TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 61–70
How is philosophy related to science and technology today? Learn the two views on whether science can know all of reality, subjective, objective and intersubjective reality, the journey of science away from myth, technology as the processing of matter, simple versus complex technology, the costs and by-products of technology, Rachel Carson and environmental thinking, sustainable development, and what philosophy still has to do, with answers to every exercise.
Modern science has gone far in answering 'What is?' and is working on 'How do we know?', so philosophers ask what remains for philosophy. Materialists hold that only the material world exists and science alone can know it. Others hold that there may be a reality beyond the senses which science cannot study, and that philosophy should seek it and guide life by it. Either way, philosophy now tries to combine science's answers into an overall view of the world that includes values.
Science studies laws of objective reality — what anyone can verify with senses and instruments, like gravity. Subjective reality is personal feeling ('I'm so happy I'm floating'). Intersubjective reality exists because many people accept it, like the value of a banknote. Science moved from imagination and myth (Thor and rain) to verified universal laws, challenging old beliefs such as the earth-centred universe, yet superstitions still survive.
Technology is the processing of matter — from a stone axe to a smartphone. Early humans made tools without knowing natural laws, but their work revealed facts about matter; today science (e.g. the periodic table) and technology influence each other. All processing needs effort and produces by-products or waste.
We want security, comfort and entertainment from technology, but pay in effort and harm. Simple technology (a chulha) has few steps, few by-products, direct effects and needs few people; complex technology (coal power for a geyser) has many steps, more waste, delayed effects and needs many workers in hard conditions. Technology serves us but also brings accidents, distraction, deadly weapons, pollution and loss of species.
With the steam engine and electricity, human impact on nature sped up, damaging ecosystems. In the 1960s–70s Rachel Carson's 'Silent Spring' exposed the dangers of the pesticide DDT, leading to its ban in the USA. Sensitive, people-centred technology is the way to sustainable development. Philosophy does not do science's job, but examines purposes, values, the human-centred view of technology and the ethics of scientific methods, such as animal experiments.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Science, Technology and Philosophy” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Classify: (1) water boils at 100 °C at sea level (2) 'This song makes me feel on top of the world' (3) a cricket trophy being 'priceless' to a team.
Answer: (1) Objective — anyone can verify it with a thermometer. (2) Subjective — a personal feeling. (3) Intersubjective — the trophy is metal, but its huge value exists because the team and fans agree on it.
Compare boiling water on a smokeless chulha with an electric kettle powered by a coal plant.
Answer: The smokeless chulha has few steps, little waste and its harm is visible at once in the home. The kettle looks clean in the kitchen, but its electricity involves mining, burning coal, steam turbines and long power lines; ash and smoke pollute far away and the harm is delayed and borne by miners and nearby people. The chulha is simple technology; the kettle is complex technology.
| Idea | Meaning | Example / remember |
|---|---|---|
| Objective reality | Verifiable by anyone with senses and instruments | Gravity |
| Subjective reality | A personal feeling or experience | 'I'm so happy I'm floating' |
| Intersubjective reality | Exists by shared acceptance | Value of a banknote |
| Universal laws of nature | Hold across space and time | Discovered by science |
| Galileo | Supported the sun-centred view against belief | Telescope 1610; trial 1633 |
| Technology | Processing of matter | Stone axe to smartphone |
| Periodic table | Fundamental science of elements | Helps technology |
| Simple technology | Few steps, little waste, direct effects | Chulha |
| Complex technology | Many steps, more waste, delayed effects | Coal power for a geyser |
| Rachel Carson | 'Silent Spring' (1962) on pesticides | DDT banned in the USA (1972) |
| Sustainable development | Meeting needs without ruining the future | Needs sensitive technology |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Fill in the blanks: (a) What all can verify with senses and instruments is the ___ world (objective / subjective / imaginative). (b) Laws that apply at all times and places are ___ (human / universal natural laws / evolution). (c) ___ is the processing of matter (Philosophy / Science / Technology). (d) Science gives comprehensive knowledge of the ___ world (imaginary / theoretical / material).
Answer: (a) Objective. (b) Universal natural laws. (c) Technology. (d) Material.
2. State the differences: (a) complex and simple technology (b) the function of science and philosophy (c) objective and subjective reality.
Answer: (a) Simple technology has fewer processes, fewer by-products, direct and immediate effects of effort and harm, and needs less manpower (chulha). Complex technology has many processes, more by-products, indirect and delayed effects, and needs more manpower for production, use, maintenance and repair (coal power for a geyser). (b) Science studies the laws of the material, objective world by observation, experiment and instruments — it tells us what is and how. Philosophy does not intervene in the material world; it examines the meaning, purpose and value of existence, the ethics of scientific methods and the human-centred view of technology — it asks what ought to be, and tries to build a whole view of the world. (c) Objective reality can be verified by anyone through senses and instruments and does not depend on anyone's feeling (gravity). Subjective reality is one person's inner feeling or experience and cannot be checked by others ('I'm floating with joy').
