TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 31–39
Can we trust what we see? Learn how philosophy separates what is real (sat) from what only seems real — the shell-silver and rope-snake examples, subjective experience and objective existence, permanent and changing, monism, dualism and pluralism, idealism, materialism and realism, motion and change, and theistic and atheistic views — with answers to every exercise.
Proverbs such as 'all that glitters is not gold' carry an old warning: things may not be what they look like. Our senses tell us about the world, but not with full reliability. Advaita Vedanta's two famous analogies make the point — a shining shell mistaken for silver (shuktirajat) and a rope mistaken for a snake (rajjusarpa). Dreams, illusions and hallucinations also feel real while they last.
Experience is subjective: the same weather or sweet feels different to different people, because of inner factors (our body and mind, a cold) and outer factors (season, atmosphere). But the object's existence and nature do not depend on who experiences it — they are objective. What only one person experiences, like a dream, is not real in this sense. So 'What is?' (metaphysics) cannot be answered without 'How do we know?' (epistemology).
Things keep changing — creation, sustenance and dissolution — yet something may stay the same, like H2O through ice, water and steam. Some philosophers held that only the unchanging is real and change is superficial; others held that change itself is the only permanent law. Applied to the self, some call the permanent part atma (soul) and the changing part the body.
Philosophers differ on how many ultimate realities there are — one (monism: Parmenides, Advaita Vedanta, Spinoza, Hegel), two (dualism: Sankhya, Descartes) or many (pluralism: Empedocles, Jaina, Leibniz) — and on their nature: consciousness (idealism), matter (materialism) or real things independent of mind (realism).
Change needs motion. Some say elements move by their own nature, following physical laws with no purpose; others say matter must be moved from outside by an all-powerful God (theism). Some theists say God shaped the world from existing elements, others that God created it from nothing. Atheistic philosophies reject God; both kinds exist in India and the West.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Appearances are Deceptive” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
At night, your school bag on a chair looks like a crouching person. Explain this with an Indian analogy.
Answer: Only the bag was there; its outline in poor light resembled a person, so we took it for one. This is like the rajjusarpa nyaya, where a rope in dim light is seen as a snake. Switching on the light (closer examination) removes the error.
You look at your Class 1 photograph and say, 'That's me, but I've changed a lot.' What metaphysical problem does this show?
Answer: Height, face, voice, interests and ideas have all changed, yet you feel the same 'I' went through these changes. This is the permanent–impermanent problem. Some philosophers explain the unchanging 'I' as the soul (atma); others say there is nothing unchanging in us and the self is itself a flow of changes.
| Theory / example | Key idea | Who holds it / remember |
|---|---|---|
| Shuktirajat nyaya | Shell seen as silver | Advaita Vedanta analogy |
| Rajjusarpa nyaya | Rope seen as a snake | Advaita Vedanta analogy |
| Monism | One ultimate reality | Parmenides, Advaita Vedanta, Spinoza, Hegel |
| Dualism | Two ultimate realities | Sankhya, Descartes |
| Pluralism | Many ultimate realities | Empedocles, Jaina, Leibniz |
| Idealism | Reality is consciousness | Vedanta, Berkeley, Hegel, Bradley |
| Materialism | Reality is matter | Charvaka, Democritus, Marxism |
| Realism | The world exists independently of mind | Jaina, Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Sankhya, Purva Mimamsa, Locke, Russell, Moore |
| Theism | God moves and creates the world | Some Indian and Western schools |
| Uddalaka's clay | Know the clay, know all clay things | Chhandogya Upanishad |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Fill in the blanks: (a) ___ studies reality (Epistemology / Metaphysics / Ethics). (b) ___ is the nature of objects experienced by the senses (illusion / sustenance / transience). (c) Dreams and illusions are ___ (subjective / intersubjective / objective).
Answer: (a) Metaphysics. (b) Transience. (c) Subjective.
2. Odd one out: (a) creation, sustenance, permanence, dissolution (b) knowledge–information, real–unreal, static–dynamic, permanent–impermanent.
Answer: (a) Permanence — the other three are forms of transformation. (b) Knowledge–information — the others are pairs of opposites discussed in metaphysics; knowledge–information is not a pair of opposites and belongs to epistemology.
3. Give the term: (a) one ultimate reality (b) two ultimate realities (c) many ultimate realities (d) God is the creator of the world (e) rejects the existence of God (f) ultimate truth is consciousness (g) ultimate truth is matter.
Answer: (a) Monism. (b) Dualism. (c) Pluralism. (d) Theism. (e) Atheism. (f) Idealism. (g) Materialism.
4. Distinguish between (a) monism, dualism and pluralism (b) idealism and materialism.
Answer: (a) Monism: one ultimate reality — Parmenides, Advaita Vedanta, Spinoza, Hegel. Dualism: two ultimate realities — Sankhya (purusha and prakriti), Descartes (mind and matter). Pluralism: many ultimate realities — Empedocles (four elements), Jaina darshana, Leibniz. (b) Idealism holds that the ultimate reality is consciousness or mind and matter depends on it — Vedanta, Berkeley, Hegel, Bradley. Materialism holds that the ultimate reality is matter and consciousness arises from it — Charvaka, Democritus, Marxism. Idealism must explain how matter comes from consciousness; materialism must explain how consciousness comes from matter.
