TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 11 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 40–50
What does it really mean to know something? Learn how knowledge differs from information and from opinion, Plato's idea of episteme, the sources of knowledge in the Western and Indian traditions (perception, memory, testimony, reason, and the six pramanas), why intuition is not accepted, and 'knowing how' versus 'knowing that', with answers to every exercise.
Repeating something learnt by heart is not knowing it. In the popular Einstein story, the driver could deliver the lecture from memory but could not handle questions. Knowledge needs understanding; rote learning gives only an illusion of knowledge ('parroting'). The study of knowledge is epistemology.
Knowledge arises when a knower interacts with something known, but not every interaction gives knowledge. Information is a collection of facts — raw material. When we think about facts, link and organise them into a coherent system, information becomes knowledge. Information must be checked, since false information (rumours, forwards) can never become knowledge.
Opinions differ between people and change with time; knowledge is meant to be the same for all. Plato called the unchanging, universal kind of knowing 'episteme' and the changeable kind 'belief' or opinion. Opinions can be true or false; knowledge cannot be false, and a knowledge-claim must be justified with proof.
Sources of knowledge: sense perception (pratyaksha), which is basic but can deceive; memory, which helps us recognise but can fail or distort; testimony (shabda or authority) — trusting experts, which needs care about whom we trust; and intellect or reason, which organises facts, sees causes and grasps abstract ideas and values. Indian philosophy lists six pramanas: pratyaksha, anumana, upamana, shabda, arthapatti, anupalabdhi.
Intuition — a hunch without evidence — is subjective and cannot be checked, so it is not accepted as a valid source. Knowing a skill ('knowing how', e.g. swimming) differs from propositional knowledge ('knowing that', e.g. metals expand on heating). A good life needs both knowledge and skills.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Getting to Know, 'Knowing'?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Riya has saved 200 facts about planets in her phone. Ravi can explain why Venus is hotter than Mercury though farther from the Sun. Who has knowledge?
Answer: Riya has information — useful raw material but unconnected. Ravi has knowledge: he has connected facts (thick carbon dioxide atmosphere, greenhouse effect) into an explanation he can use to answer new questions.
You smell smoke in the kitchen and conclude the milk is burning. Which sources are you using?
Answer: Sense perception (smell) gives the sensation; memory links this smell to burnt milk from earlier days; reason (inference) concludes that the milk on the stove is burning. You then check by looking — confirming with another sense.
| Source / idea | What it means | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Knower and known | Their interaction gives rise to knowledge | Needed but not enough |
| Information | Scattered facts — raw material | Like coins piled at random |
| Knowledge | Facts linked into a coherent system | Cannot be false |
| Plato's episteme | Knowledge true for all places, times and persons | Contrast: belief / opinion |
| Sense perception (pratyaksha) | Direct contact of senses and objects | Basic but can deceive |
| Memory | Recognising and comparing | Can forget or distort |
| Testimony (shabda / authority) | Trusting experts and reliable texts | Check credibility |
| Reason / intellect | Organises facts, sees causes, grasps values | Builds the 'house' from the bricks |
| Intuition | A hunch without evidence | Not a valid source: subjective, unverifiable |
| Indian pramanas | Pratyaksha, anumana, upamana, shabda, arthapatti, anupalabdhi | Six means of knowledge |
| Knowing how / knowing that | Skill / propositional knowledge | Swimming / 'metals expand on heating' |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. True or false with reason: (a) The known is the person who knows. (b) All knowledge gained through the senses is true. (c) Credibility does not matter in testimony. (d) Knowledge and skill are not important for a good life.
Answer: (a) False — the knower is the person who knows; the known is the object of knowledge. (b) False — senses can deceive (a stick looks bent in water, a cold dulls smell), so sense-information must be checked. (c) False — testimony is only as good as its source; trusting ignorant persons or wrong sources misleads us, so credibility is essential. (d) False — a good life needs both: knowledge to understand the world and ourselves, and skills to carry out daily tasks; actions based on poor knowledge fail.
2. Distinguish between (a) direct and indirect knowledge (b) knowledge and information (c) knowledge and opinion (d) knowledge and wisdom.
Answer: (a) Direct knowledge comes from immediate contact — sense perception or inner sensation (seeing a flower, feeling pain). Indirect knowledge comes through something else — memory, testimony or inference (knowing about refraction from a teacher, inferring a plane from its sound). (b) Information is a collection of facts, possibly scattered and unverified; knowledge is information that has been checked, understood and organised into a coherent system and becomes part of our thinking. Information can be false; knowledge cannot. (c) Opinion varies between persons and over time and may be true or false; knowledge is the same for all, cannot be false, and is justified with proof — Plato's episteme versus belief. (d) Knowledge is understanding of what is true; wisdom adds awareness of the situation and of morality and guides right action — designing a deadly weapon may need knowledge but is not wise.
