TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 59–79
How do we decide whether an action is right or wrong — by the intention behind it or by its results? This ethics chapter covers Indian ideas (rta, rna, the law of karma and its types, the four purusharthas, nishkama karma, Jaina vows and the three jewels, Charvaka hedonism, the Buddha's four noble truths and eightfold path) and Western theories (Kant's good will and categorical imperative; hedonism, Bentham's hedonistic calculus and Mill's qualitative utilitarianism), and ends with what evolution and brain science add. Every exercise is answered.
Voluntary actions, done by free will, can be judged right or wrong. Ethics asks how to judge them — mainly by intention or by consequence, which do not always match (a well-meaning helper may hurt an accident victim). Moral rules come from long experience but sometimes clash or need exceptions, and laws and customs should be examined critically, not followed blindly.
Indian ethics begins with rta, the order in nature and in human action, which matures into the law of karma: every voluntary action, driven by raga (attraction) or dvesha (aversion), brings its fruit to the doer. Rebirth explains why the good sometimes suffer. Karma is sanchita, prarabdha or kriyamana. Rna (debt) to gods, sages, ancestors and fellow humans teaches gratitude.
The four purusharthas are dharma, artha, kama and moksha; artha and kama must be pursued within dharma, and moksha is the highest goal. Knowledge and morality support each other. The Gita teaches nishkama karma — acting from duty without craving for the fruit. Jainism uses samvara and nirjara, the five vows and the three jewels; Charvaka is hedonist; Buddhism offers the four noble truths, the eightfold path and panchashila.
Kant's deontology: only a good will is good without condition; duty is what reason can universalise. Moral commands are categorical, not hypothetical, and every person must be treated as an end, never merely as a means.
Consequentialism judges by results. Hedonism takes pleasure as the good — psychological (we do seek it) or ethical (we ought to). Utilitarianism is universalistic hedonism: Bentham's 'greatest happiness of the greatest number' with a seven-point hedonistic calculus; Mill adds that pleasures differ in quality. Science now studies how evolution and the brain shape moral behaviour.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What to do and why?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Classify these as sanchita, prarabdha or kriyamana karma (in the traditional scheme): (a) the studying you are doing today (b) results you are facing now from earlier choices (c) old deeds whose results have not yet started.
Answer: (a) Kriyamana — being performed now; its fruit will follow. (b) Prarabdha — its results have begun and must be borne. (c) Sanchita — stored up; on this view it can still be cancelled by knowledge or by right duties.
Two students volunteer at a blood-donation camp: one because it is right to help, one to get a certificate for a college application. Which is nishkama karma?
Answer: The first student acts from a sense of duty with no expectation — nishkama karma. The second acts for a reward — sakama karma. Both actions help others, but on the Gita's view only the first frees the doer from binding fruits.
Use Bentham's calculus to choose between (a) watching a movie alone tonight and (b) helping organise a free health camp in your locality this weekend.
Answer: The movie is near and fairly certain but short and affects only you. The camp may be less intense and is a few days away, but its benefits last longer, produce further pleasures (healthier neighbours, new friendships), carry little pain and reach many people. On extent, duration and fecundity the camp wins, so a utilitarian would choose (b).
| Idea / thinker | Key claim | Remember |
|---|---|---|
| Rta | Order in nature and in conduct | Rigveda; seasons, day–night |
| Law of karma | Every voluntary act bears fruit for the doer | Linked with rebirth |
| Rna | Debts to gods, sages, ancestors, humans | Gratitude |
| Purusharthas | Dharma, artha, kama, moksha | Moksha is highest |
| Nishkama karma | Act from duty without craving fruit | Bhagavad Gita |
| Jaina ethics | Samvara, nirjara; five vows; three jewels | Ahimsa is central |
| Charvaka | Pleasure is the goal; only artha and kama | Hedonism |
| Bauddha | Four noble truths, eightfold path, panchashila | Nirvana |
| Kant | Good will; categorical imperative; persons as ends | Deontology |
| Bentham | Greatest happiness of the greatest number; 7-point calculus | Quantity of pleasure |
| J. S. Mill | Better Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied | Quality of pleasure |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Find the odd one out: (1) right–wrong, good–bad, voluntary–involuntary, customs–mores (2) Devruna, Mitraruna, Pitruruna, Rishiruna (3) truth, pleasure, non-violence, non-stealing.