5. Short notes: (a) subjective experience (b) theism (c) problem of motion.
Answer: (a) Experience varies from person to person — the same morning feels cold to one, warm to another. Inner factors (body, mind, illness) and outer factors (season, light, distance) shape it. So experience must be examined before calling it real; what only one person experiences, like a dream, is not real in content, though the object itself exists objectively. (b) Theism holds that matter cannot move by itself and an all-powerful, all-knowing God sets it in motion with a purpose. Things exist as long as God wills. Some theists say God arranged existing elements; others that God created everything from nothing. Theistic and atheistic schools exist in both India and the West. (c) Change requires motion. Are the basic elements active by nature or moved from outside? We see effects like earthquakes without seeing the inner motion. One view: elements move by their own nature, following physical laws with no purpose (e.g. clouds shaped by wind). The other: God is the mover. Any theory of the world must explain motion.
6. Answer in 20–25 words: (a) What is objectivity? (b) What are the concerns of metaphysics? (c) Explain rajjusarpa nyaya. (d) Explain the relationship between motion and change.
Answer: (a) Objectivity means a thing's existence and nature do not depend on who experiences it or how; it is the same for everyone. (b) Metaphysics asks what is real, how the real differs from the apparent, what things are made of, how many basic realities there are, their nature and why they change. (c) In dim light a rope looks like a snake and frightens us; closer observation shows it is a rope — an example that appearance can deceive. (d) Change cannot happen without motion; motion is a precondition of change, though we often see only the change, not the motion.
7. Explain with examples: (a) The existence of an object is objective though its experience is subjective. (b) Appearances are deceptive. (c) Motion is a precondition of change.
Answer: (a) A cup of tea may taste too sweet to one person and just right to another, but the amount of sugar in it is fixed; the tea and its sugar exist whether or not anyone tastes them. (b) A shell glinting in the sun looks like silver, distant hills look blue, railway lines seem to meet, artificial flowers look real — closer examination shows the truth. (c) Ice melts only when its molecules move faster as heat is added; a volcano erupts because of movements inside the earth that we do not see. Without motion, nothing could be formed, grow or break down.
8. Discuss the nitya–anitya (permanent–impermanent) problem in metaphysics.
Answer: Everything we sense changes — it is created, lasts a while and is dissolved. Yet some things seem to stay the same through change: water remains H2O as ice, liquid or steam; gold remains gold as ring or bangle (Uddalaka's clay example). One group of philosophers holds that the changing depends on an unchanging principle, which alone is real; change is only on the surface. Another group holds that change itself is the nature of reality and there is no unchanging base. The problem is sharpest for the self: I feel I am the same person since birth though my body, feelings and ideas change. Some systems call the permanent part atma and the perishable part the body; those who deny any permanent principle reject the soul, while those who accept only the permanent as real deny that the body is ultimate.
9. Discuss various philosophical views on ultimate reality.
Answer: By number: monism (one — Parmenides, Advaita Vedanta, Spinoza, Hegel), dualism (two — Sankhya, Descartes), pluralism (many — Empedocles, Jaina, Leibniz). By nature: idealism (consciousness — Vedanta, Berkeley, Hegel, Bradley), materialism (matter — Charvaka, Democritus, Marxism), realism (a world independent of mind — Jaina, Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Sankhya, Purva Mimamsa, Locke, Russell, Moore). Some schools hold both matter and consciousness are basic. Problems each must face: how opposites come from one element (Thales' water and fire), how mind comes from matter or matter from mind, and whether elements move by themselves (a purposeless natural process) or are moved by God (theism, with creation either from existing elements or from nothing).
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. The branch of philosophy that studies reality is…
Answer: A. It asks 'What is?'.
2. The nature of objects known through the senses is…
Answer: D. They keep changing.
3. Dreams and illusions are…
Answer: A. Only one person experiences them.
4. Shuktirajat nyaya is the analogy of…
Answer: D. Shukti = shell, rajat = silver.
5. The permanent nature of water is…
Answer: D. States change; composition does not.
6. Which pair is a dualist pair?
Answer: B. Two ultimate realities.
7. Pluralism holds that ultimate realities are…
Answer: D. E.g. Empedocles' four elements.
8. Charvaka darshana is an example of…
Answer: C. It accepts matter as the reality.
9. Berkeley and Bradley are…
Answer: A. Reality is mind or consciousness.
10. Which is NOT a form of transformation in the chapter?
Answer: B. Permanence is the opposite of change.
11. A precondition of change is…
Answer: B. Nothing changes without motion.
12. Water tastes sour to a feverish person. The sourness is…
Answer: A. It comes from the person's state.
13. The view that change is the only permanent law…
Answer: A. It treats change as the world's real nature.
14. The view that God created the world from nothing is a form of…
Answer: D. Some theists hold creation from a void.
15. Uddalaka's clay example comes from the…
Answer: B. He teaches Shwetaketu.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Appearances are Deceptive” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Appearances are Deceptive the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 35 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Appearances are Deceptive” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Appearances are Deceptive.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Appearances are Deceptive” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.