TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 36–53
Long before truth tables and quantifiers, Aristotle analysed reasoning in terms of subjects, predicates and classes. This chapter covers that traditional scheme: the four categorical propositions A, E, I and O, which terms each one distributes, and two kinds of inference. Immediate inference draws a conclusion from one premise (opposition, conversion, obversion). Mediate inference needs two premises (syllogisms). Every activity box and all 30 items in Q.7 and Q.8 are answered below.
For Aristotle, the founder of traditional logic, a proposition is made of terms. A term is a word or group of words that serves as subject or predicate; on its own it is neither true nor false. A logical proposition has three parts in the order subject – copula – predicate ('All apples | are | red').
Propositions are conditional or categorical. A conditional proposition makes its assertion under a condition. It is either hypothetical (antecedent and consequent: 'If metal is heated, it expands') or disjunctive (alternatives, exclusive or inclusive). A categorical proposition asserts or denies a relation between two classes without any condition.
Categorical propositions have quality (affirmative/negative) and quantity (universal/particular), which gives the four-fold scheme: A (All S is P), E (No S is P), I (Some S is P), O (Some S is not P). Singular propositions count as universal: affirmative singular = A, negative singular = E. Ordinary-language words also signal the type. 'Every, always, whoever' give A; 'never, none, not a single' give E; 'many, most, a few, often' give I; 'hardly, rarely, seldom, few' give O.
A term is distributed when the proposition refers to its whole class. A distributes S only; E distributes both; I distributes neither; O distributes P only. Remember it as: universals distribute the subject, negatives distribute the predicate.
Inference is deductive or inductive. Deductive inference is immediate (from one premise) or mediate (from two or more). Immediate inference covers opposition (contradictory, contrary, sub-contrary, sub-altern) and eduction (conversion, obversion and others). Mediate inference is the syllogism: hypothetical, disjunctive or categorical.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Traditional Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Given 'Most smartphones are fragile' (I). Give its contradictory, sub-contrary and sub-altern, and say what follows if the I is true.
Answer: E is false; O and A are doubtful.
Give the converse and obverse of 'Not a single river here is polluted'.
Answer: Converse: No polluted things are rivers here. Obverse: All rivers here are non-polluted.
| Proposition (form) | Quantity, quality and distribution | Converse / obverse |
|---|---|---|
| A: All S is P | Universal affirmative; S distributed, P undistributed | Converse I (Some P is S); obverse E (No S is non-P) |
| E: No S is P | Universal negative; both distributed | Converse E (No P is S); obverse A (All S is non-P) |
| I: Some S is P | Particular affirmative; neither distributed | Converse I (Some P is S); obverse O (Some S is not non-P) |
| O: Some S is not P | Particular negative; only P distributed | No converse; obverse I (Some S is non-P) |
| Singular: 'Smita is smart' / 'Yash is not a coward' | Treated as A / as E | Whole subject is referred to |
| Contradictory A–O, E–I | Not both true, not both false | Truth of one = falsity of the other |
| Contrary A–E / Sub-contrary I–O | Not both true / not both false | Other cases doubtful |
| Sub-altern A–I, E–O | Universal T ⇒ particular T; particular F ⇒ universal F | Universal F or particular T ⇒ doubtful |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (1–15) and the distribution table (Subject / Predicate for A, E, I, O).
Answer: (1) Aristotle. (2) Syllogism. (3) Disjunctive. (4) E. (5) Distributed. (6) Mediate. (7) Opposition of Propositions. (8) Obversion. (9) Sub-altern. (10) Contraries. (11) A. (12) O. (13) Universal. (14) O. (15) Hypothetical. Table: A — S distributed, P undistributed; E — both distributed; I — both undistributed; O — S undistributed, P distributed.
2. Q.2 True or false (1–15); Q.3 Match; Q.4 Logical terms (1–15).
Answer: Q.2: (1) True. (2) False: A and O are contradictories; A and E are contraries. (3) True. (4) False: the quality stays the same. (5) True. (6) True. (7) False: that describes a categorical proposition. (8) True. (9) False: it is deductive (mediate). (10) True. (11) False: they cannot both be false, but they can both be true. (12) True. (13) False: that is a rule of conversion. Obversion's rules are about quality, quantity and the complementary predicate. (14) True. (15) False: O has no converse. Q.3: (1)–(b), (2)–(d), (3)–(a), (4)–(c). Q.4: (1) Term. (2) Copula. (3) Subject term. (4) Conditional proposition. (5) Disjunctive proposition. (6) Categorical proposition. (7) E proposition. (8) A proposition. (9) Immediate inference. (10) Opposition of propositions. (11) Singular proposition. (12) Conversion. (13) Obversion. (14) Syllogism. (15) Sub-altern relation.
