TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 54–66
Reasoning tests in entrance exams often give you two statements and ask what follows from them. That is the categorical syllogism, Aristotle's model of deductive reasoning. This chapter covers its structure (major, minor and middle terms), its four figures, the rules a valid syllogism must obey and the formal fallacy each broken rule produces. It ends with a comparison with the five-membered Nyaya syllogism of Indian logic. All 30 Q.7 arguments are diagnosed below.
A categorical syllogism is a deductive, mediate inference made of three categorical propositions: two premises and a conclusion. Together they contain exactly three terms, and each term appears in exactly two of the propositions. The conclusion follows from the two premises taken jointly, and it cannot assert more than they do. Its validity depends only on its form, not on its content.
The predicate of the conclusion is the major term (P), its subject the minor term (S), and the term found in both premises but not in the conclusion the middle term (M). The premise with P is the major premise (written first in logical form) and the premise with S is the minor premise.
The figure depends on where M stands. Figure I: M–P, S–M. Figure II: P–M, S–M (M predicate in both). Figure III: M–P, M–S (M subject in both). Figure IV: P–M, M–S. Tradition says Galen added the fourth figure.
The book's rules come in three groups. Structure: exactly three propositions and exactly three terms. Distribution: the middle term must be distributed at least once, and no term may be distributed in the conclusion unless it is distributed in its premise. Quality: no conclusion from two negative premises; if one premise is negative the conclusion must be negative; if both premises are affirmative the conclusion must be affirmative. Breaking a rule is a formal fallacy: argument of sorites, four terms (equivocation), undistributed middle, illicit minor, illicit major, negative (exclusive) premises, or an affirmative conclusion from a negative premise.
In Indian logic, inference (anumana) is knowledge that follows other knowledge. It may be for oneself (svartha) or for others (parartha). The Nyaya syllogism has five members: Pratijna, Hetu, Udaharan, Upanaya and Nigaman. Its three terms are paksha (minor), sadhya (major) and hetu or linga (middle). It joins deduction and induction through the example (udaharan) and is suited to debate, while Aristotle's three-line syllogism is purely formal and suited to testing validity.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Syllogism” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Put in logical form, name the figure and test: 'Some teachers are poets, and all poets are dreamers, so some teachers are dreamers.'
Answer: Valid syllogism in Figure I (mood AII). No rule is broken.
Test: 'All doctors are graduates. No nurses are doctors. Therefore no nurses are graduates.'
Answer: Invalid: fallacy of illicit major. (A nurse could still be some other kind of graduate.)
| Rule | If it is broken | Quick check |
|---|---|---|
| Exactly three propositions | Argument of sorites (book's term) | Count the statements |
| Exactly three terms, each used in one sense | Four terms / equivocation (ambiguous major, middle, minor) | Watch for words with two meanings |
| Middle term distributed at least once | Undistributed middle | Is M the subject of A/E, or the predicate of E/O, anywhere? |
| S distributed in conclusion ⇒ distributed in minor premise | Illicit minor | Check the subject of a universal conclusion |
| P distributed in conclusion ⇒ distributed in major premise | Illicit major | Check the predicate of a negative conclusion |
| Not both premises negative | Negative (exclusive) premises | Two of E/O |
| A negative premise needs a negative conclusion | Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise | E/O premise but A/I conclusion |
| Both premises affirmative ⇒ affirmative conclusion | Negative conclusion from affirmative premises | A/I premises but E/O conclusion |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (1–16).
Answer: (1) Mediate. (2) Three. (3) Predicate. (4) Middle. (5) Major. (6) Conclusion. (7) Formal. (8) Equivocation. (9) illicit Minor. (10) Subject. (11) Argument of Sorites. (12) five. (13) three. (14) Pratijna. (15) Hetu. (16) Aristotelian.
