TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 80–94
Why does a sunset or a song move us even when it is of no use to us? This aesthetics chapter compares the knowledge, utilitarian and aesthetic perspectives, explains aesthetic experience as Kant's 'disinterested delight', asks whether beauty is objective or subjective, separates art from craft, classifies the fine arts by medium, presents Western theories (Plato's imitation, Croce, Tolstoy, Collingwood) and Indian theories (Bharata's rasa, alankara, riti, dhvani), and ends with what evolution tells us about our taste. Every exercise is answered.
Humans can appreciate and create beauty beyond the needs of survival. Aesthetics studies beauty, aesthetic and artistic experience, works of art and their place in life; the term was coined by Baumgarten in the 18th century from a Greek word for sense perception, and Kant set aesthetic experience apart from moral experience and mere sensual pleasure.
We relate to the world through three perspectives: the knowledge perspective (what is it, which laws govern it), the utilitarian perspective (what is it useful for) and the aesthetic perspective, which values the object and the viewer in their own uniqueness, with no further purpose. It shows that things have value of their own, not only as resources.
Aesthetic experience starts in the senses but stirs emotion, memory, thought and imagination; it is always pleasurable, but unlike desire it does not need possession — Kant called it disinterested delight. Greek and medieval thinkers held beauty to be objective (harmony, proportion, symmetry, rhythm); Hume held it subjective ('beauty lies in the eye of the beholder'); later thinkers saw it as both, and many hold that beauty cannot be strictly defined.
A work of art is man-made, created mainly for appreciation rather than use, and need not be only beautiful. Art differs from craft in its creativity. The process of art links artist, work and receiver. Fine arts are visual, audio, symbolic (literature) or audio-visual, and spatial, temporal or spatio-temporal.
Plato saw art as an imitation of an imitation; later theories saw art as expression (Croce, Collingwood) or communication of feeling (Tolstoy). In India, Bharata's Natyashastra gave the rasa–bhava theory (eight rasas; Abhinavagupta added shanta), followed by alankara, riti and dhvani. Science suggests some tastes — for landscapes with water and for babies' faces — have evolutionary roots.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Following the path of art” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
You see a banyan tree on your way to college. Describe it from all three perspectives.
Answer: Knowledge: Ficus benghalensis, a fig tree whose aerial roots grow down to form new trunks. Utilitarian: it gives shade, a resting place and shelter for birds. Aesthetic: the hanging roots look like curtains, light falls through the leaves in patches and the tree feels calm and ancient — enjoyed for itself, with no further purpose.
Two friends argue: one calls a new glass skyscraper beautiful, the other calls it ugly. How would a Greek thinker and Hume each settle this?
Answer: A Greek thinker would examine the building's proportion, symmetry, balance and rhythm and declare it beautiful or not on that basis — one answer is correct. Hume would say the beauty is in the viewers' responses, so both reports are honest and there is no fact in the building to settle it.
Name the rasa a viewer mainly tastes in each: (a) a comic scene in a play (b) a hero defending his village (c) a mother mourning her lost child (d) a monk's calm at the end of a long journey.
Answer: (a) Hasya (humour). (b) Vira (heroism). (c) Karuna (pathos). (d) Shanta (peace), the ninth rasa added by Abhinavagupta.
| Thinker / idea | Key claim | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Baumgarten (18th c.) | Coined 'aesthetics' | From the Greek for sense perception |
| Kant | Aesthetic experience = disinterested delight | Separate from moral and sensual pleasure |
| Greek and medieval thinkers | Beauty is objective | Harmony, proportion, symmetry, rhythm |
| David Hume | Beauty is subjective | Eye of the beholder |
| Plato | Art is imitation of imitation | Kept out of the philosopher-king's education |
| Croce / Collingwood | Art is intuition / expression | Expressionism |
| Tolstoy | Art communicates feelings and values | 'What is Art?' (1897) |
| Bharata | Rasa–bhava; eight rasas | Natyashastra |
| Abhinavagupta | Added shanta rasa | Ninth rasa |
| Bhamaha, Dandin / Vamana | Alankara / riti | Ornament / style |
| Anandavardhana | Dhvani — suggested meaning | Soul of poetry |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks: (1) ___ experiences include natural and man-made elements (aesthetic / imaginary / divine). (2) In Indian aesthetics, Bharata's idea of ___ is fundamental (rasa–bhava / bhava–bhavana / rasa-bhavana). (3) In the Greek and medieval period beauty was considered a(n) ___ quality of an object (subjective / objective / inter-subjective).
Answer: (1) Aesthetic. (2) Rasa–bhava. (3) Objective.
2. Q.2 Answer in 20–25 words: (1) Give two examples of the aesthetic perspective. (2) What are the characteristics of aesthetic experience? (3) Give any four words used for 'beautiful'. (4) What is a work of art? (5) State the important elements of the process of art.
Answer: (1) Enjoying the play of light and shadow on a heap of rocks instead of asking what they are for; being moved by a painting of a table, papers and spectacles that recalls a grandparent. (2) It begins in the senses but stirs emotion, memory, thought and imagination; it is always pleasurable; it is disinterested — it needs no possession or use; it attends to the unique object. (3) Lovely, nice, awesome, amazing (also pretty, gorgeous, epic). (4) A man-made creation made mainly to be appreciated rather than used, expressing the artist's creativity through a medium such as colour, sound, words or movement. (5) The artist (creation), the work of art (presentation through a medium) and the receiver (appreciation and criticism).