3. Answer in 20–25 words: (a) Elements of the process of knowledge (b) What is testimony? (c) Uses of memory in knowing (d) What are sense organs? (e) What is inner sensation?
Answer: (a) The knower, the known (object), and the interaction between them; information from senses, memory and testimony is then organised by intellect. (b) Testimony is knowledge gained by trusting the word of a reliable expert, teacher or text, e.g. learning about refraction from a textbook. (c) We recognise a plane by its remembered sound, compare new experiences with old ones and use memorised tables to solve sums. (d) Eyes, ears, nose, tongue and skin — through direct contact with objects they give us sensations of colour, sound, smell, taste and touch. (e) Direct awareness of what is happening in our own body and mind, such as pain, hunger, joy or sadness, without anyone telling us.
4. Explain with examples: (a) Knowledge is not merely information. (b) Sense experience must be used carefully as a source of knowledge.
Answer: (a) A pile of bricks, cement and iron is not a house; likewise a pile of facts is not knowledge. Many facts about the Indian giant squirrel become knowledge only when we link them and understand, for example, how it glides without wings. If information alone were knowledge, an encyclopaedia or search engine would be the most knowledgeable of all. (b) Senses are our basic link to the world, but they can mislead: a stick looks bent in water, colours change in dim light, a cold dulls smell, a mirage looks like water. So we check sense-information with other senses, memory, testimony and reason before accepting it.
5. Discuss the sources of knowledge in detail.
Answer: Sense perception (pratyaksha): direct contact of sense organs with objects gives colour, sound, smell, taste and touch; all knowledge of the material world rests on it, but senses can deceive, so care is needed. Inner sensations tell us of pain or joy directly. Memory: lets us recognise and compare (a plane's sound, multiplication tables) but forgets and distorts. Testimony/authority: we accept experts and reliable books because no one can learn everything, but we must check credibility. Reason/intellect: arranges information from all sources, sees causal links (rain and petrichor), grasps abstract laws, concepts and values, and decides how to use knowledge; logic guides it. Intuition: a hunch without evidence; being subjective and unverifiable, it is not accepted. The Indian tradition names six pramanas — pratyaksha, anumana, upamana, shabda, arthapatti, anupalabdhi — accepted in different numbers by different schools.
6. Write a dialogue on the need for knowledge and skill for a good life.
Answer: Sample — Aman: I can fix any phone; why should I study theory? Neha: Your skill earns money — that's 'knowing how'. But can you tell a safe battery from a fake one? Aman: Not always. Neha: That needs 'knowing that' — facts about batteries and charging. Aman: So knowledge keeps my skill safe. Neha: And knowledge without skill is also incomplete — a person who knows physics but cannot swim can still drown. Aman: Then a good life needs both — knowing and doing. Neha: And wisdom to use them for good.
7. Activity: Observe how children aged 3–6 learn and note the methods they use.
Answer: Sample: Small children learn by touching, tasting and shaking things (sense perception), copying elders (imitation), asking endless 'why' questions (testimony from adults), remembering and repeating rhymes (memory), and simple reasoning ('the floor is wet, so it rained'). They also learn by trial and error — e.g. finding which blocks fit.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. The person who knows is called the…
Answer: A. The known is the object.
2. Information becomes knowledge when it is…
Answer: D. Knowledge is a coherent system.
3. According to Plato, true knowledge is called…
Answer: A. The changeable kind is belief or opinion.
4. Which statement is true of opinions?
Answer: D. Knowledge, unlike opinion, cannot be false.
5. Pratyaksha pramana refers to…
Answer: D. Direct contact of senses and object.
6. A stick looking bent in water shows that…
Answer: D. It is an effect of refraction.
7. Which is a weakness of memory?
Answer: B. Memory may distort.
8. Accepting what a reliable teacher says about refraction is knowledge by…
Answer: C. Shabda / authority.
9. Intuition is not accepted as a source of knowledge because it is…
Answer: A. Knowledge must be objective and justified.
10. 'I know how to swim' is an example of…
Answer: A. A practical skill.
11. Which is NOT among the six Indian pramanas?
Answer: B. Intuition is in the Western list, and is rejected.
12. Smelling petrichor and linking it to rain on dry soil is the work of…
Answer: A. Intellect sees causal links.
13. Feeling a headache yourself, without a doctor telling you, is…
Answer: C. We sense inner states directly.
14. Which phrase signals an opinion rather than a claim to know?
Answer: B. 'I think' shows uncertainty.
15. Knowledge studied in epistemology is mainly…
Answer: D. E.g. 'metals expand on heating'.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Getting to Know, 'Knowing'?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Getting to Know, 'Knowing'? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 35 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Getting to Know, 'Knowing'?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Getting to Know, 'Knowing'?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Getting to Know, ‘Knowing’?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.