TalentJR apps
Textbook: Logic – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 67–77
Every science lab report you write rests on two things: what you saw and what you tested. This chapter asks why we may trust a general law when we have checked only some cases. It covers the formal grounds of induction (uniformity of nature and causation), and then the material grounds: observation and experiment. You will learn how observation differs from perception, what makes an observation good, the fallacies of non-observation and mal-observation, the three kinds of variable in an experiment, and seven differences between observation and experiment.
Induction moves from checked cases to all cases, from the known to the unknown. This jump from 'some' to 'all' is the inductive leap, and it makes the conclusion probable rather than certain. Two kinds of grounds justify it. The formal grounds are the principle of uniformity of nature (nature repeats itself under similar conditions) and the principle of causation (the same cause always produces the same effect). The material grounds, observation and experiment, supply the facts that make a law materially true.
Perception is simply noticing whatever reaches our senses, with no aim and no choice. Observation is perception that is selective and has a purpose. So all observation is perception, but not all perception is observation. Observation is purposive, it selects significant facts and significant aspects of a fact, it sets aside illusory appearances, and it uses instruments to extend the senses.
Good observation needs four conditions: the right mental set (curiosity, alertness, no prejudice, plus checking by others through public verifiability), awareness of the limits of sense organs and instruments, attention to external conditions such as fog or poor light, and training in the techniques of observation.
Faulty observation gives two fallacies. Non-observation means leaving out relevant facts. It happens either through neglect of instances (narrow experience, poor physical conditions, bias) or through neglect of operative conditions (the real cause is overlooked, as with Digby's sympathetic powder). Mal-observation means misreading what is seen, as when a rope is taken for a snake. Its causes are poor physical conditions, lack of experience and a peculiar state of mind.
An experiment is observation under conditions that the investigator creates and controls. It studies the effect of an independent variable on a dependent variable while the relevant (controlled) variables are held constant. It is deliberate, uses an artificial setting, varies conditions systematically and can be repeated. Observation is natural, wider in scope, works from cause to effect and from effect to cause, and cannot be repeated at will. Experiment is narrower, works only from cause to effect and is more objective.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Grounds of Induction” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Classify each as perception or observation: (a) You notice it is raining while reading. (b) A meteorologist reads the rain gauge at 8:30 a.m. daily. (c) A coach notes how many seconds each runner needs for 100 m.
Answer: (a) Perception; (b) and (c) observation.
Name the fallacy: 'Every time our school team wore the blue jersey we won, so the jersey brings victory.' The team also practised daily before those matches.
Answer: Fallacy of non-observation by neglect of operative conditions. The jersey has been mistaken for the cause; practice was overlooked.
A student tests whether the amount of salt changes the boiling point of water. Name the three kinds of variable.
Answer: Independent: amount of salt. Dependent: boiling temperature. Controlled: water volume, vessel, flame, pressure, all kept the same.
| Point | Observation | Experiment |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Selective perception of facts with a purpose | Observation under conditions controlled by the investigator |
| Setting | Natural: events as they occur | Artificial: conditions arranged in advance |
| Role of the scientist | Slave of nature: must wait | Master: changes conditions at will |
| Direction of reasoning | Cause → effect and effect → cause | Cause → effect only |
| Scope | Wider: possible in every field | Narrower: not always possible or ethical |
| Repetition | Cannot be repeated at will | Can be repeated anywhere, any time |
| Bias | More open to personal bias (subjective) | Little room for bias (objective) |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (1–14).
Answer: (1) Material. (2) Observation. (3) Faithful. (4) Mal-observation. (5) Observation. (6) Perception. (7) Impartial. (8) Non-observation. (9) Mal-observation. (10) Artificial. (11) Experiment. (12) Natural. (13) Bias. (14) Illusion.
2. Q.1 Fill in the blanks (15–27).
Answer: (15) Experiment. (16) Experiment. (17) Observation. (18) Observation. (19) Independent variable. (20) Mal-observation. (21) Experiment. (22) Controlled. (23) Observation. (24) Observation. (25) Non-observation. (26) Inductive leap. (27) Formal.
3. Q.2 State whether true or false (1–21).
Answer: (1) False: observation is purposive. (2) False: perception has no definite purpose. (3) True. (4) False: neglecting relevant circumstances or conditions is neglect of operative conditions, not of instances. (5) True. (6) False: mal-observation is misinterpreting facts; neglecting instances is non-observation. (7) True. (8) False: every experiment involves observation, under controlled conditions. (9) False: the observer has no control; that belongs to the experimenter. (10) True. (11) True. (12) False: isolating factors is possible only in experiment. (13) True: for example, experiments that would harm people. (14) False: observation is natural and experiment is artificial. (15) True. (16) True. (17) True. (18) True: observation is needed before an experiment is planned. (19) False: experiment goes only from cause to effect. (20) True. (21) False: experiment is a material ground.
