TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 17–28
Why do things happen, and is the link between a cause and its effect really necessary? This chapter explains material and efficient causes, the Indian debate between satkaryavada (Sankhya's parinamavada, Advaita's vivartavada) and asatkaryavada (Nyaya's arambhavada), the Greek atomists and Plato, Aristotle's four kinds of change, four causes, entelechy and unmoved mover, David Hume's empiricist attack on necessary connection, and how science talks about causes today. Every exercise is answered.
A cause is that because of which a change happens; the effect is what results from the change. Science uses cause–effect laws (metals expand when heated) both to explain and to predict; religions too speak of causes, as in the link between karma and its fruits. Philosophy does not hunt for particular causes — it examines the concept of cause itself.
Indian philosophy studied causation in the context of suffering and liberation. It distinguishes the material cause (what changes, e.g. wood) from the efficient cause (what brings the change about, e.g. the carpenter).
Satkaryavada says the effect already exists, hidden, in its material cause: Sankhya's parinamavada holds the cause really transforms into the effect (milk into curd), while Advaita's vivartavada holds the transformation is only an appearance (a rope seen as a snake). Nyaya's asatkaryavada or arambhavada says the effect is a new beginning that did not exist before.
In the West, the atomists saw change as mechanical and purposeless; Plato thought change was a striving of particulars towards their perfect forms. Aristotle classified change into qualitative, quantitative, spatial (locomotion) and substantial, and named four causes — material, formal, efficient and final. Living things change by an inner force, entelechy, and God is the unmoved mover.
Hume found that experience shows us contiguity, succession and constant conjunction, but never necessity; our belief in necessary connection is a habit of mind. Modern science looks for causes within laws of nature and speaks in terms of probability, not hidden potentials or purposes.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Cause?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Name the material cause and efficient cause of (a) a clay diya (b) a cup of tea.
Answer: (a) Clay is the material cause; the potter (with the wheel and fire) is the efficient cause. (b) Water, tea leaves, milk and sugar are the material causes; the person making tea, using the heat of the stove, is the efficient cause.
A student says: 'A statue is already inside the stone; the sculptor just removes extra stone.' Which theory is this, and how would a Naiyayika reply?
Answer: This is satkaryavada (close to parinamavada). A Naiyayika would reply that the statue's shape, beauty and use did not exist before the sculptor worked; the same stone could have become a step or a grinding stone; and if the statue were already there, no sculptor would be needed. So the statue is a new effect — arambhavada.
Every time Riya switches on the fan, it starts. Apply Hume's four ideas.
Answer: The first three are seen. Necessity is not: one day there may be a power cut or a burnt-out motor, and imagining that is not a contradiction. Our feeling that the fan 'must' start is a habit formed by repetition.
| Theory / thinker | Main claim | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Material cause | That in which change happens | Wood for a bat; clay for a pot |
| Efficient cause | That which brings about the change | Carpenter; potter |
| Satkaryavada | Effect pre-exists in the material cause | Sankhya, Advaita |
| Parinamavada | Cause really transforms into effect | Milk → curd (Sankhya) |
| Vivartavada | Transformation only appears to happen | Rope seen as snake (Advaita) |
| Asatkaryavada / Arambhavada | Effect is a new beginning | Nyaya; God as efficient cause |
| Empedocles / Democritus | Motion by attraction–repulsion / atoms move by nature | Mechanical, no purpose |
| Plato | Particulars strive towards perfect forms | Change matters little |
| Aristotle | Four changes, four causes, entelechy, unmoved mover | Teleological view |
| David Hume | No experience of necessary connection | Belief in necessity = habit |
| Modern science | Causes within laws of nature; probability | Low pressure → rain |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Find the odd one out: (1) Earth, Water, God, Fire (2) Material cause, Formal cause, Final cause, Thought cause (3) Observation, Change, Experiment, Conclusion.
Answer: (1) God — earth, water and fire are material elements (atoms are the material cause of the world in Nyaya), while God is the efficient cause. (2) Thought cause — it is not one of Aristotle's four causes (material, formal, efficient, final). (3) Change — observation, experiment and conclusion are steps of the scientific method; change is what is studied.