3. Q.3 Short notes: (1) Plato's theory of art as imitation (2) Types of art (3) Indian views on art.
Answer: (1) Plato held that the natural world copies the eternal world of forms and art copies the natural world, so art is an imitation of an imitation, two steps away from truth and useless for knowing reality. Epics and plays portray gods as jealous and quarrelsome, weakening reverence and moral discipline. So he kept such art out of the education of the philosopher-king in his ideal state. (2) By medium: visual arts (painting, sculpture, architecture), audio art (vocal and instrumental music), literature (symbolic art using words) and audio-visual arts (dance, drama, film). By space and time: spatial (painting), temporal (music), spatio-temporal (dance, drama, film; literature also assumes a space–time frame). Fine arts are made mainly for appreciation; applied arts and crafts mainly for use. (3) Bharata's Natyashastra gave the rasa–bhava theory: fitting acting and words produce rasa, relished by the spectator; eight rasas, with shanta added by Abhinavagupta; rasa-vighna are obstacles. Bhamaha and Dandin stressed alankara (ornament), Vamana riti (style — form as important as content), Anandavardhana dhvani (suggested meaning), Magha 'ramaniya' (fresh delight). Art aims to show right and wrong and to entertain; all arts are interconnected.
4. Q.4 Discuss in detail the nature of art.
Answer: Art involves the artist, the work and the receiver. It is necessarily man-made — a rainbow is not art — and expresses creativity, which can make what nature does not contain. But being man-made is not enough: a stone-age tool or a hunting bow is not art, while the Bhimbetka paintings or a bow of flowers made only to please are. A work of art is made mainly for appreciation, not use; a vase used as a paperweight still has mainly aesthetic value, though architecture, built for use, can be great art (Taj Mahal, Kailasa temple). Art is not only about beauty; it can show good, evil and even the ugly, blending fact with imagination. Art differs from craft, which repeats patterns with skill but little fresh creativity, though each needs something of the other. Historically art grew out of our mixed relationship with nature, then took society as its subject; it was tied to religion and morality until about the 18th century and then became independent with its own standards. The process moves from the artist's inner creation, through presentation in a medium, to the receiver's appreciation and criticism. Art keeps tradition alive, criticises society and deepens our awareness.
5. Q.5 Explain the various Western theories of art.
Answer: (1) Imitation theory (Plato, Aristotle): art imitates nature and human life. For Plato it is an imitation of an imitation, far from truth, and morally risky, so he excluded it from the philosopher-king's education. Imitation can be a crude surface copy or a subtle grasp of essence. Greek and medieval thinkers judged art by truth, knowledge and morality. (2) Expression theory (after the Renaissance; Collingwood, Croce): art expresses the artist's inner emotional life. Croce called art intuition — the artist's non-rational response in the form of dynamic images; the outer work, made with craft and skill, is a bridge that lets the receiver feel pure emotion. (3) Communication theory (Tolstoy, 'What is Art?', 1897): beauty is not art's aim; art transmits feelings from artist to audience, uniting people. Great art is universal, appeals to ordinary people and presents life's values and struggles. Later, art became autonomous and philosophy of art focused on artistic analysis.
6. Q.6 Write a dialogue between an artist and an appreciator on whether aesthetic value is objective.
Answer: Appreciator: Your painting is beautiful — but my friend says it's dull. Who's right? Artist: Maybe both. The Greeks would say beauty lies in the work — balance, proportion, rhythm. I did plan those carefully. Appreciator: Then it should be beautiful for everyone. Artist: Hume would disagree: beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Your friend's response is just as real. Appreciator: So there's no standard at all? Artist: Not quite. Scientists find nearly everyone is soothed by green landscapes with water — I used a lake here on purpose. Appreciator: So part of beauty is shared and part is personal? Artist: Exactly. Some features work for most people, but each viewer brings memories and taste. That's why we can discuss art, yet never fully settle it.
7. Extra (from the chapter): Distinguish between the utilitarian and the aesthetic perspective.
Answer: The utilitarian perspective asks what a thing is useful for; it treats objects as tools, classifies them by function and comes from the instinct to survive and flourish — a rock is a seat or a building material. The aesthetic perspective has no further purpose; it attends to the particular object and the person experiencing it, enjoying form, colour, light and texture for their own sake — the same rock is admired for its pattern and glitter. The aesthetic view reveals the value things have in themselves, not only as resources.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. … experiences include natural and man-made elements.
Answer: B. Both a sunset and a sculpture can give it.
2. In Indian aesthetics, Bharata's fundamental idea is…
Answer: C. Dhvani is Anandavardhana's.
3. In the Greek and medieval period beauty was considered a(n) … quality.
Answer: B. It lay in harmony and proportion.
4. 'Disinterested delight' was Kant's description of…
Answer: D. Joy without the wish to own or use.
5. Classifying chairs and tables by their use reflects the … perspective.
Answer: A. Use decides the category.
6. Who held that beauty lies in the eye of the beholder?
Answer: A. Beauty depends on the viewer.
7. Which is a craft rather than fine art, according to the textbook?
Answer: B. Pattern repeated with skill, little creativity.
8. Which art is designed for use yet can be great art?
Answer: D. Taj Mahal, Kailasa temple.
9. Music is called…
Answer: A. It unfolds in time.
10. Dance, drama and film are…
Answer: C. They use both space and time.
11. For Plato, art is…
Answer: D. Two steps from the forms.
12. Tolstoy's main idea about art is that it…
Answer: B. Beauty is not its central aim.
13. The ninth rasa, shanta, was added by…
Answer: D. Bharata gave eight.
14. Riti (style) as the essence of poetry is linked with…
Answer: A. Form matters as much as content.
15. The male bowerbird decorating its bower suggests that…
Answer: A. Decoration attracts mates.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Following the path of art” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise Following the path of art the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 40 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Following the path of art” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of Following the path of art.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “Following the path of art” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.