) and appeal to ignorance (ad Ignorantiam — not treated as fallacious in a court of law, where a person is innocent until proved guilty).

Petitio principii (begging the question) is a fallacy of proof: the very thing to be proved is assumed. In hysteron proteron the premise directly repeats the conclusion in synonyms ('the cloth is transparent because we can see through it'); in arguing in circles the premise depends on the conclusion, so the argument goes round: P because Q, and Q because P.

Key points to remember

  • Fallacy = an error in reasoning; Copi: arguments that seem correct but prove not to be
  • Formal fallacy: violates a rule of logic (structure); non-formal: misleading language (content)
  • Collective use = members taken together; distributive use = each member separately
  • Division: whole → part, class → member; Composition: part → whole, member → class
  • Accident: general rule wrongly applied to a special case
  • Converse accident: special case wrongly turned into a general rule
  • Ad Baculum = force/fear; ad Hominem = against the man; ad Populum = emotions of people
  • Ad Verecundiam = improper authority; ad Misericordiam = pity; ad Ignorantiam = ignorance
  • Petitio principii = begging the question: the conclusion is assumed
  • Hysteron proteron: direct assumption by synonym; arguing in circles: P because Q, Q because P
Want a teacher to explain Fallacies?

Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Fallacies” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.

Get a tutor for this chapter →

👩‍🏫 Class 11 Logic classes — live online, request a call back

Prefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.

Live online classesSmall groups or 1:1 with a teacher, from home, any city.
We call you backOur team asks what your child needs, then shares timings and fees.
Home tutor?We are still building our list of home tutors — ask on the call if there is one near you.

Keep learning