3. Q.5 Give reasons (1–5); Q.6 Explain (1–11); truth tables of the four oppositions (fill the '?').
Answer: Q.5: (1) I and O have the same terms, are both particular and differ only in quality, so they cannot both be false. (2) The predicate is affirmed or denied of the whole of a single subject, as in a universal. (3) The converse must stay negative (O or E), and S, undistributed in O, would become the distributed predicate, which breaks the rule of distribution. (4) Obversion changes the quality and keeps the quantity, so universal affirmative becomes universal negative with non-P. (5) P is undistributed in A; making it the subject of a universal would distribute it, so only a particular (I) is allowed. Q.6: see the notes. Distribution of each type (A: S; E: S, P; I: none; O: P), the four oppositions with examples, conversion (rules of quality and distribution) and obversion (quality changes, quantity same, complementary predicate). Opposition tables: Contrary: A T → E F; A F → E ?; E T → A F; E F → A ?. Contradictory: each value flips. Sub-contrary: I T → O ?; I F → O T; O T → I ?; O F → I T. Sub-altern: A T → I T; A F → I ?; I T → A ?; I F → A F; E T → O T; E F → O ?; O T → E ?; O F → E F.
4. Activity: give the oppositions of (1) All diplomats are liberal (2) No cats are dogs (3) Some musicians are singers (4) Some thin people are not healthy (5) Every child is innocent (6) Not a single game is enjoyable (7) A few lectures are monotonous (8) Many movies are not tragedies (9) Executives are always stressed (10) Ascetics are never materialistic
Answer: (1) A: O Some diplomats are not liberal; E No diplomats are liberal; I Some diplomats are liberal. (2) E: I Some cats are dogs; A All cats are dogs; O Some cats are not dogs. (3) I: E No musicians are singers; O Some musicians are not singers; A All musicians are singers. (4) O: A All thin people are healthy; I Some thin people are healthy; E No thin people are healthy. (5) A: O Some children are not innocent; E No child is innocent; I Some children are innocent. (6) E: I Some games are enjoyable; A All games are enjoyable; O Some games are not enjoyable. (7) I: E No lectures are monotonous; O A few lectures are not monotonous; A All lectures are monotonous. (8) O: A All movies are tragedies; I Many movies are tragedies; E No movies are tragedies. (9) A: O Some executives are not stressed; E No executives are stressed; I Some executives are stressed. (10) E: I Some ascetics are materialistic; A All ascetics are materialistic; O Some ascetics are not materialistic.
5. Activity: converse of (1) Hexagon means six-sided polygon (2) Any chickoo is ripe (3) No crows are sparrows (4) Many ladies are hardworking (5) Few voters are present (6) All tigers are wild (7) Not a single cupboard is wooden (8) Hardly children are extroverts (9) Indians are generally vegetarians (10) A few teachers are strict. Obverse of (1) All journalists are writers (2) No lions are herbivorous (3) A few subjects are interesting (4) Some producers are not rich (5) Every mother is anxious (6) Not a single stick is straight (7) Many books are expensive (8) Occasionally students are punctual (9) All gadgets are modern (10) Several teachers are good speakers
Answer: Converse: (1) A six-sided polygon is a hexagon (A stays A: definition). (2) Some ripe things are chickoos. (3) No sparrows are crows. (4) Some hardworking people are ladies. (5) 'Few' signals O, so there is no converse. (6) Some wild animals are tigers. (7) No wooden things are cupboards. (8) O, so there is no converse. (9) Some vegetarians are Indians. (10) Some strict people are teachers. Obverse: (1) No journalists are non-writers. (2) All lions are non-herbivorous. (3) A few subjects are not non-interesting. (4) Some producers are non-rich. (5) No mother is non-anxious. (6) All sticks are non-straight. (7) Many books are not non-expensive. (8) Occasionally students are not non-punctual. (9) No gadgets are non-modern. (10) Several teachers are not non-good speakers. Tables: converse A→I (Some P is S), E→E (No P is S), I→I (Some P is S), O not possible; obverse A→E (No S is non-P), E→A (All S is non-P), I→O (Some S is not non-P), O→I (Some S is non-P).