4. Q.3 Match the columns; Q.4 Give logical terms (1–4).
Answer: Q.3: (1) Mal-observation – (a) misinterpretation of sense data. (2) Non-observation – (b) neglecting relevant facts. (3) Observation and experiment – (d) material grounds of induction. (4) The principle of causation – (c) formal grounds of induction. Q.4: (1) Observation. (2) Fallacy of non-observation. (3) Fallacy of mal-observation. (4) Experiment.
5. Q.5 Answer in brief: (1) Differentiate observation and perception. (2) Conditions of good observation. (3) Fallacy of non-observation. (4) Fallacy of mal-observation. (5) Characteristics of experiment.
Answer: (1) Perception is becoming aware of whatever reaches our senses, without aim or choice; observation is selective perception with a definite purpose. Everything observed is perceived, but not everything perceived is observed. Example: hearing traffic noise vs a researcher counting cars at a junction for a survey. (2) A proper mental set (curiosity, attention, patience, no prejudice; others verify the record); healthy senses and awareness of the limits of senses and instruments; attention to external conditions such as fog or glare; training in what, when, where and how to observe and which instrument to use. (3) Overlooking relevant facts. (a) Neglect of instances, through narrow experience, unfavourable conditions or bias: remembering only the days a 'lucky pen' worked. (b) Neglect of operative conditions, missing the real cause: Digby's powder, where cleaning the wound did the healing. (4) Misreading sense impressions, taking one thing for another: a rope seen as a snake. Causes: physical conditions (mirage), lack of experience (a baby and its reflection), mental state (fear makes a shirt look like a ghost). (5) It is deliberately undertaken; it creates an artificial situation that removes obstructing conditions (coin and feather in a vacuum); it varies one condition at a time while holding the relevant variables constant; it can be repeated by anyone to confirm the result.
6. Q.6 Answer the following: (1) What is observation? Explain its characteristics. (2) What is experiment? Explain the nature of experiment. (3) Explain the differences between observation and experiment.
Answer: (1) Observation is selective perception of facts with a definite purpose. Characteristics: purposive (astronomers searched for Neptune with a definite aim); selects significant facts relevant to the hypothesis; selects significant aspects of a fact (a doctor notes pulse and temperature); sets aside illusory aspects (a stick looks bent in water because of refraction); uses instruments such as the telescope, microscope and X-ray to extend the senses. (2) Experiment is observation under conditions created and controlled by the investigator. Its purpose is to find the effect of one factor on another. Independent variable: the factor changed (type of soap). Dependent variable: the measured result (dirt left on the cloth). Relevant or controlled variables: water amount, water temperature, washing time, amount of soap and amount of dirt, all kept constant. (3) Definition (selective perception vs controlled observation); setting (natural vs artificial); control (slave of nature vs master); direction (both ways vs cause to effect only); scope (wider vs narrower, and observation is needed before, during and after an experiment); repetition (not possible at will vs possible anywhere, any time); bias (more subjective vs more objective). See the table above.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. The jump from 'some' cases to 'all' cases is called the…
Answer: C. Induction concludes beyond its evidence.
2. Which pair are the formal grounds of induction?
Answer: A. They justify generalising in principle.
3. Observation and experiment are the… grounds of induction.
Answer: D. They supply the facts.
4. Observation differs from perception because it is…
Answer: D. Perception has no aim or selection.
5. A doctor notes a patient's pulse and temperature, not the colour of his shirt. This shows observation is…
Answer: B. Only the relevant aspects are noted.
6. A rope taken for a snake is the fallacy of…
Answer: B. The impression is misread.
7. Digby's sympathetic powder illustrates…
Answer: C. Keeping the wound clean was overlooked.
8. A baby thinks its reflection is another baby. The cause of the error is…
Answer: D. Mal-observation due to inexperience.
9. Experiment is defined as…
Answer: C. The investigator controls the conditions.
10. In a test of fertilisers on wheat yield, the yield is the…
Answer: D. It is what is measured.
11. In the same test, the amount of water given to each plot is a…
Answer: C. It could affect yield, so it is held constant.
12. Who goes from both cause to effect and effect to cause?
Answer: A. Experiment goes only from cause to effect.
13. Which can be repeated at will?
Answer: A. Conditions are under the experimenter's control.
14. Why does a coin and a feather experiment need a vacuum?
Answer: D. Removing air isolates the effect of weight.
15. Ignoring results that go against your belief is non-observation due to…
Answer: B. A cause of neglect of instances.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Grounds of Induction” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Grounds of Induction the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 45 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Grounds of Induction” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Grounds of Induction.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Grounds of Induction” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.