3. Short notes / opinions: (a) problems created by technology (b) importance of science for human well-being (c) collective (intersubjective) reality — real or imaginary?
Answer: (a) Technology brings people closer yet isolates them (heads bent over phones); speed causes road accidents; distracted driving kills; weapons have become terribly destructive; pollution and heaps of waste grow; natural resources are used up and many species are endangered; complex technology creates hard, unhealthy labour and inequalities, and its harm is often hidden and delayed. (b) Science replaces myth and superstition with verified knowledge (rain explained, not Thor), gives universal laws, underlies medicine, food production and technology, warns us of dangers (Rachel Carson and DDT) and helps us decide wisely; without it people turn to quacks and sorcery. (c) Sample: Intersubjective reality is real in its effects but not part of nature. A banknote's value exists only because people agree on it, so it can change (inflation, demonetisation). It is not imaginary like a dream, since it works for everyone, yet not objective like gravity. I think it is a real human creation — real as long as people keep accepting it.
4. Discuss in detail the impact of science and technology on human life.
Answer: Positive: science gives true, testable knowledge of nature and frees us from superstition; technology provides security (houses), comfort (fans, geysers), entertainment (TV), basic needs (cooked food, clothing), fast travel and instant communication; science and technology improve each other (periodic table and materials). Negative: every technology costs effort and harm and produces waste; complex technologies hide their harm — coal mining, smoke and ash behind 'clean' electricity; workers labour in unhealthy conditions; people become cogs in machine systems; phones cause distraction and accidents; destructive weapons, pollution and loss of species threaten life, as Rachel Carson showed with DDT. Way ahead: choose sensitive, simpler, locally suitable technology (smokeless chulha) for sustainable development. Philosophy helps by asking about purpose and values, checking the ethics of methods (animal experiments) and questioning a purely human-centred view.
5. Write dialogues: (a) friends on celebrating eco-friendly festivals (b) advantages and disadvantages of a phone or TV.
Answer: Sample (a) — Om: Let's buy a big plaster idol for Ganeshotsav! Sara: Plaster doesn't dissolve; it pollutes the lake. Om: Then a shadu (clay) idol and immersion in a tank at home? Sara: Yes, and flowers instead of plastic decorations, no loud speakers for the sake of the elderly and animals. Om: And no firecrackers at Diwali — just diyas. Sara: Celebration and care for nature can go together. Sample (b) — Kabir: My phone helps me study, call family and pay bills. Meera: True, but you scroll for hours and sleep late. Kabir: And I check it even while cycling. Meera: That's dangerous — the brain can't focus on two things. Kabir: So: useful tool, bad master. I'll set screen-time limits and never use it on the road.
6. Activity: Find a real person who refuses some technology and lives well without it.
Answer: Sample: My grandfather does not use a smartphone; he keeps a basic phone for calls, reads newspapers and meets friends in person every evening. He says he sleeps better and talks more with people. Many people also choose bicycles over motorbikes for short trips, saving fuel and staying fit.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. What all can verify through senses and instruments is called the ___ world.
Answer: D. E.g. gravity.
2. Laws that apply at all times and places are…
Answer: C. Science discovers them.
3. ___ is the processing of matter.
Answer: B. From a stone axe to a smartphone.
4. Science gives detailed knowledge of the ___ world.
Answer: C. It studies the experiential world.
5. The value of a banknote is an example of…
Answer: C. It exists by shared acceptance.
6. 'I am so happy I'm floating in the air' expresses…
Answer: A. It is a personal feeling.
7. Which is a feature of simple technology?
Answer: A. Like the chulha.
8. Generating electricity from coal is an example of…
Answer: A. Many processes and much waste.
9. The periodic table belongs to…
Answer: D. Processing elements is technology.
10. 'Silent Spring' was written by…
Answer: D. It warned about DDT.
11. What do we mainly expect from technology?
Answer: C. We pay for it in effort and harm.
12. Unwanted by-products of processing are called…
Answer: B. Smoke and ash are examples.
13. Experiments on animals are discussed in philosophy as…
Answer: A. Philosophy examines the ethics of scientific methods.
14. Judging what is beneficial only by human interests is the…
Answer: C. Philosophy analyses this view of technology.
15. Which is the way to sustainable development, according to the chapter?
Answer: D. Technology must consider people and inequalities too.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Science, Technology and Philosophy” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Science, Technology and Philosophy the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 35 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Science, Technology and Philosophy” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Science, Technology and Philosophy.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Science, Technology and Philosophy” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.