TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 72–83
Some arguments sound convincing but fall apart when examined — these are fallacies. Learn what a fallacy is, why studying fallacies helps, formal vs non-formal fallacies, and Copi's non-formal fallacies: division, composition, accident, converse accident, the six kinds of irrelevant conclusion (ad Baculum, ad Hominem, ad Populum, ad Verecundiam, ad Misericordiam, ad Ignorantiam) and begging the question (hysteron proteron, arguing in circles) — with all 28 arguments of Q.6 identified and explained.
A fallacy is any error in reasoning: the premises fail to support the conclusion. Copi describes fallacious arguments as ones that look correct but turn out, on examination, not to be. Studying fallacies helps us spot and understand bad reasoning, come closer to the truth, avoid errors in our own arguments and avoid being misled by others. Since fallacies are countless, no complete classification is possible.
Formal fallacies concern the structure of an argument: a rule of deductive logic is broken (e.g. affirming the consequent: p ⊃ q, q ∴ p). Non-formal fallacies concern content and arise from misleading use of language: irrelevant conclusions, ambiguous words, confusing collective with distributive terms, and misusing rules in exceptional cases.
Division goes from the collective use of a term to its distributive use (class to member, whole to part); composition does the reverse (member to class, part to whole). Accident applies a general rule to a special case where it does not fit; converse accident turns a special or exceptional case into a general rule.
Ignoratio elenchi (irrelevant conclusion) is a group of fallacies whose premises are beside the point: appeal to force or fear (ad Baculum, 'might is right'), personal attack (ad Hominem), emotional appeal to people (ad Populum), appeal to improper authority (ad Verecundiam), appeal to pity (ad Misericordiam) and appeal to ignorance (ad Ignorantiam — not treated as fallacious in a court of law, where a person is innocent until proved guilty).
Petitio principii (begging the question) is a fallacy of proof: the very thing to be proved is assumed. In hysteron proteron the premise directly repeats the conclusion in synonyms ('the cloth is transparent because we can see through it'); in arguing in circles the premise depends on the conclusion, so the argument goes round: P because Q, and Q because P.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Fallacies” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Name the fallacy: 'Each ingredient — chocolate, pickle and curd — tastes good, so a dish made by mixing them will taste good.'
Answer: Fallacy of composition (part to whole): a quality of each part on its own need not belong to the whole.
Name the fallacy: 'You say junk food is unhealthy, but you ate a burger yesterday, so your point is worthless.'
Answer: Argumentum ad Hominem — a personal attack on the opponent's conduct in place of reasons.
Name the fallacy: 'This medicine is effective because it works.'
Answer: Hysteron proteron (begging the question by synonym) — the premise simply restates the conclusion.
| Fallacy | What goes wrong | Your own example |
|---|---|---|
| Division | Collective → distributive (whole to part, class to member) | The orchestra is loud, so each violin is loud. |
| Composition | Distributive → collective (part to whole, member to class) | Each page is thin, so the dictionary is thin. |
| Accident | General rule applied to an exception | Keep promises, so return a sword to a friend who is now enraged. |
| Converse accident | Exception turned into a general rule | Doctors may prescribe strong drugs, so anyone may. |
| Ad Baculum | Threat, force or fear instead of reasons | Sign this or lose your job. |
| Ad Hominem | Attack on the person, not the argument | Don't trust his maths answer; he failed English. |
| Ad Populum | Appeal to people's emotions | Every loyal fan buys the official jersey. |
| Ad Verecundiam | Improper authority quoted | A film star says this insurance plan is best. |
| Ad Misericordiam | Appeal to pity | Give me marks; I worked so hard. |
| Ad Ignorantiam | Not disproved, so true (or not proved, so false) | No one proved ghosts don't exist, so they do. |
| Hysteron proteron | Premise restates conclusion in synonyms | Opium causes sleep because it is sleep-inducing. |
| Arguing in circles | P because Q, and Q because P | She is popular because many like her; many like her because she is popular. |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (10) and Q.2 True or false (10).
