TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 1–16
Where did philosophy come from, how is it different from myth, religion, art and science, and why should anyone study it today? Learn the four ways humans answered their curiosity, the early Greek thinkers, the scope of philosophy, its main methods (analysis, dialogue, vada, khandana-mandana, doubt) and its definitions, with answers to every exercise.
Humans have always wondered about the world. Their curiosity was answered in several ways: mythology (stories of gods and superhuman beings, such as Indra and Vrutra or the Norse god Thor), religion (faith in a supernatural power), art (creating and enjoying beauty), and finally philosophy and science, which rest on human intellect and reason.
Once people noticed that events follow a fixed order and have causes inside this world, they began to look for the basic principle behind everything. The early Greek thinkers gave different answers: Thales said water, Anaximander the apeiron (the boundless), Anaximenes air, Pythagoras number, Heraclitus fire and Empedocles four elements.
Philosophy and science ask similar questions, but science adds observation, experiment and instruments to reason, while philosophy works with reason alone. Because philosophy first raised the questions that sciences later took up, it is called the mother of all sciences. Philosophy also studies values (how things ought to be), not only facts (how things are).
Philosophy's core is critical examination — testing an idea from many sides instead of accepting it blindly. Its methods include analysis of concepts, dialogue (Upanishads, Socrates, Plato), debate or vada (with jalpa and vitanda as its poor forms), khandana-mandana (purvapaksha → khandana → uttarapaksha → siddhanta), the dialectical method and Descartes' method of doubt.
The word philosophy comes from Greek philo (love) and sophia (wisdom); in India the word tattvajnana (knowledge of the basic principle) and darshana are used. Wisdom is more than intelligence or information — it includes moral awareness. Studying philosophy trains us to question, to avoid being misled, to respect other views and to live a good life.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
A science teacher explains why the sky looks blue, and you say 'What a beautiful sky!' Which part belongs to science and which to philosophy?
Answer: Scattering of sunlight making the sky blue is a fact, explained by science. Calling it beautiful is a value judgement; questions like 'What is beauty?' and 'Does beauty depend on the viewer?' are discussed in philosophy (aesthetics).
Analyse the concept 'friendship' in the philosophical way.
Answer: Friendship involves at least two people, mutual liking, trust, free choice (no one is forced) and caring for the other's good, not only one's own benefit. So a friend is someone we freely choose, trust, and wish well for its own sake — which separates friendship from mere acquaintance or business partnership.
| Thinker / method | Key idea | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Thales | Water is the first principle | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Anaximander | Apeiron — the boundless | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Anaximenes | Air | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Pythagoras | Number | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Heraclitus / Parmenides | Fire / Being | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Empedocles / Anaxagoras | Four elements / Nous (mind) | Pre-Socratic Greek |
| Socrates | Dialogue; unexamined life not worth living | Father of Western philosophy |
| Plato | Wrote philosophy as dialogues; philosophy begins in wonder | Disciple of Socrates |
| Uddalaka and Shwetaketu | Salt in water — the unseen essence | Chhandogya Upanishad |
| Vada / jalpa / vitanda | Truth-seeking debate / win-at-all-costs / only attacking | Ancient Indian debate |
| Khandana-mandana | Purvapaksha → khandana → uttarapaksha → siddhanta | Indian method of writing texts |
| René Descartes | Method of doubt; 'I think, therefore I am' | French, modern philosophy |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Fill in the blanks: (a) Fundamental principle according to Thales (air / water / number). (b) ___ and ___ are foundational to the sciences (experience, tales, intellect, faith). (c) Method used in both Indian and Western philosophy (khandana-mandana / dialogue / analysis). (d) Anaximenes' principle (apeiron / atom / air). (e) Objects of the same kind share a common ___ (particularity / principle / essence). (f) A competitive debate is called ___ (vada / jalpa / vitanda).
Answer: (a) Water. (b) Experience and intellect (reason). (c) Dialogue. (d) Air. (e) Essence. (f) Jalpa.
