TalentJR apps
Textbook: English Yuvakbharati – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 204–218
Notes on Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes mystery 'The Sign of Four' and its extract (Chapters 2 and 3): Mary Morstan's strange case of a vanished father, a pearl arriving every year and a mysterious letter, Holmes's first deductions and the foggy cab ride across London to meet the unknown writer. Novel outline, the Agra treasure story, extract synopsis, character sketches, plot sequence, setting in London and India, themes, key dialogues and answers to every Brainstorming activity.
The novel: Mary Morstan asks Holmes for help. Her father, Captain Morstan, vanished in London in 1878; since 1882 she has received a valuable pearl every year from an unknown sender. Holmes, Watson and Mary meet Thaddeus Sholto, son of Major Sholto, who reveals that his father had hidden a great treasure from India and that Mary has a claim to it.
At the Sholto house, Thaddeus's brother Bartholomew is found dead from a poisoned thorn and the Agra treasure is gone. Holmes deduces two culprits — a man with a wooden leg and a small companion. With the dog Toby, the Baker Street Irregulars and a disguise, he traces their launch, the Aurora, and after a chase on the Thames, Tonga is shot and Jonathan Small captured — but the treasure box is empty; Small had thrown it into the river.
Small's confession explains the past: during the 1857 rebellion at Agra fort, he and three Sikh companions murdered a rajah's servant for his jewels — 'the Four'. Imprisoned in the Andaman Islands, Small struck a deal with Major Sholto and Captain Morstan, but Sholto betrayed them and took the treasure to England. The treasure brought only death, fear and ruin. Watson, freed from the worry of Mary's wealth, proposes to her and she accepts.
The extract, Chapter 2: Mary, modestly dressed and composed but agitated, tells Holmes her story — her father, an officer of an Indian regiment who had been at the Andaman convict guard, disappeared on 3 December 1878; after a Times advertisement in May 1882 a pearl began arriving yearly; today a letter asks her to come to the Lyceum Theatre at seven, with two friends but no police, promising justice. Watson is charmed; Holmes says a client is merely a factor in a problem.
Chapter 3: Holmes finds that Major Sholto died on 28 April 1882, just before the pearls began, and concludes that Sholto's heir is trying to make amends. Mary shows a strange paper with a plan of a building and 'The sign of the four' with four names. On a foggy September evening the three go to the Lyceum, are taken by a coachman in a cab through winding streets to a shabby suburb, and are received by an Indian servant who says the Sahib awaits them.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “The Sign of Four” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Why does Watson call Holmes 'an automaton — a calculating machine'?
Answer: After Mary leaves, Watson exclaims that she is a very attractive woman. Holmes, puffing his pipe, says he did not notice. Watson finds this coldness almost inhuman and calls him a calculating machine. Holmes explains that he never lets personal qualities bias his judgement: a client is merely a factor in a problem, and emotions spoil clear reasoning. He even says the most charming woman he knew was a poisoner, and the most unpleasant man a great philanthropist. The remark shows the contrast between Holmes's pure logic and Watson's warm feelings.
| Clue | Detail | What it suggests |
|---|---|---|
| Father's disappearance | 3 December 1878, Langham Hotel | The wrong done to Mary |
| Only friend | Major Sholto, 34th Bombay Infantry, Upper Norwood | Sholto knows more than he admits |
| Times advertisement | 4 May 1882 | Someone seeking Mary |
| Pearls | one a year, rare and valuable; six so far | Compensation from a guilty party |
| Sholto's death | 28 April 1882 | Pearls start right after — sent by his heir |
| The letter | London S.W., 7 July; Lyceum, 7 p.m.; no police | The heir wants to give her justice |
| Handwriting | disguised, same person; unlike her father's | Father not alive/sender is someone else |
| The paper | Indian paper, building plan, red cross, '3.37 from left' | Location of a hidden treasure |
| Sign of the four | Small, Mahomet Singh, Abdullah Khan, Dost Akbar | A secret pact — the key to the mystery |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. A1 (i), (ii): Qualities of Holmes, Watson and Mary; Mary from Watson's point of view.
Answer: (i) Holmes — observant, logical, unemotional, quick, cautious, confident. Watson — warm, kind, romantic, modest, loyal, honest. Mary — composed, dignified, sweet, sensitive, brave, methodical (a model client). (ii) Sample (as Watson): The moment Miss Morstan entered, I noticed her quiet good taste and the brave composure that hid her agitation. Her face was not perfectly beautiful, but her expression was so sweet and her blue eyes so sympathetic that I have never seen a face that promised a more refined nature. She trusted us readily and, though pale and anxious in the cab, kept perfect self-control. I could not stop thinking of her — though I reminded myself that a poor army surgeon had no right to such thoughts.
2. A1 (iii), (v): Holmes as the leading character; Holmes is always a step ahead of Watson.
Answer: (iii) The whole extract revolves around Holmes: Mary comes for his help, he questions her, studies the envelope, letter and handwriting, researches the Times files, forms the theory about Sholto's heir, examines the paper and guides the party through London. (v) Watson thinks the letter-writer is a man of business habits, but Holmes reads vacillation and self-esteem in his handwriting; Watson cannot see the meaning of the dates, but Holmes links Sholto's death with the start of the pearls; Watson loses his bearings in the fog, while Holmes names every street.
