TalentJR apps
Textbook: Political Science – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 45–54
Who protects your rights when the government itself is the other side in a case? This chapter explains judicial independence, India's court system and tribunals, how judges are appointed, original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction, the five writs, public interest litigation, judicial activism and judicial review — from Marbury v. Madison to Kesavananda Bharati — with answers to every exercise.
In almost every democracy the judiciary is independent of the executive and legislature, though it too has limits. Its main job is adjudication — deciding disputes by law and seeing that decisions are obeyed. Because the government is often a party to cases and is far stronger than a citizen, an independent judiciary is needed to treat both sides equally. Judicial independence is a modern idea; monarchs wanted obedient courts.
The USA first wrote judicial independence into its Constitution: the President appoints judges with Senate approval, judges serve for life and can be removed only through impeachment approved by Congress. India too protects judges — they can be removed only after misconduct is inquired into and proved, and Parliament approves.
India has a single integrated system: Supreme Court (headed by the Chief Justice of India), High Courts (usually one per state), District Courts and lower courts; Family Courts in big cities; and quasi-judicial tribunals such as the Armed Forces Tribunal, ITAT, National Green Tribunal, Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal and Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal — all finally under the Supreme Court. Since the 1990s a Collegium of the CJI and senior judges recommends appointments, reducing the government's role.
Courts have original jurisdiction (first hearing — the Supreme Court alone hears Centre–state and state–state disputes and disputes over the election of the President and Vice-President), appellate jurisdiction and, for the Supreme Court, advisory jurisdiction on matters the President refers. They interpret the Constitution and laws and protect rights through five writs: Habeas Corpus, Mandamus, Prohibition, Quo Warranto and Certiorari.
Public Interest Litigation lets anyone raise matters of public concern; courts sometimes act on their own. This wider role is judicial activism — praised as filling gaps left by the executive, criticised as overreach. Judicial review is the power to strike down laws inconsistent with a written constitution; it began with Marbury v. Madison (USA, 1803), is implied in the US and Indian constitutions, does not exist in the UK, and in India covers constitutional amendments through the Basic Structure Doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973).
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Role of the Judiciary” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
A student is held in a police station overnight with no charge. Which writ helps, and how?
Answer: Habeas Corpus. A relative can petition the High Court or Supreme Court, which orders the police to produce the student before it. If the court finds the detention illegal, it orders immediate release.
Why can't the UK courts strike down an Act of Parliament the way Indian courts can?
Answer: Judicial review tests a law against a written constitution that is the supreme law. The UK has no single written constitution, so there is no higher law against which its courts can measure an Act of Parliament; hence the power of judicial review, in this sense, does not exist there.
| Case / court / writ | What it is or did | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| 1803 | Marbury v. Madison (USA) | Origin of judicial review; CJ John Marshall |
| USA | First to provide for independent judiciary | Senate confirms judges; life tenure |
| 1971 | 24th Amendment | Parliament may amend Fundamental Rights |
| 1973 | Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala | Basic Structure Doctrine |
| 1990s | Collegium system | Judiciary leads appointments |
| Article 32(2) | Five writs | High Courts under Article 226 |
| PIL | Public Interest Litigation | Anyone may raise public issues |
| 2016 | National Anthem in cinemas order | Made optional in 2018 |
| Lodha Panel | BCCI reforms | Example for judicial activism |
| Tribunals | AFT, ITAT, NGT, MAT, MRT | Quasi-judicial, under the Supreme Court |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Choose the correct alternative: (1) ___ is the first country to create an independent judiciary (India, United States, United Kingdom, Soviet Union). (2) The primary function of the judiciary is ___ (making laws, executing laws, adjudication, make appointments).
Answer: (1) United States. (2) Adjudication.
2. Identify the incorrect pair and correct it: (a) Written Constitution – India (b) Judicial Review – United Kingdom (c) Independent Judiciary – United States.
Answer: Incorrect: (b). Correct: Judicial Review – United States (or India). The UK has no judicial review because it has no written constitution.
3. State the concept: (1) Petition regarding important public concern. (2) The process of removal of judges. (3) Cases can be heard for the first time only in certain courts.
Answer: (1) Public Interest Litigation. (2) Impeachment. (3) Original jurisdiction.
4. Complete the concept map: Writs.
Answer: Habeas Corpus; Mandamus; Prohibition; Quo Warranto; Certiorari.
5. True or false with reasons: (1) There is no need to approve appointment of judges by the Senate in the United States. (2) In India the judiciary is independent.