Answer: (1) Voluntary–involuntary — it is a classification of actions, while the others are moral evaluations or social norms. (2) Mitraruna — the traditional three debts are deva, rishi and pitru rna (manushya rna is the added fourth); 'debt to friends' is not one of them. (3) Pleasure — truth, non-violence and non-stealing are moral vows (sadharana dharma, Jaina and Buddhist vows).
2. Q.2 Answer in 20–25 words: (1) What are raga and dvesha, the two motivations behind voluntary actions? (2) When does the process of nirjara begin? (3) What are the noble truths of the Bauddhas? (4) What are the main criteria of moral evaluation of an act?
Answer: (1) Raga is attraction or desire — wanting something; dvesha is aversion or dislike — not wanting something. Every voluntary action is driven by one of these two. (2) Nirjara, the shedding of karmic matter, begins when a person controls thoughts, desires, feelings, speech and behaviour through moral conduct based on right faith and knowledge. (3) Life involves suffering; suffering has a cause; suffering can cease; and there is a path — the noble eightfold path — leading to its cessation. (4) The intention or purpose with which the act is done, and the consequences it produces; deontology stresses the first, consequentialism the second.
3. Q.3 Complete the concept maps: (1) purusharthas (2) triratnas (3) Jaina's five vows.
Answer: (1) Dharma, artha, kama, moksha. (2) Right faith, right knowledge, right conduct. (3) Ahimsa (non-violence), satya (truth), asteya (non-stealing), brahmacharya (celibacy / self-control), aparigraha (non-possessiveness).
4. Q.4 Short notes: (1) Evolution and morality (2) Bentham's hedonism and hedonistic calculus (3) Buddhist ethics (4) Purushartha.
Answer: (1) Evolution shows that humans and their behaviour are products of a long biological history. Brain research links conduct to the nervous system — the emotional amygdala dominates early, the planning neocortex matures later. So moral questions such as nature versus nurture or career choice can be approached through biology and a person's abilities, not only tradition. Research confirms that pleasure shapes decisions, but the Buddha's warning about chasing pleasure, and technology built to give instant pleasure, raise fresh ethical questions. (2) Bentham said humans are ruled by pleasure and pain; the right act gives the greatest happiness of the greatest number, and each person's pleasure counts equally — even animals' pain counts. Pleasure can be measured by seven criteria: intensity, duration, certainty, propinquity, fecundity, purity and extent. The first six concern the individual; extent makes the theory universalistic. (3) Its aim is the end of suffering. It rests on the four noble truths and the eightfold path — right view, resolve, speech, action, livelihood, effort, mindfulness and concentration. Panchashila forbids killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying and intoxicants. This discipline steadies body and mind and leads to nirvana, the end of rebirth. (4) Purusharthas are the goals of a good human life: kama (pleasure, including art), artha (wealth as a means), dharma (duty, morality, what holds society together) and moksha (liberation). Artha and kama must be pursued within dharma. The first three concern this life; moksha is the highest, spiritual goal.
5. Q.5 In the Indian tradition, why has karma theory always been linked with rebirth?
Answer: The law of karma says every voluntary act inevitably brings its fruit to the doer — good acts good fruits, bad acts bad fruits. But in real life we see wicked people enjoying pleasures and good people suffering, which seems to break the law. Rebirth resolves this: if the cause of present happiness or suffering is not found in this life, it must lie in actions of previous lives, and the fruits of present actions may come in this or a future life. It also encourages good deeds, since none will go unrewarded. Hence all darshanas except Charvaka accept both karma and rebirth, and treat freedom from rebirth (moksha) as the highest goal.
6. Q.6 Why did Kant not agree with Hume that reason is the slave of passions and motivations?
Answer: Hume held that desires and passions decide what we want, and reason only works out how to get it. Kant saw that if morality rested on feelings it would vary from person to person — what is right for one would be wrong for another — so ethics would become subjective and lose universality and impartiality. Like Socrates and Plato, Kant believed moral laws must be the same for all. Since reason is common to every human being, he based ethics on reason: reason itself commands what is right (return the lost phone to the office), independent of anyone's wishes. Reason can control desires; this ability gives humans dignity and makes morality possible.