2. Q.2 True or false (1–15); Q.3 Match (major, minor, middle with hetu, sadhya, paksha); Q.4 Logical terms (1–17).
Answer: Q.2: (1) False: the order of statement does not matter. (2) True. (3) False: AAA in Figure I is valid; M is distributed as the subject of the major premise. (4) False: it depends on form. (5) True. (6) False: if one premise is negative the conclusion must be negative. (7) True. (8) True. (9) True. (10) False: in A and I the relation is affirmative. (11) True. (12) False: that is Udaharan. (13) False: that is Upanaya. (14) True. (15) True: the universal rule is called vyapti (it is stated in the Udaharan). Q.3: (1)–(b) Sadhya, (2)–(c) Paksha, (3)–(a) Hetu. Q.4: (1) Categorical syllogism. (2) Fallacy of equivocation (four terms). (3) Major term. (4) Minor term. (5) Middle term. (6) Major premise. (7) Minor premise. (8) Anumana. (9) Parartha (inference for others). (10) Pratijna. (11) Hetu. (12) Udaharan. (13) Upanaya. (14) Nigaman. (15) Sadhya. (16) Paksha. (17) Hetu (linga).
3. Q.5 Give reasons (1–5); Q.6 Explain (1–6); activity boxes: (a) 'No men are quadruped; some men are tall; so no tall beings are quadruped' (b) 'All Indians are Asians; no Asians are American; so all Americans are Indians' (c) complete the rules–fallacies table (d) rearrange 'Hard-workers are successful; ambitious persons are hard-workers; so ambitious persons are successful' to show undistributed middle, illicit major and illicit minor.
Answer: Q.5: (1) M must link S and P; if it is never taken in full, S and P may be tied to different parts of it. (2) Two exclusions say only what S and P are not related to, so nothing joins them. (3) Otherwise the conclusion says more about that term than the premises do, which a deduction may not. (4) Pratijna and Hetu are repeated in Nigaman and Upanaya, so three members carry the argument. (5) The example shows the universal rule is grounded in observation, making the inference inductive as well as deductive. Q.6: see the notes (rule of structure, undistributed middle, illicit process, four figures, likeness and difference with Nyaya). Boxes: (a) Illicit minor: 'tall beings' is undistributed as the predicate of the I premise but distributed as the subject of the E conclusion. (b) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise: the minor premise is E, yet the conclusion is A. (c) Structure: three propositions → argument of sorites; three terms → four terms (equivocation). Distribution: middle distributed → undistributed middle; minor rule → illicit minor; major rule → illicit major. Quality: two negatives → negative premises; negative premise → affirmative conclusion from a negative premise. (d) Undistributed middle: All successful people are hard-workers; all ambitious persons are hard-workers; so all ambitious persons are successful. Illicit major: All hard-workers are successful; no ambitious persons are hard-workers; so no ambitious persons are successful. Illicit minor: All hard-workers are successful; all hard-workers are ambitious; so all ambitious persons are successful.
4. Q.7 (1–10) Recognise the formal fallacy: (1) Indians–reformers–brave (2) wrong things–calculations (3) TV channels–magazines (4) athletes–film stars (5) water–ice–liquid (6) sportsmen–lazy men (7) grapes–mangoes (8) animals–men–tall (9) wooden things–boxes (10) mammals–fish
Answer: (1) Illicit minor: 'brave' is undistributed as the predicate of the A premise but distributed as the subject of the A conclusion. (2) Undistributed middle: 'wrong things' is the subject of an O and the predicate of an A, undistributed both times. (3) Illicit major: 'TV channel' is distributed as the predicate of the E conclusion but undistributed as the subject of the I premise. (4) Negative premises (E and O). (5) Four terms (ambiguous middle): 'water' means liquid water in one premise and the substance H₂O in the other. Ice is water only in the second sense. (6) Illicit major: 'well groomed' is distributed in the O conclusion but undistributed as the predicate of the A premise. (7) Negative premises (O and E). There is also an illicit major, since 'grapes' is undistributed as the subject of the O premise. (8) Illicit major: 'animals' is undistributed as the subject of the I premise but distributed as the predicate of the O conclusion. (9) Illicit minor: 'boxes' is undistributed in the I premise but distributed in the A conclusion. (10) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise: the minor premise is E, but the conclusion is I.
