TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 78–86
Every science project starts with 'I think this happens because…'. That guess is a hypothesis. This chapter explains what a hypothesis is, its six characteristics, how hypotheses come to scientists (imagination, hard work, knowledge, insight, chance, enumeration and analogy), the seven conditions of a good hypothesis, and how hypotheses are verified directly or indirectly. It closes with the limits of verification, where the fallacy of affirming the consequent from Chapter 2 returns.
A hypothesis is a tentative, provisional supposition put forward to explain facts that we cannot yet explain. The word comes from Greek: hypo (under) and tithenai (to place). Scientific inquiry begins when a scientist feels a problem, and the hypothesis gives the inquiry its direction by telling the scientist what to observe and what to test.
Characteristics: a hypothesis is an important stage of investigation, an attempt at explanation, provisional, an organising principle that reveals order among scattered facts (Newton's gravitation linked falling bodies, planets and tides), a result of rational activity, and a result of keen, creative imagination (Appert's sealed, heated jars of food).
Hypotheses are suggested by creative imagination (Newton), painstaking work (Kepler is said to have tried nineteen wrong hypotheses), adequate and wide knowledge (Pasteur and the silkworm disease), insight (Archimedes in the bath), chance used by a trained mind (Fleming and penicillin), and by simple enumeration and analogy (Lowell's guess about life on Mars).
A good hypothesis is relevant, self-consistent, testable (verifiable at least in principle), compatible with established knowledge (though a strong new hypothesis may overturn an old law, as Copernicus overturned Ptolemy), has explanatory power, has predictive power and is simple, making the fewest independent assumptions.
Verification checks whether a hypothesis agrees with facts. Direct verification observes or experiments on what the hypothesis names (Neptune seen through a telescope; argon isolated from air). Indirect verification deduces consequences and tests them (the Kon-Tiki voyage). Verification shows that a hypothesis explains the facts, not that it is the only explanation; arguing 'if H then C; C; so H' is the fallacy of affirming the consequent. Proof needs 'if and only if H then C'.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Hypothesis” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Test this hypothesis against the conditions: 'My phone battery drains fast because an invisible spirit uses it at night.'
Answer: A bad hypothesis: irrelevant, untestable, not compatible with established knowledge and not simple. 'A background app drains the battery' is a good rival because it can be tested at once.
Show by truth table that 'H ⊃ C, C, ∴ H' is invalid but 'H ≡ C, C, ∴ H' is valid.
Answer: With '⊃' the argument affirms the consequent and is invalid (row H false, C true). With '≡' it is valid. That is why proof needs 'if and only if'.
| Case | What happened | Illustrates |
|---|---|---|
| Jenner (1796) | Milkmaids with cowpox escaped smallpox; cowpox matter tested as protection | Hypothesis as a tentative solution |
| Appert (1795–1810) | Sealed, heated jars kept food from spoiling | Creative imagination |
| Kepler (1609) | Many failed guesses before elliptical orbits | Painstaking work |
| Pasteur (1865) | Solved silkworm disease with general knowledge of disease | Adequate and wide knowledge |
| Fleming (1928) | Mould killed germs on a spoiled plate; penicillin | Chance used by a trained mind |
| Galle, Le Verrier (1846) | Neptune found near the predicted spot | Direct verification by observation |
| Rayleigh and Ramsay (1894) | Argon isolated from atmospheric nitrogen | Direct verification by experiment |
| Heyerdahl (1947) | Raft voyage from Peru to Polynesia in 101 days | Indirect verification and its limits |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (1–5).
Answer: (1) Hypothesis. (2) Indirect. (3) Simple enumeration. (4) Tentative. (5) Verification.
2. Q.2 True or false (1–5); Q.3 Match the columns.
Answer: Q.2: (1) False: a hypothesis must be consistent, not inconsistent. (2) False: directly verified hypotheses are empirical (instantial); theoretical ones are verified indirectly. (3) True. (4) True. (5) True. Q.3: (1) Origin of hypothesis – (b) keen imagination. (2) Conditions of good hypothesis – (c) verifiability. (3) Analogy – (d) suggests a hypothesis to the scientist. (4) Non-instantial hypothesis – (a) indirectly verified.
3. Q.4 Give logical terms (1–5).
Answer: (1) Relevant hypothesis. (2) Indirect verification. (3) Hypothesis. (4) Insight. (5) Simple hypothesis.
