TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 1–16
What is the world ultimately made of, and how many basic realities are there — one, two or many? This chapter of metaphysics compares the answers of the Indian darshanas (Charvaka, Jaina, Vaisheshika, Bauddha, Sankhya, Advaita Vedanta) and Western thinkers (Parmenides, Heraclitus, Democritus, Plato, Aristotle, Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz, Hegel), sorts them into monism, dualism, pluralism, materialism, idealism and realism, and ends with how modern science describes reality. Every exercise is answered.
Metaphysics asks 'What is?'. Looking at a world full of different things, thinkers guessed that everything comes from a few basic elements. Two questions followed: how many ultimate realities are there (one, two or many) and what is their nature (material, spiritual or both)?
By number, theories are monism (one), dualism (two) and pluralism (many). By nature, they are materialism (only matter is ultimately real), idealism (reality is spiritual or conscious) and realism (both matter and consciousness are real and independent).
A substance is the bearer of qualities, quantity and relations; qualities cannot exist on their own, but a substance stays the same even when its qualities change. India spoke of dravya, the West of substance.
Indian views: Charvaka — materialist pluralism (four elements); Jaina — pluralist realism (jiva and ajiva); Vaisheshika — nine substances, eternal atoms and abhava; Buddhism — dependent origination and impermanence; Sankhya — dualist realism (Purusha and Prakriti); Advaita Vedanta — idealist monism (only Brahman is real, three levels of reality).
Western views: Parmenides (one, unchanging being) versus Heraclitus (constant change); Empedocles and Democritus (pluralism, atoms); Plato's two worlds; Aristotle's substance and categories; Descartes' dualism, Spinoza's monism (God or nature), Leibniz's monads and Hegel's dialectical Absolute. Science today explains reality in terms of particles, forces and energy, and raises its own ethical questions.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “There is something, but what it is?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Your school bag is blue today; you paint it red next week. Use the idea of substance to say whether it is the same bag.
Answer: Only a quality changed. The bag — the substance that carries colour, size and shape — is the same bag, just as a board stays a board whatever its colour.
Why does a dream count as 'pratibhasika sat' and not simply as 'nothing'?
Answer: The dream was really experienced, so it is not pure nothing; but it is cancelled as soon as we wake. In the same way, says Shankaracharya, the waking world is real for daily life but is cancelled by knowledge of Brahman, which alone is never cancelled.
Use Hegel's dialectical pattern on a class debate about mobile phones in school.
Answer: A better third position emerges: phones are kept switched off in class but allowed for set study tasks. Later this rule may meet its own objection, and the debate moves on — that is the dialectical pattern.
| School / thinker | Number and nature of reality | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Charvaka | Many, material (4 elements) | Materialism + pluralism; no soul |
| Jaina | Many: jiva and ajiva | Pluralism + realism |
| Vaisheshika | Nine substances; eternal atoms | Pluralism + realism; abhava |
| Bauddha | Dependent origination; all impermanent | No permanent substance |
| Sankhya | Two: Purusha and Prakriti | Dualism + realism |
| Advaita Vedanta | One: Brahman | Monism + idealism |
| Parmenides / Heraclitus | One unchanging being / one ever-changing fire | Both monists |
| Democritus | Infinite atoms in the void | Materialism + pluralism |
| Plato / Aristotle | World of forms / substance in this world | Two worlds vs one world |
| Descartes | Mind and matter | Dualism + realism |
| Spinoza / Hegel | God or Nature / the Absolute | Monism |
| Leibniz | Infinite monads | Pluralism + idealism |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks: (1) Experience of ___ objects is about form, colour, shape, type etc. (material / imaginary / philosophical) (2) ___ darshana classifies all things into jiva–ajiva (Sankhya / Jain / Nyaya) (3) Instruments and experiments are necessary to acquire ___ knowledge (subjective / inter-subjective / objective) (4) According to Plato, the existence of the visible world depends on the world of ___ (forms / reflections / material objects) (5) According to Descartes, corporeal and incorporeal substances have ___ qualities (opposite / inter-dependent / inter-relational).
Answer: (1) Material. (2) Jain. (3) Objective. (4) Forms. (5) Opposite.
2. Q.2 Find the odd one out: (1) Thales, Anaximenes, Heraclitus, Descartes (2) Materialism, Realism, Asatkaryavada, Chidvada.
Answer: (1) Descartes — the others are pre-Socratic Greek monists; Descartes is a modern dualist. (2) Asatkaryavada — it is a theory of causation (the effect does not pre-exist in the cause); the other three are theories about the nature of reality.