Answer: Q.1: 1 Accident. 2 Formal. 3 Misericordiam. 4 Baculum. 5 Division. 6 Arguing in Circles. 7 Improper authority. 8 Distributive use of term to collective use. 9 Ignoratiam (ignorantiam). 10 Hysteron Proteron. Q.2: 1 True. 2 True. 3 False — that is composition; converse accident turns a special case into a general rule. 4 False — 'tu quoque' is linked with ad Hominem, not ad Populum. 5 False — ad Misericordiam appeals to pity; threat is ad Baculum. 6 False — an irrelevant conclusion is a non-formal fallacy; formal fallacies break rules of logic. 7 True. 8 True. 9 False — that describes ad Misericordiam. 10 True.
2. Q.3 Match the columns and Q.4 Give logical terms (10).
Answer: Q.3: Ignoratio Elenchi — irrelevant conclusion; Petitio Principii — begging the question; Argument ad Hominem — appeal directed against the man; Argument ad Populum — emotional appeal to people. Q.4: 1 Fallacy. 2 Non-formal fallacy. 3 Formal fallacy. 4 Fallacy of composition. 5 Converse fallacy of accident. 6 Ignoratio elenchi. 7 Argumentum ad Baculum. 8 Argumentum ad Hominem. 9 Argumentum ad Misericordiam. 10 Argumentum ad Verecundiam.
3. Q.5 Explain the ten fallacies: division, composition, accident, converse accident, ad Baculum, ad Hominem, ad Verecundiam, ad Ignorantiam, ad Populum, petitio principii.
Answer: Division: what holds of a class or whole is wrongly said of each member or part ('the crowd was huge, so each person in it was huge'). Composition: what holds of each member or part is wrongly said of the whole ('every musician is skilled, so the band is skilled'). Accident: a sound general rule applied where an exception exists ('do not cut people, so surgeons must not operate'). Converse accident: an exception turned into a rule ('a diabetic may skip fasting, so everyone may'). Ad Baculum: force or fear replaces reasons; 'might is right'. Ad Hominem: attack on the person's conduct or character instead of the argument. Ad Verecundiam: an authority who has no expertise on the matter is quoted. Ad Ignorantiam: lack of proof treated as proof (not fallacious in court). Ad Populum: emotions and popularity replace evidence. Petitio principii: the conclusion is assumed — by synonym (hysteron proteron) or by a circle (arguing in circles).
4. Q.6 (1–10) Recognise the fallacy with reasons.
Answer: (1) Ad Baculum — a threat to make the listener vote. (2) Division — the colour of the whole ball is wrongly given to each atom. (3) Ad Hominem — Ravi's truthfulness is attacked through his brother's conduct. (4) Accident — a moral rule is applied to an ordinary paid service that does not violate it. (5) Arguing in circles — interesting because read by many, read by many because interesting. (6) Ad Verecundiam — a cricketer is no authority on democracy. (7) Ad Misericordiam — pity for the family replaces reasons about the job. (8) Hysteron proteron — 'humiliating' and 'degrading' mean the same. (9) Converse accident — a concession for a sick student is made a rule for all. (10) Hysteron proteron — 'authentic' and 'factual' are near-synonyms, so the premise repeats the conclusion.
5. Q.6 (11–20) Recognise the fallacy with reasons.
Answer: (11) Division — the union's collective vote is wrongly passed to each member. (12) Ad Hominem — his family life is attacked instead of judging his ministerial ability. (13) Ad Populum — long popularity with people is offered instead of evidence of quality. (14) Ad Ignorantiam — no one opposed it, so it is assumed correct. (15) Ad Misericordiam — pity, not the quality of the answers, is used to seek marks. (16) Accident — the general right of self-defence is applied to a surgery done for the patient's good. (17) Ad Baculum — the threat of not speaking forces agreement. (18) Hysteron proteron — 'eternal' and 'never dies' mean the same. (19) Ad Verecundiam — an actor is not an authority on election results. (20) Converse accident — killing permitted in the special case of war is turned into a general permission.