6. Q.7 (1–10) Give the oppositions asked: (1) All red vehicles are BEST buses [contradictory, contrary] (2) Some citizens are patriotic [contradictory, sub-contrary] (3) No crows are white [contrary, sub-altern] (4) Some mistakes are not forgivable [sub-contrary, sub-altern] (5) Any fruit is nourishing [contrary, sub-altern] (6) Not a single creature is useless [contradictory, sub-altern] (7) Many philosophers are philanthropists [sub-contrary, sub-altern] (8) A few males are not dominating [contradictory, sub-altern] (9) Every mango is sweet [contradictory, sub-altern] (10) Not even one resource is sufficient [contrary, contradictory]
Answer: (1) A. O: Some red vehicles are not BEST buses. E: No red vehicles are BEST buses. (2) I. E: No citizens are patriotic. O: Some citizens are not patriotic. (3) E. A: All crows are white. O: Some crows are not white. (4) O. I: Some mistakes are forgivable. E: No mistakes are forgivable. (5) A. E: No fruit is nourishing. I: Some fruits are nourishing. (6) E. I: Some creatures are useless. O: Some creatures are not useless. (7) I. O: Many philosophers are not philanthropists. A: All philosophers are philanthropists. (8) O. A: All males are dominating. E: No males are dominating. (9) A. O: Some mangoes are not sweet. I: Some mangoes are sweet. (10) E. A: All resources are sufficient. I: Some resources are sufficient.
7. Q.7 (11–20): (11) Children often eat junk food [contradictory, sub-altern] (12) Children seldom play outdoor games [sub-contrary, contradictory] (13) Several air-hostesses are beautiful [sub-altern, sub-contrary] (14) None of the rich are generous [contrary, contradictory] (15) Whoever works is paid [contrary, sub-altern] (16) Victory is frequently celebrated [sub-contrary, contradictory] (17) Some grapes are not green [sub-altern, sub-contrary] (18) All Indians are intelligent [sub-altern, contradictory] (19) Games are never boring [contrary, sub-altern] (20) Some chemicals are poisonous [sub-altern, contradictory]
Answer: (11) I. E: No children eat junk food. A: All children eat junk food. (12) O (Some children do not play outdoor games). I: Some children play outdoor games. A: All children play outdoor games. (13) I. A: All air-hostesses are beautiful. O: Several air-hostesses are not beautiful. (14) E. A: All rich people are generous. I: Some rich people are generous. (15) A. E: No one who works is paid. I: Some who work are paid. (16) I. O: Victory is frequently not celebrated (some victories are not celebrated). E: No victory is celebrated. (17) O. E: No grapes are green. I: Some grapes are green. (18) A. I: Some Indians are intelligent. O: Some Indians are not intelligent. (19) E. A: All games are boring. O: Some games are not boring. (20) I. A: All chemicals are poisonous. E: No chemicals are poisonous.
8. Q.7 (21–30): (21) Hardly students study [sub-contrary, contradictory] (22) All pilots are smart [contrary, contradictory] (23) A few yogis are intuitive [sub-contrary, sub-altern] (24) Diamonds are always precious [contrary, contradictory] (25) No circles are triangles [contradictory, sub-altern] (26) Theists are always religious [contrary, contradictory] (27) Some doctors are not rich [sub-contrary, sub-altern] (28) Every journalist is present [contradictory, contrary] (29) No donkeys are fast runners [contradictory, sub-altern] (30) Any professor is a postgraduate [sub-altern, contrary]
Answer: (21) O (Some students do not study). I: Some students study. A: All students study. (22) A. E: No pilots are smart. O: Some pilots are not smart. (23) I. O: A few yogis are not intuitive. A: All yogis are intuitive. (24) A. E: No diamonds are precious. O: Some diamonds are not precious. (25) E. I: Some circles are triangles. O: Some circles are not triangles. (26) A. E: No theists are religious. O: Some theists are not religious. (27) O. I: Some doctors are rich. E: No doctors are rich. (28) A. O: Some journalists are not present. E: No journalist is present. (29) E. I: Some donkeys are fast runners. O: Some donkeys are not fast runners. (30) A. I: Some professors are postgraduates. E: No professor is a postgraduate.