3. Q.3 True or false, with reason: (1) Leibniz was a monist. (2) According to Parmenides reality is changing. (3) Charvaka advocates materialism. (4) Shankaracharya does not consider pratibhasika sat as ultimate reality.
Answer: (1) False — Leibniz was a pluralist: reality consists of infinitely many monads. (2) False — for Parmenides reality is one, eternal and unchanging; change is unreal. (3) True — Charvaka holds that only the four material elements exist and consciousness arises from matter. (4) True — dream reality is cancelled on waking; only paramarthika sat (Brahman) is ultimate.
4. Q.4 Complete the concept maps: (1) three levels of reality by Shankaracharya (2) material elements accepted by Charvaka (3) elements of Prakriti.
Answer: (1) Pratibhasika sat (dream experience), vyavaharika sat (waking experience), paramarthika sat (knowledge of Brahman). (2) Earth, water, fire, air. (3) Sattva, rajas, tamas (the three gunas); its evolutes are mahat, ahankara, manas, five sense organs, five motor organs, five tanmatras and five mahabhutas.
5. Q.5 Answer in 20–25 words: (1) What forces are created by particles in the world? (2) How many substances do the Vaisheshikas accept? Name them. (3) What is Hegel's dialectical method? (4) State the nature of atoms according to Democritus.
Answer: (1) Particles give rise to four forces — gravitational, electromagnetic, and the strong and weak nuclear forces — which shape matter, natural processes and living beings. (2) Nine: earth, water, fire, air, ether, space (dik), time (kala), mind (manas) and soul (atman). (3) Two opposite principles clash and a better third principle arises; it then meets its own opposite, so the Absolute and the universe keep evolving. (4) Atoms are infinite, indivisible, always moving in the void, alike in quality but different in shape and size; they combine and separate mechanically, without any purpose.
6. Q.6 Short notes: (1) Abhava (2) Monism (3) Heraclitus' notion of reality (4) Nature of atoms according to Vaisheshikas (5) Hegel's concept of the Absolute.
Answer: (1) Abhava means non-existence. Vaisheshikas saw that our experience includes both 'this is' and 'that is not' — e.g. noticing that a friend is absent from the exam hall or that a shop has no stock of an item. So knowing absence is real knowledge, and they analysed abhava in detail. (2) Monism holds that there is only one ultimate reality. It can be idealist (Advaita's Brahman, Hegel's Absolute) or neutral or material; Parmenides, Spinoza and the early Greek thinkers who named one first principle are monists. (3) For Heraclitus change is the essence of reality; fire, which keeps burning, consuming fuel and giving off smoke, is its symbol. 'No one steps into the same river twice': there is continuity but no permanence. Harmony arises from the tension of opposites, like a bow held curved by equal pull. (4) If we keep dividing objects we must reach indivisible particles — paramanus. Atoms of earth, water, fire and air combine to make objects and separate to destroy them, but atoms are eternal — neither made nor destroyed — while objects are perishable. They were inferred by reasoning, not seen. (5) The Absolute is one, not dependent on anything, conscious, rational and dynamic. It holds countless potentialities and aims to realise them; in doing so it shows itself as matter and the universe, evolving through dialectics — thesis, antithesis, synthesis.
7. Q.7 Explain with examples: (1) You cannot step into the same river twice. (2) Charvakas accept materialism and pluralism.
Answer: (1) Heraclitus meant that everything is always changing. When you step into a river a second time, new water has flowed in and you too have changed; it looks like the same river only because the flow is continuous. Likewise your body renews its cells and your ideas grow — continuity without permanence. (2) Charvakas say only the four material elements — earth, water, fire and air — are real (pluralism, since there are many basic realities). Everything, even consciousness, comes from their combination (materialism), just as betel leaf, areca nut and lime, none of them red, produce red colour when chewed together. So there is no separate soul and no creator.
8. Q.8 Distinguish between: (1) materialism and idealism (2) dualism and pluralism.
Answer: (1) Materialism says reality is basically matter and consciousness is its by-product (Charvaka, Democritus); idealism says reality is basically consciousness or spirit and matter is secondary or illusory (Advaita, Hegel). Materialism usually rejects soul and God; idealism treats consciousness as the deepest truth. (2) Dualism accepts exactly two independent ultimate realities, usually matter and consciousness (Sankhya's Prakriti and Purusha; Descartes' body and mind). Pluralism accepts many ultimate realities (Charvaka's four elements, Vaisheshika's nine substances, Leibniz's monads, Democritus' atoms).