4. Q.5 Explain: (1) direct verification by observation, (2) direct verification by experiment, (3) indirect verification, with examples; (4) characteristics of hypothesis.
Answer: (1) We look directly at what the hypothesis says exists. Uranus did not follow its calculated orbit, so astronomers supposed an unknown planet was pulling it. Le Verrier calculated where it should be, and in 1846 Galle at the Berlin Observatory saw Neptune there. (2) A laboratory experiment shows the thing the hypothesis names. Rayleigh found that nitrogen from air was denser than nitrogen made from compounds and supposed an unknown gas was present; with Ramsay he isolated argon (1894), which explained the difference. (3) When H cannot be checked directly, we deduce its consequences and test them. Hypothesis: the South Sea islanders came from South America. Consequence: people must have been able to cross by primitive raft. Test: Heyerdahl's Kon-Tiki raft reached Polynesia in 101 days (1947). This shows the hypothesis may be true, not that it is true. (Genetic evidence now points mainly to an Asian origin.) (4) Important stage (the Uranus problem); attempt at explanation (Jenner's cowpox idea); provisional; organising principle (gravitation); result of rational activity; result of creative imagination (Appert).
5. Q.6 (1)–(2) Explain with illustrations the factors that suggest a hypothesis / the origin of hypothesis.
Answer: There are no fixed rules for forming a hypothesis, but the history of discovery shows six sources. (1) Keen and creative imagination: Newton saw in a falling apple the force that also holds the Moon. (2) Painstaking work: Kepler is said to have tried nineteen hypotheses before elliptical orbits. (3) Adequate and wide knowledge: Pasteur solved the silkworm disease through his general knowledge of disease. (4) Insight: Archimedes' sudden idea in the bath about displaced water. (5) Chance used by a trained mind: Fleming's spoiled culture plate (1928). Because he had already studied lysozyme, he saw the meaning of a germ-free ring around the mould, which led to penicillin. (6) Simple enumeration and analogy: from Earth–Mars resemblances Lowell suggested life on Mars, a hypothesis still unconfirmed in 2026.
6. Q.6 (3) Explain direct verification with examples; (4) explain with illustrations the conditions of a good hypothesis.
Answer: (3) Direct verification checks a hypothesis by appealing to facts it refers to. By observation: Neptune seen in 1846 where it was predicted. By experiment: argon isolated from atmospheric nitrogen by Rayleigh and Ramsay. Hypotheses checked this way are instantial or empirical, and leave little doubt. (4) Relevance: the facts must follow from it; 'tight trousers straighten thigh bones' does not explain bone shape. Self-consistency: 'living ghost' or 'weightless matter' contradict themselves. Testability: it must be capable of being shown true or false, at least in principle (life on Earth will one day end). Compatibility: it should fit established laws, although a strong new theory can replace an old one (Copernicus over Ptolemy). Explanatory power: gravitation explains apples, planets and tides. Predictive power: it yields new consequences to check. Simplicity: fewest independent assumptions, so the Sun-centred system is preferred.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. A hypothesis is best described as…
Answer: D. It is provisional.
2. 'Hypo' in hypothesis means…
Answer: D. Tithenai means to place.
3. Gravitation linking falling bodies, planets and tides shows a hypothesis is…
Answer: C. It reveals order among facts.
4. Kepler's many failed guesses illustrate…
Answer: B. Long effort before success.
5. Archimedes' bath illustrates…
Answer: B. A sudden flash.
6. Fleming's penicillin illustrates…
Answer: B. He knew about lysozyme.
7. Lowell's claim of life on Mars came from…
Answer: C. Based on resemblances.
8. 'Weightless matter' fails which condition?
Answer: A. It contradicts itself.
9. A hypothesis about ghosts fails mainly on…
Answer: A. It cannot be verified.
10. Copernicus was preferred to Ptolemy because his hypothesis was…
Answer: A. Fewer independent assumptions.
11. The discovery of argon is an example of…
Answer: C. The gas was isolated in the lab.
12. The Kon-Tiki voyage is an example of…
Answer: D. A deduced consequence was tested.
13. A hypothesis verified only indirectly is called…
Answer: A. Also called theoretical.
14. 'If H then C; C; so H' commits…
Answer: A. C may have another cause.
15. Proof of a hypothesis needs the form…
Answer: A. The biconditional rules out rivals.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Hypothesis” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Hypothesis the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 50 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Hypothesis” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Hypothesis.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Hypothesis” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.