2. Take the odd one out: (a) dialogue, debate, analysis, evaluation (b) air, water, mountain, fire (c) shishya, vadi, prashnika, prativadi.
Answer: (a) Evaluation — the others are methods of philosophy. (b) Mountain — the others were proposed as fundamental principles (Anaximenes, Thales, Heraclitus). (c) Shishya — the others are participants in a vada.
3. Give the philosophical term: (a) refuting the opponent without giving one's own argument (b) forming a third view from the clash of two opposite views (c) the method that analyses concepts (d) what has moral awareness besides intelligence and knowledge.
Answer: (a) Vitanda. (b) Dialectical method. (c) Method of analysis. (d) Wisdom.
4. Distinguish between (a) philosophy and the sciences (b) vada and jalpa.
Answer: (a) Sciences use experience, observation, experiments and instruments along with reason; philosophy uses reason alone. Sciences study facts (what is) and each studies one part of the world; philosophy also studies values (what ought to be), knowledge itself and the whole of life, and even questions the assumptions of science. Scientific answers can be tested and settled; philosophical questions have no final answers. (b) Vada is an open-minded debate whose aim is truth; agreeing with the other side is not defeat and faulty points are withdrawn. Jalpa is a competitive debate whose aim is just to win against the opponent.
5. Complete the concept charts: (a) process of khandana-mandana (b) types of vada (c) participants in a vada.
Answer: (a) Purvapaksha (opponent's view) → khandana (its refutation) → uttarapaksha (author's view with reasons) → siddhanta (conclusion). (b) Vada (truth-seeking), jalpa (to win), vitanda (only refuting). (c) Vadi, prativadi, prashnika and sabhapati.
6. Write short notes: (a) characteristics of philosophy (b) method of analysis (c) method of dialogue.
Answer: (a) Philosophy studies life and the world as a whole; works by reason alone; deals with values as well as facts; asks what is, how we know and how to live; critically examines ideas and even the assumptions of science; has no final answers, so its search is endless; places the human being at the centre. (b) Analysis splits a concept into its parts and studies their relations, as a chemist analyses a compound — but it works on abstract ideas, so the mind is the laboratory. 'Man' can be analysed as a two-legged, rational and social being; 'democracy' leads to questions about 'people', 'government' and 'State'. Socrates used it for exact definitions, and twentieth-century analytical philosophers saw analysis as philosophy's only task. It clears confusion. (c) Dialogue is learning through questions and answers. In India the guru answered the shishya's questions — Uddalaka–Shwetaketu and Maitreyi–Yajnavalkya in the Upanishads, Milindapanha, Krishna–Arjuna in the Gita. Socrates questioned people on virtue and justice and led them from confusion to clarity; Plato wrote his works as dialogues. Collective thinking brings in many views and reduces personal bias.
7. Answer in 20–25 words: (a) What is philosophy? (b) What is the dialectical method? (c) What is essence? (d) What does wisdom consist of? (e) What does religion ask us to have faith in? (f) Characteristics of art? (g) How does man's curiosity express itself?
Answer: (a) Philosophy, the love of wisdom, is a reasoned, critical study of life and the world as a whole — what is, how we know it and how to live. (b) A method in which a third, more balanced view is developed out of the conflict between two opposite views. (c) Essence is the common nature shared by all things of one kind, e.g. tree-ness in every tree, grasped by intellect, not senses. (d) Wisdom consists of awareness of the situation and of morality; it guides right conduct, beyond mere intelligence and knowledge. (e) Religion asks us to trust a supernatural, otherworldly power and the persons believed to know its nature. (f) Art creates and enjoys beauty for its own sake, without concern for use or profit; it needs creativity and delights both artist and viewer. (g) Through mythology, religious thinking, philosophy, science and art.
8. Explain with examples: (a) Science uses various instruments to gain knowledge. (b) A critical attitude is the core of philosophising.