2. Q.2 Distinguish between: (1) satkaryavada and asatkaryavada (2) cause and effect.
Answer: (1) Satkaryavada (Sankhya, Advaita) says the effect already exists, hidden, in its material cause; production only reveals it; cause and effect are not different in kind (milk and curd). Asatkaryavada (Nyaya) says the effect did not exist before; it is a new beginning; it differs from the cause in form, qualities and use (wood and bat), and an efficient cause is essential. (2) The cause comes first and brings about change; the effect comes after and is produced by it. The cause has the capacity to produce; the effect is that capacity realised. E.g. heat is the cause, the expansion of metal the effect.
3. Q.3 Complete the concept maps: (1) Aristotle's types of cause (2) types of satkaryavada.
Answer: (1) Material cause, formal cause, efficient cause, final cause. (2) Parinamavada (Sankhya — real transformation) and vivartavada (Advaita Vedanta — apparent transformation).
4. Q.4 Short notes: (1) Entelechy (2) Aristotle's four-fold theory of causation (3) Satkaryavada.
Answer: (1) Aristotle held that every living being has a psyche, a principle of self-movement. Its inner driving force, by which a seed sprouts, grows into a sapling and a tree, flowers, fruits and makes seeds again, is entelechy. Non-living things lack it and need an outside force to move. It fits Aristotle's teleological view that nature moves towards ends. (2) For Aristotle, 'cause' meant every factor responsible for a thing's existence. Material cause — the stuff (stone for a statue, paper for a book); formal cause — the idea or design that fixes its shape; efficient cause — the agent who shapes it (sculptor, printer); final cause — the purpose (to honour someone, to be read). It explains man-made objects well, but final and efficient causes are hard to apply to natural changes, so modern science dropped them. (3) Satkaryavada says the effect is present in its material cause before it appears. Sankhya argues that nothing comes from nothing, a particular effect needs a particular material (milk for curd), a cause produces only what it can, and cause and effect share one nature. The efficient cause only brings the hidden effect out. Sankhya's form is parinamavada; Advaita's form is vivartavada.
5. Q.5 Answer in 20–25 words: (1) What are the two important questions asked in the Indian tradition about causation? (2) Why is Sankhya's satkaryavada called parinamavada? (3) Why is Advaita Vedanta's satkaryavada called vivartavada? (4) What is arambhavada?
Answer: (1) Does the effect exist in some form in its material cause before production? And is the effect independent of, and different from, its cause? (2) Because Sankhya holds that the cause itself really changes (parinama) into the effect — Prakriti actually transforms into the world, as milk turns into curd. (3) Because Advaita holds that the cause only appears to change: Brahman seems to become the world, like a rope seeming to be a snake, while really remaining unchanged. (4) Nyaya's view that the effect is a new beginning (arambha): it did not exist in the material cause and starts to exist only when it is produced.
6. Q.6 True or false, with reason: (1) Aristotle explained God as the 'unmoved mover'. (2) There is a relation between potentiality and actuality.
Answer: (1) True — to avoid an infinite regress of movers, Aristotle posited God as pure form with no unrealised potential, who moves the world by attracting it while remaining unmoved. (2) True — according to satkaryavada an effect is the actualisation of a potential already present in its material cause; that is why curd comes only from milk and mangoes only from mango seeds. If there were no such link, anything could come from anything.
7. Q.7 Explain with examples: (1) Not in a pail unless in the well. (2) According to Hume, the causal relation is not a necessary relation.
Answer: (1) Whatever is drawn in the pail must already be in the well. Sankhya uses this to say that the qualities found in things must already exist in their cause: since sattva, rajas and tamas are present in all objects, they must be present in Prakriti. Likewise oil comes from sesame seeds, not from sand. (2) We see that the sun's heat touches the candle, the melting comes after, and it happens every time; but we never perceive that it must happen. Imagining a candle that does not melt is not self-contradictory, unlike a two-sided triangle. Our sense of necessity is a habit formed by repetition, so the causal link is not logically necessary.