Answer: (1) False. In the USA the President appoints federal judges, but the appointment is confirmed only after the Senate approves it. (2) True. Indian judges cannot be removed unless misconduct is inquired into and proved and Parliament approves; since the 1990s the Collegium of senior judges recommends appointments, reducing government influence; and courts can strike down unconstitutional laws and actions of government.
6. Explain the co-relation: (1) Judiciary and Executive. (2) Supreme Court and High Court.
Answer: (1) The executive is often a party to cases, and being powerful it could influence decisions; so the judiciary is kept independent of it. Courts check the executive through writs such as Mandamus, through judicial review of its actions and, via judicial activism, by giving it directions and deadlines. The executive, in turn, formally appoints judges (on the Collegium's recommendation) and enforces court orders. (2) Both are constitutional courts in one integrated system. The Supreme Court is at the top and hears appeals from High Courts; High Courts are at state level, hear appeals from District Courts and supervise lower courts. Both protect rights through writs (Art. 32 and Art. 226) and interpret the Constitution. The Supreme Court alone has exclusive original jurisdiction in Centre–state disputes and advisory jurisdiction.
7. Express your opinion: (1) Judiciary must have a leading role in the appointment of judges. (2) Judicial activism is significant today.
Answer: (1) I agree, mostly. If the government chose judges, it might pick favourable ones, yet it is itself a party in many cases. A leading role for senior judges, as in the Collegium, protects independence. However, the process should be more transparent, with reasons recorded, so that public trust grows. (2) I agree. PILs have helped the poor, prisoners, workers and the environment when the executive failed to act, and courts have widened rights like the right to a clean environment. Still, courts should use activism carefully and not take over the executive's work, as the debate over orders like the 2016 cinema-anthem ruling (later made optional) shows.
8. Explain judicial review: (a) meaning (b) need (c) when and where it started (d) Indian context.
Answer: (a) Judicial review is the power of the judiciary to examine whether a law passed by the legislature agrees with the constitution and to declare it unconstitutional and invalid if it does not. (b) A written constitution is the highest law; laws must agree with it, otherwise the constitution becomes meaningless. Since the executive and legislature make laws, they would be biased in judging them, so the independent judiciary, which takes no part in law-making, is given this power. (c) It began in the USA with Marbury v. Madison (1803): Chief Justice John Marshall struck down a law of Congress for the first time. The US Constitution does not state the power; it is implied and unchallenged. It does not exist in the UK, which has no written constitution. (d) In India too the power is implied, and the Supreme Court has struck down many laws. On amendments, Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) held that Parliament may amend any provision, including Fundamental Rights, but not the basic structure; only the Supreme Court can declare an amendment unconstitutional.
9. Activity: Make a list of examples of judicial activism in India.
Answer: Sample: right to life read to include a clean environment and livelihood; Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace (1997); orders shifting Delhi's public transport to CNG; mid-day meals in schools under the right to food case; directions on bonded labour (Bandhua Mukti Morcha); Lodha Panel reforms of the BCCI; recognising privacy as a Fundamental Right (2017).
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. ___ was the first country to create an independent judiciary.
Answer: C. Written into the US Constitution.
2. The primary function of the judiciary is…
Answer: A. Deciding disputes by law.
3. Which pair is incorrect?
Answer: A. The UK has no judicial review.
4. A petition on an important public concern is…
Answer: B. Anyone may file it.
5. The process of removing judges is called…
Answer: A. Needs legislative approval.
6. Cases heard for the first time only in certain courts form their…
Answer: D. E.g. Centre–state disputes in the Supreme Court.
7. Which writ means an order to perform a duty?
Answer: C. 'We command'.
8. Judicial review began with…
Answer: C. US Supreme Court, 1803.
9. Which is a quasi-judicial body?
Answer: C. A specialised tribunal.
10. The Supreme Court advises the President under its…
Answer: B. Only on referred matters.
11. In India, judges are appointed formally by the…
Answer: B. On the Collegium's recommendation.
12. Courts directing the executive to act within a time limit is an example of…
Answer: B. A wider view of the courts' role.
13. The 24th Amendment (1971) dealt with…
Answer: A. Upheld in Kesavananda Bharati.
14. Which writ asks a lower court to send case records upward?
Answer: B. For review by the higher court.
15. Why does the judiciary hold the power of judicial review?
Answer: C. Law-makers would be biased judges of their own laws.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Role of the Judiciary” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Role of the Judiciary the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 40 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Role of the Judiciary” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Role of the Judiciary.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Role of the Judiciary” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.