9. Q.8 (1–15) Converse and obverse: (1) All Indians are patriotic (2) No managers are engineers (3) Most actors are famous (4) Some flowers are not fragrant (5) Every exam is challenging (6) Not a single classroom is bright (7) Some leaders are social reformers (8) A few leaves are not green (9) Any attendance is mandatory (10) Many mobile games are addictive (11) Some taxis are not black (12) Toys are always colourful (13) Salesmen are never introverts (14) Some singers are not dancers (15) Any professor is knowledgeable
Answer: (1) C: Some patriotic people are Indians. O: No Indians are non-patriotic. (2) C: No engineers are managers. O: All managers are non-engineers. (3) C: Some famous people are actors. O: Most actors are not non-famous. (4) C: not possible (O). O: Some flowers are non-fragrant. (5) C: Some challenging things are exams. O: No exam is non-challenging. (6) C: No bright places are classrooms. O: All classrooms are non-bright. (7) C: Some social reformers are leaders. O: Some leaders are not non-social reformers. (8) C: not possible. O: A few leaves are non-green. (9) C: Some mandatory things are attendance. O: No attendance is non-mandatory. (10) C: Some addictive things are mobile games. O: Many mobile games are not non-addictive. (11) C: not possible. O: Some taxis are non-black. (12) C: Some colourful things are toys. O: No toys are non-colourful. (13) C: No introverts are salesmen. O: All salesmen are non-introverts. (14) C: not possible. O: Some singers are non-dancers. (15) C: Some knowledgeable people are professors. O: No professor is non-knowledgeable.
10. Q.8 (16–30): (16) Some arguments are valid (17) Not even one lady is old (18) Most highways are broad (19) Some families are not nuclear (20) All sportsmen are energetic (21) No illiterates are employed (22) Some websites are informative (23) Some pens are not blue (24) Efforts are never wasted (25) Every proposition is a sentence (26) Some actors are great scientists (27) A few artists are feminists (28) No social workers are managing directors (29) All medicines are not bitter (30) Not a single radio jockey is a football player
Answer: (16) C: Some valid things are arguments. O: Some arguments are not non-valid. (17) C: No old persons are ladies. O: All ladies are non-old. (18) C: Some broad things are highways. O: Most highways are not non-broad. (19) C: not possible. O: Some families are non-nuclear. (20) C: Some energetic people are sportsmen. O: No sportsmen are non-energetic. (21) C: No employed persons are illiterates. O: All illiterates are non-employed. (22) C: Some informative things are websites. O: Some websites are not non-informative. (23) C: not possible. O: Some pens are non-blue. (24) C: No wasted things are efforts. O: All efforts are non-wasted. (25) C: Some sentences are propositions. O: No proposition is a non-sentence. (26) C: Some great scientists are actors. O: Some actors are not non-great scientists. (27) C: Some feminists are artists. O: A few artists are not non-feminists. (28) C: No managing directors are social workers. O: All social workers are non-managing directors. (29) O: no converse. O: Some medicines are non-bitter. (30) C: No football players are radio jockeys. O: All radio jockeys are non-football players.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. In which proposition are both terms distributed?
Answer: B. E excludes the whole of S from the whole of P.
2. A and E are…
Answer: B. Both universal, differ in quality.
3. I and O are…
Answer: B. Both particular, differ in quality.
4. If E is true, its contradictory I is…
Answer: C. Contradictories always differ.
5. If A is false, its contrary E is…
Answer: A. Contraries may both be false.
6. The converse of 'No birds are reptiles' is…
Answer: A. E converts simply.
7. The obverse of 'All judges are fair' is…
Answer: B. A becomes E with non-P.
8. 'Hardly anyone reads newspapers now' is an…
Answer: C. Book convention: 'hardly' signals O.
9. Singular affirmative propositions are treated as…
Answer: A. The whole subject is referred to.
10. Which proposition has no converse?
Answer: B. It would break the rule of distribution.
11. 'If metal is heated, it expands' is a…
Answer: C. Condition plus consequence.
12. Immediate inference draws its conclusion from…
Answer: B. No mediating premise.
13. In obversion the quantity…
Answer: A. Only the quality changes.
14. The relation between A and I is…
Answer: B. Same quality, differ in quantity.
15. A term is distributed when it refers to…
Answer: A. That is the definition.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Traditional Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Traditional Logic the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 60 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Traditional Logic” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Traditional Logic.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Traditional Logic” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.