8. Q.8 What is asatkaryavada? Explain with an example.
Answer: Asatkaryavada, held by Nyaya, says the effect does not exist in its material cause before it is produced; it comes into being anew. Example: a cricket bat is not hidden in a block of wood. Arguments: (a) if the bat were already there, no carpenter would be needed; (b) 'produce' means bringing into being what did not exist; (c) the bat differs from the wood in shape, qualities and use — you cannot play a shot with a crooked log; (d) the same wood can become a chair, a door or a bat, so these effects cannot all pre-exist. Because the effect's existence begins with production, it is called arambhavada. Applied to the world, atoms of earth, water, fire and air are the material cause and God, who knows them fully, is the efficient cause who arranges them in order.
9. Q.9 Explain the four types of change given by Aristotle.
Answer: (1) Qualitative change — a change in qualities: a green, sour, hard mango becomes yellow, sweet and soft. (2) Quantitative change — a change in size or amount: a small mango becomes large; a banyan puts out more aerial roots. (3) Spatial (local) change — a change of place: the mango falls from the tree, goes into a box and reaches a home. (4) Substantial change — the coming into being or destruction of a substance: the mango forms from a flower and is destroyed when eaten. In the first three the substance stays the same while something about it changes; in the fourth the substance itself begins or ends.
10. Q.10 Explain in detail David Hume's notion of causation.
Answer: Hume was an empiricist: only ideas traced to sense experience give knowledge, however popular other ideas may be. Before him people believed that a cause has the power to produce its effect and that the link is necessary. Hume analysed 'A causes B' into four ideas: contiguity (A and B close in space and time), succession (A comes before B), constant conjunction (A and B always go together) and necessary connection (B must follow A). The first three come from experience: a candle left in strong sun is in contact with the heat, melts afterwards, and does so every time. But however often we watch, we never perceive the 'must'. A necessary truth cannot be denied without contradiction — a two-sided triangle is unthinkable — whereas 'the candle did not melt in the sun' may be false but is imaginable. So causal relations are not necessary. Our strong belief in necessity is psychological: repeated conjunction builds a habit of expecting B whenever we see A. Hume's analysis of causation and induction challenged both philosophy and science and pushed later thinkers to improve epistemology and scientific method.
11. Q.11 Write a dialogue among players or spectators on the causes of losing a match.
Answer: Sam: We lost because the umpire was unfair! Neha: One wrong decision cannot explain a 60-run loss. Our top order collapsed. Sam: That was bad luck. Coach: Was it? We skipped two practice sessions and did not study their bowlers. Neha: And we dropped three catches. Sam: So there wasn't one cause but many. Coach: Right — some were in our control, like practice and fielding; some were not, like the toss and the dew. Neha: Then next time we fix the causes we control. Coach: Exactly. Even then a win is only more probable, never certain — that is how causes work in sport.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. Odd one out: Earth, Water, God, Fire
Answer: A. The others are material elements; God is the efficient cause for Nyaya.
2. Odd one out among Aristotle's causes:
Answer: A. The fourth real cause is efficient cause.
3. Satkaryavada holds that the effect…
Answer: D. Sat means existing.
4. Sankhya's satkaryavada is called…
Answer: D. The cause really transforms.
5. The rope–snake example illustrates…
Answer: B. The change is only apparent.
6. For Nyaya, the efficient cause of the world is…
Answer: B. Atoms are the material cause.
7. A raw mango turning sweet and yellow is a … change.
Answer: A. Colour and taste are qualities.
8. A mango being eaten and destroyed is a … change.
Answer: B. The substance itself ceases.
9. The purpose for which a thing is made is its … cause.
Answer: D. Final = end or goal.
10. Aristotle's word for the inner force of growth in living things is…
Answer: D. Psyche is the soul; entelechy is its growth-force.
11. Aristotle's God is NOT…
Answer: C. The world is eternal; God only moves it.
12. Which does Hume say we never observe?
Answer: B. The 'must' is not seen.
13. According to Hume, our belief in causal necessity comes from…
Answer: B. Repetition breeds expectation.
14. Denying which statement gives a contradiction?
Answer: D. Only necessary truths give contradictions when denied.
15. Modern science expresses causal links mainly in terms of…
Answer: A. Sunrise is highly probable; rain less so.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Cause?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise What is Cause? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 45 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What is Cause?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of What is Cause?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “What is Cause?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.