9. Q.9 Explain in detail Descartes' dualism and Spinoza's monism.
Answer: Descartes defined substance as that which exists independently. Having proved 'I think, therefore I am', he asked what this 'I' is. Thinking, feeling and willing belong to the mind; the body is matter. Matter is extended in space and time and is known by the senses; mind is conscious, takes no space and cannot be sensed. So the world has two substances with opposite qualities — corporeal and incorporeal — which do not depend on each other. Strictly, only God fits the definition fully, since mind and matter are created by God; they are substances in a limited sense. This is dualism and realism. Spinoza accepted the same definition but drew a different conclusion. If a substance depends on nothing, we should be able to know it fully without knowing anything else. Yet to know a pen fully we must know paper, language, writers and readers — every object is tied to others. So no ordinary thing is a true substance; only one infinite, eternal, limitless reality is. Spinoza called it God or Nature and held that everything is part of it (pantheism). It has infinite attributes, of which our limited minds know only a few, such as thought and extension. This is monism.
10. Q.10 Explain completely Sankhya's view about reality.
Answer: Sankhya is dualist and realist. Two eternal, infinite and independent principles exist. Purusha is pure consciousness — consciousness is its essence; it contains no matter, is inactive, unchanging and beyond the physical world. Prakriti is the material principle and the source of all change, activity, creation and destruction. It is made of three gunas — sattva, rajas and tamas — present in different proportions in every object. In its original state the gunas are balanced; contact with Purusha disturbs this balance and evolution begins, from subtle to gross: mahat or buddhi (intellect), ahankara (ego), manas (mind), five sense organs, five motor organs, five tanmatras (subtle elements) and five mahabhutas (gross elements). At dissolution each product returns to its source and the whole world merges back into Prakriti; creation and dissolution keep repeating. Matter has no consciousness and consciousness no matter, yet in human beings body and soul exist together.
11. Q.11 Write a dialogue helping a classmate who believes that the things we see in dreams are real, to understand 'pratibhasika sat'.
Answer: Riya: Last night I won a gold medal in my dream. It felt totally real! Aman: Where is the medal now? Riya: Well… it vanished when I woke up. Aman: So the dream was real while it lasted, but waking up cancelled it? Riya: Yes. Aman: Shankaracharya calls that pratibhasika sat — 'apparent reality'. It is experienced, so it is not pure nothing, but it lasts only as long as the dream. Riya: And the waking world? Aman: That is vyavaharika sat — real for everyday life. But he says that once we know Brahman, even this world is seen as appearance; only paramarthika sat, Brahman, is never cancelled. Riya: So my dream medal was real only at the dream level. Aman: Exactly — the levels are judged by what can cancel what.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. Which darshana classifies all things into jiva and ajiva?
Answer: B. Jiva is living and conscious; ajiva is non-living.
2. Instruments and experiments are needed to gain … knowledge.
Answer: D. Results that anyone can check are objective.
3. According to Plato, the visible world depends on the world of…
Answer: C. Forms are eternal essences known by reason.
4. Descartes' two substances have … qualities.
Answer: B. Mind is unextended and thinking; body is extended and non-thinking.
5. Which thinker is the odd one out?
Answer: A. The other three are pre-Socratic monists; Descartes is a modern dualist.
6. Charvaka is best described as…
Answer: B. Four material elements, no soul.
7. 'You cannot step into the same river twice' expresses the view of…
Answer: D. Reality is constant change.
8. Which is NOT one of the nine Vaisheshika substances?
Answer: B. Motion is a Jaina ajiva category, not a Vaisheshika substance.
9. In Sankhya, Purusha is…
Answer: B. The gunas belong to Prakriti.
10. The reality of the waking world, according to Shankaracharya, is…
Answer: C. Dream reality is pratibhasika; Brahman is paramarthika.
11. Leibniz was a…
Answer: D. Infinite monads with a level of consciousness.
12. Spinoza's view that everything is part of God or Nature is called…
Answer: D. One infinite substance pervades all.
13. Democritus' atoms differ from one another in…
Answer: D. They have no qualitative differences.
14. Which pair is correctly matched?
Answer: D. Forms are Plato's, fire is Heraclitus', monads are Leibniz's.
15. How many fundamental forces does physics recognise today?
Answer: A. Gravitational, electromagnetic, strong nuclear and weak nuclear.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “There is something, but what it is?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise There is something, but what it is? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 45 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “There is something, but what it is?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of There is something, but what it is?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “There is something, but what it is?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.