7. Q.7 Discuss in detail ethics in Jaina darshana.
Answer: Every jiva can attain infinite knowledge, faith, power and bliss, but passions and desires attract fine matter (pudgala) into it (asrava), binding it to a body; this external bondage stems from inner bondage — craving. Liberation needs two processes: samvara, stopping the inflow of new matter, and nirjara, wearing away matter already bound. The means are the three jewels: right faith in the teachings of the liberated ones, right knowledge of world and self, and right conduct — knowledge must show in action. When a person controls thoughts, desires, feelings, speech and behaviour, nirjara begins and asrava stops. Conduct centres on five vows: ahimsa (no harm to any being in body, speech or thought, since every jiva has a right to liberation), satya, asteya, brahmacharya and aparigraha (owning only what is needed). Householders keep them as lighter anuvratas; monks and nuns as strict mahavratas. Through them faith, knowledge and conduct become perfect and the jiva is freed from rebirth.
8. Q.8 Write a dialogue: Can a happy person be a moral person?
Answer: Isha: If I'm happy, I'm doing something right, aren't I? Dev: Charvaka and the hedonists would say pleasure is the goal. But what if your happiness comes from cheating? Isha: Then it's wrong. Dev: So happiness alone doesn't make an act moral. Kant would say what matters is acting from duty with a good will. Isha: Does that mean a moral person must be unhappy? Dev: Not at all. Mill said higher pleasures — learning, helping, art — are worth more, and the Gita says acting without craving brings peace. Isha: And the Buddha warned that chasing pleasure makes us restless. Dev: So a person who does right and is content with that can be both happy and moral. Isha: Happiness as a by-product, not the target — I like that.
9. Q.9 State the contribution of technology in the search for pleasure.
Answer: Technology has made pleasure faster and easier: streaming services, games and social media offer instant entertainment; food delivery, travel bookings and online shopping satisfy wants in minutes; medicine relieves pain and aims to extend healthy life. Much of it is designed to keep us seeking more — endless feeds and notifications. This raises ethical questions: such pleasures are intense and near but often short, impure (followed by stress or addiction) and centred on oneself, so they score poorly on Bentham's own calculus. As the Buddha warned, chasing instant pleasure can increase dissatisfaction. Ethics asks us to use technology for lasting, shared well-being, not just quick thrills.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. Odd one out: right–wrong, good–bad, voluntary–involuntary, customs–mores
Answer: A. The others are value terms or norms; this pair classifies actions.
2. Odd one out: Devruna, Mitraruna, Pitruruna, Rishiruna
Answer: D. The traditional three are deva, rishi and pitru rna.
3. Odd one out: truth, pleasure, non-violence, non-stealing
Answer: B. The others are vows.
4. Actions whose fruits must be borne now are…
Answer: C. Their fruit has already begun.
5. The early three-fold scheme of goals is called…
Answer: A. Moksha was added later.
6. Giving your seat purely out of duty is…
Answer: D. No reward is expected.
7. In Jainism, stopping the inflow of new karmic matter is…
Answer: C. Nirjara sheds old matter.
8. Which is NOT one of the three jewels?
Answer: B. Right livelihood is from the Buddhist path.
9. Charvaka's ethics is best called…
Answer: B. Pleasure is the goal.
10. 'Reason is the slave of the passions' was said by…
Answer: A. Kant rejected it.
11. 'If you want good marks, study regularly' is a … imperative.
Answer: B. It depends on a goal.
12. Treating a person merely as a means violates…
Answer: C. Kant: persons are ends in themselves.
13. Utilitarianism is a form of…
Answer: A. Everyone affected counts.
14. 'A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush' illustrates Bentham's criterion of…
Answer: D. A sure pleasure is preferred.
15. Who said it is better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied?
Answer: C. Quality of pleasure matters.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What to do and why?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise What to do and why? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 55 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “What to do and why?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of What to do and why?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “What to do and why?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.