Answer: (a) Our senses are limited, so science extends them with instruments: a microscope shows microbes, a telescope or binoculars show far-off objects, and laboratory equipment lets scientists repeat experiments and check results. Observation and experiment with such tools mark the scientific method. (b) Philosophy does not accept any idea blindly; it questions its meaning, reasons and consequences. For example, before praising democracy a philosopher asks who 'the people' are, what 'government' means and whether majority rule is always just. Socrates questioned common beliefs about justice and courage, and Descartes doubted everything until he found what could not be doubted.
9. Long answers: (a) Describe the nature of philosophy using its definitions. (b) What are the methods of philosophy? Describe any two.
Answer: (a) Etymologically, philosophy means love of wisdom (Greek philo + sophia); wisdom is knowledge plus moral awareness. In India it is tattvajnana — knowledge of the basic principle behind all things — and each system is a darshana, a total vision of life. Plato said philosophy begins in wonder; Russell said it keeps wonder alive by making the familiar look unfamiliar — so philosophy starts from curiosity. Wittgenstein called it an activity of making thoughts logically clear — so it is a method, not just a set of beliefs. Marx said the point is to change the world, not only interpret it — so it guides action. Together they show philosophy as a reasoned, critical, all-round study of life that questions even science's assumptions and helps us live well. (b) Methods: analysis, dialogue, vada, khandana-mandana, dialectical method and method of doubt. Vada: in a vadasabha the vadi presents his view, the prativadi counters it and gives his own, prashnikas ask questions and the sabhapati presides; the more reasonable side wins, and the aim is truth, not victory (unlike jalpa and vitanda). Method of doubt: Descartes, facing the sceptics, doubted all he had learnt — even the world's existence — and found that the doubter's own existence cannot be doubted: 'I think, therefore I am'. This became a firm base for knowledge and shows that doubt is a healthy tool.
10. (c) Explain one concept — friendship, religion, society, beauty or faith — by the method of analysis. Also: write a dialogue on justice.
Answer: Sample (society): a society needs (1) a group of people, (2) lasting relations between them, (3) shared rules, customs and values, and (4) institutions such as family, school and government. A crowd at a bus stop is not a society because it lacks lasting relations and shared rules. Sample dialogue — Student: Justice means giving everyone the same. Teacher: Should a doctor give the same medicine to every patient? Student: No, each according to illness. Teacher: Then is justice always 'the same for all'? Student: Perhaps justice is giving each person what is due to them. Teacher: And who decides what is due? Student: It should be decided by fair rules, not by the strongest. Teacher: Good — now you see the question is deeper than it looked.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. According to Thales, the fundamental principle is…
Answer: D. Anaximenes chose air and Pythagoras number.
2. The two foundations of science are…
Answer: C. Science adds observation to reasoning.
3. Which method was used in both Indian and Western philosophy?
Answer: D. Upanishads in India; Socrates and Plato in Greece.
4. Objects of the same kind share a common…
Answer: C. E.g. tree-ness in all trees.
5. A debate held only to defeat the opponent is…
Answer: B. Vada seeks truth; vitanda only refutes.
6. Apeiron was the first principle of…
Answer: B. Apeiron means the boundless.
7. Philosophy is called the mother of all sciences because…
Answer: D. Sciences branched out from philosophical questions.
8. 'What is beauty?' is a question for…
Answer: A. Values are studied in philosophy.
9. The essence of the philosophical method is…
Answer: D. Ideas are tested, not simply accepted.
10. In khandana-mandana, the opponent's view stated first is the…
Answer: B. It is then refuted (khandana).
11. 'I think, therefore I am' was said by…
Answer: C. He reached it through the method of doubt.
12. The chairperson of a vadasabha was called…
Answer: C. Prashnikas were questioners from the audience.
13. The word 'sophia' means…
Answer: A. Philo means love.
14. 'Philosophers have only interpreted the world… the point is to change it' — said by…
Answer: D. Russell spoke of keeping wonder alive.
15. Which one is NOT among the four relationships philosophy studies?
Answer: B. The fourth is humans and any reality beyond the senses.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 40 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “What is Philosophy? Why Philosophy?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.