3. A2 (i): Arrange the incidents in sequence.
Answer: (5) Mary Morstan was a well-dressed young lady → (4) Mary's father was an officer in an Indian regiment → (3) Mary received a large and lustrous pearl through the post → (2) Holmes gave Winwood Reade's 'Martyrdom of Man' to Dr Watson → (1) Holmes put a revolver in his pocket.
4. A2 (ii): Importance of the statements.
Answer: (a) The visit to the Lyceum Theatre is the meeting point arranged by the unknown writer — it moves the story from Baker Street into action and leads to Thaddeus Sholto. (b) The yearly pearls show that someone feels guilty and wants to compensate Mary; Holmes links them to Major Sholto's death. (c) Holmes's careful examination of the paper reveals the 'sign of the four' and four names — the vital clue that later explains the Agra treasure and the murders.
5. A3 (i), (v), (vi): Time references; importance of places; places in India and England.
Answer: (i) 1878 — father's leave and disappearance (3 December 1878, 'nearly ten years ago'); 4 May 1882 — Times advertisement; 28 April 1882 — Sholto's death; 7 July — letter's postmark; 'half-past three', 'half-past five', 'not yet seven' on a September evening. (v) London — the main scene of the mystery; Lyceum Theatre — the rendezvous; Edinburgh — Mary's school; Agra — origin of the treasure (in the novel); Andaman Islands — where Morstan and Sholto commanded the convict guard and the pact was made. (vi) India: Bombay (34th Bombay Infantry — the regiment of Morstan and Sholto), Andaman Islands (convict guard; curiosities in the luggage), Agra (treasure). England: London — Baker Street (case begins), Langham Hotel (father vanished), Upper Norwood (Sholto's home), Lyceum Theatre (rendezvous), Surrey side suburbs (destination); Edinburgh — Mary's boarding school.
6. A4 (ii), (iv): Mary's meeting with Holmes; give reasons.
Answer: (ii) Mary enters Holmes's room calm in manner but trembling with agitation. She explains that Holmes had helped her employer. She narrates her father's disappearance, the yearly pearls and the morning's letter, and shows the pearls and papers. Holmes listens keenly, studies the letter and handwriting and agrees to accompany her with Watson to the Lyceum. (iv) (a) She wanted help with her strange, inexplicable situation. (b) Holmes had helped Mrs Forrester before, which gave Mary confidence. (c) A father vanishing, yearly pearls and a mysterious letter make it unusual. (d) He wanted to check old Times files about Major Sholto. (e) Sholto's heir sent them to compensate her for a wrong. (f) The letter had warned her not to bring the police.
7. A5 (i), (ii): Explain the lines; identify speakers.
Answer: (i) (a) Watson to Holmes — Holmes judges only by logic and ignores emotion, like a machine. (b) Watson to Holmes — Watson wonders what justice Mary could get, since her father is surely dead; it raises the central question of the mystery. (c) Holmes to Watson — as they drive into shabby, working-class suburbs, he notes wryly that the quest is not leading to elegant places. (ii) 'You once enabled my employer…' — Mary to Holmes; polite, hopeful; establishes trust. 'You will, I am sure, excuse me' — Watson to Mary/Holmes; courteous, modest; shows his tact. 'Your statement is most interesting…' — Holmes to Mary; brisk, keen; shows his professional curiosity. 'Are you the parties who come with Miss Morstan?' — the coachman to the trio; cautious, questioning; builds suspense. 'The Sahib awaits you' — the Indian servant to the trio; formal; introduces the Indian connection and ends the extract on suspense.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. Mary Morstan's dress suggested…
Answer: B. Plain, untrimmed, tasteful.
2. Mary came to Holmes because he had helped…
Answer: C. Her employer.
3. Mary's father was…
Answer: C. Senior captain.
4. Mary was brought up in…
Answer: D. Till seventeen.
5. Since 1882 Mary has received every year…
Answer: B. Rare and valuable.
6. The letter asked Mary to meet at…
Answer: A. Third pillar from the left.
7. Holmes concluded the handwriting was…
Answer: B. Same author as pearl boxes.
8. Watson calls Holmes a calculating machine because…
Answer: D. No emotion in judgement.
9. Holmes's key discovery was that Major Sholto…
Answer: D. Just before the pearls began.
10. Holmes took a revolver because…
Answer: C. Caution.
11. The paper in Mary's father's desk showed…
Answer: C. With four names.
12. The weather on the evening of the drive was…
Answer: C. Dense drizzly fog.
13. Holmes called out the names of streets because…
Answer: D. Never at fault.
14. 'Our quest does not appear to take us to very fashionable regions' means…
Answer: B. Run-down suburbs.
15. A major theme of the novel is…
Answer: C. The Agra treasure.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “The Sign of Four” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise The Sign of Four the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 35 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “The Sign of Four” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of The Sign of Four.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “The Sign of Four” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.