5. Q.7 (11–20): (11) birds–colourful–ugly (12) enthusiasts–poor judgement–mistakes–deserve (13) potters–artists–accountants (14) circles–triangles–geometrical figures (15) end of life–death–perfection (16) Europeans–black–short (17) Indians–rich–generous (18) philosophers–ordinary men–wise (19) fishes–swimmers–marine animals (20) oranges–sour–ripe
Answer: (11) Negative premises (O and E). (12) Argument of sorites: four propositions. (As a chain it actually works: some enthusiasts show poor judgement, those who show poor judgement make frequent mistakes, and none who make frequent mistakes deserve. So some enthusiasts do not deserve. It is simply not a single syllogism.) (13) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise. (14) Undistributed middle: 'geometrical figures' is the predicate of two A premises. (15) Four terms (ambiguous middle): 'end' means goal in the first premise and termination in the second. (16) Negative premises (E and O). (17) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise: 'All rich people are not generous' is taken as O. There is also an illicit minor, since 'rich people' is undistributed in the O premise. (18) Illicit major: 'wise' is undistributed as the predicate of the A premise but distributed in the E conclusion. (19) Illicit minor: 'those which swim' is undistributed as the predicate of the A premise but distributed in the A conclusion. (20) Undistributed middle: 'oranges' is the subject of two particular premises. There is also an illicit major, since 'sour' is undistributed in the I premise but distributed in the E conclusion.
6. Q.7 (21–30): (21) reporters–impartial–correct news (22) cats–dogs–wild (23) games–interesting–enjoyable (24) games–interesting–challenging (25) men–idiots–animals–rational (26) hard-workers–employees–paid (27) Indians–Americans–Russians (28) Indians–brain workers–software engineers (29) illiterates–graduates–teachers (30) men–rational–mortal–life
Answer: (21) Argument of sorites: four propositions. (22) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise: the minor premise is E, but the conclusion is A. (23) Illicit major: 'interesting' is undistributed as the predicate of the A premise but distributed as the predicate of the O conclusion. (24) Undistributed middle: 'games' is the subject of two particular premises. There is also an illicit minor, since 'challenging things' is undistributed in the I premise but distributed in the E conclusion. (25) Argument of sorites: four propositions (and more than three terms). (26) Illicit minor: 'employees' is undistributed as the subject of the O premise but distributed as the subject of the E conclusion. (27) Negative premises (two E). (28) Affirmative conclusion from a negative premise: the minor premise is O, but the conclusion is A. (29) Negative premises (E and O). (30) Argument of sorites: four propositions. As a chain it is valid; it is just not a single syllogism.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. The predicate of the conclusion is the…
Answer: B. P is the major term.
2. The middle term appears in…
Answer: A. It links S and P.
3. 'All metals are heavy; all stones are heavy; so all stones are metals' commits…
Answer: A. 'Heavy' is the predicate of two A propositions.
4. In Figure II the middle term is…
Answer: A. P–M, S–M.
5. A syllogism with two negative premises commits…
Answer: C. Two exclusions link nothing.
6. 'Any bell rings; some rings are beautiful…' commits…
Answer: C. 'Rings' changes its meaning.
7. If one premise is negative, the conclusion must be…
Answer: D. Rule of quality.
8. Which term is distributed in an O proposition?
Answer: C. Some S is not P excludes S from all of P.
9. In the Nyaya syllogism, 'Hetu' is the…
Answer: A. Because it has smoke.
10. The Nyaya major term is called…
Answer: A. What is to be proved (fire).
11. 'All fishes are marine animals; all fishes swim; so all swimmers are marine animals' commits…
Answer: B. 'Swimmers' is undistributed in the premise but distributed in the conclusion.
12. A syllogism's validity depends on…
Answer: C. It is a formal inference.
13. Udaharan states…
Answer: A. Where there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen.
14. The premise containing the minor term is the…
Answer: D. By definition.
15. 'No potters are accountants; some artists are potters; so some artists are accountants' commits…
Answer: D. Negative premise, affirmative conclusion.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Syllogism” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Syllogism the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 55 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Syllogism” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Syllogism.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Syllogism” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.