6. Q.6 (21–28) Recognise the fallacy with reasons.
Answer: (21) Composition — attentiveness of each student is wrongly given to the class as a whole. (22) Ad Ignorantiam — no proof of life after death is taken as proof that there is none. (23) Converse accident — some accidents by young drivers are made a rule against all young drivers. (24) Division — what is true of the compound (salt is safe) is wrongly said of its elements (sodium and chlorine are harmful alone). (25) Ad Hominem — the accuser's own guilt does not disprove the charge. (26) Ad Misericordiam — the man's disability is used to arouse pity, not to answer the charge. (27) Ad Baculum — threat of dismissal. (28) As printed (artists are moody, Hemant is one, so he is moody) the reasoning is a valid syllogism; it becomes the fallacy of division only if 'artists are moody' is meant collectively (artists as a group), not of each artist.
7. Activities 1–13: formal fallacy (G ⊃ K, K ∴ G); Anita's large building; Seeta, Geeta, Neeta of XI A; shedding blood and surgery; Mr. X's death and surgeons; 'Surrender or die'; copying accusation; married girl and sari; friend says the film is good; job and bed-ridden father; soul is immortal; Raju is insane; vicious circle of poverty.
Answer: Activity 1: the second argument (G ⊃ K, K ∴ G) commits a formal fallacy — affirming the consequent; p ⊃ q, p ∴ q is valid M.P. Activity 2: division — the size of the building is wrongly given to one flat. Activity 3: composition — three bright students do not make the whole class bright. Activity 4: accident — the rule against shedding blood does not cover surgery. Activity 5: converse accident — one death during an operation is made into a rule for all surgeons. Activity 6: ad Baculum — a threat replaces reasons. Activity 7: ad Hominem — the accuser's past conduct is attacked. Activity 8: ad Populum — tradition and feeling replace reasons. Activity 9: ad Verecundiam — a friend is not an authority on films. Activity 10: ad Misericordiam — pity replaces reasons. Activity 11: ad Ignorantiam — lack of proof of mortality is taken as proof of immortality. Activity 12: hysteron proteron — 'insane' and 'behaves like a mad man' mean the same. Activity 13: poverty → illiteracy → unemployment → poverty.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. A fallacy that breaks a rule of logic is called…
Answer: A. It concerns structure.
2. 'The team is strong, so each player is strong' commits…
Answer: A. Whole/class to part/member.
3. 'Each part is light, so the machine is light' commits…
Answer: D. Part to whole.
4. 'Lying is wrong, so a doctor must tell a dying patient every grim detail' commits…
Answer: D. General rule forced onto a special case.
5. 'An ambulance may break signals, so all vehicles may' commits…
Answer: C. Special case made into a rule.
6. 'Might is right' is the principle behind…
Answer: C. It uses force or fear.
7. Attacking an opponent's character instead of his reasons is…
Answer: C. Against the man.
8. 'A famous cricketer drinks this cola, so it is healthy' is…
Answer: D. A cricketer is no authority on nutrition.
9. A lawyer's plea to sympathise with a weeping client commits…
Answer: A. Appeal to pity.
10. 'No one has proved ghosts exist, so they don't' commits…
Answer: A. Lack of proof is not proof.
11. Ad Ignorantiam is not fallacious in…
Answer: D. Innocent until proved guilty.
12. 'The wind is invisible because we cannot see it' commits…
Answer: C. Same idea in synonyms.
13. 'P because Q, and Q because P' is the form of…
Answer: A. A vicious circle.
14. Ignoratio elenchi means…
Answer: A. The premises miss the point.
15. 'Married women must wear a sari — great-grandmothers always did' is mainly…
Answer: A. An emotional appeal to tradition and people's feelings.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Fallacies” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Fallacies the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 40 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Fallacies” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Fallacies.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Fallacies” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.