Who am I?.... What am I?Class 12 Philosophy Chapter 3 Notes – Maharashtra Board

Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 29–39

What is the 'I' that stays the same while our body, habits and ideas keep changing? This chapter compares answers to 'Who am I?' — Charvaka's conscious body, the Jaina jiva, the Buddhist five aggregates and Nagasena's chariot, Sankhya's Purusha, Advaita's 'I am Brahman', Pythagoras, Democritus, Plato's three-part soul, Aristotle's soul as the form of the body, Descartes' interactionism, Hume's bundle theory — and what evolutionary biology and neuroscience say about self-awareness today. Every exercise is answered.

🎧 Listen to the summary

Summary: Who am I?.... What am I?

An ID card tells others our name, age, class or religion, but many people share these. What makes each 'I' unique is a changing blend of habits, thoughts, emotions and values. Yet we feel that all these changes happen to one and the same 'me'. Philosophy asks about the human self that all of us share: is it a substance, and is it matter or consciousness?

Indian views: Charvaka — the conscious living body is the self (dehatmavada); Jaina — every living being is a conscious jiva bound to matter by karma, able to reach infinite knowledge, faith, power and bliss; Buddhism — no permanent self, only a stream of five aggregates (Nagasena's chariot); Sankhya — the self is Purusha, pure consciousness, distinct from body and mind; Advaita — the self is Brahman itself.

Western views: the Pythagoreans saw the body as a cage of an immortal soul; Democritus made the soul of fine fire atoms, perishing with the body; Plato's soul belongs to the world of forms and, joined to a body, has reason, spirit and appetite; Aristotle's soul is the form of the body and dies with it; medieval thought saw man as body plus immortal soul created by God.

Descartes held mind and body are different substances that interact causally, which raised the mind–body problem and many rival theories. Hume found no permanent self within — only a bundle or flow of perceptions linked by memory, like the frames of a film.

Science studies the self through evolutionary biology and neuroscience: humans are aware that they are aware; they are social but not eusocial like ants; the brain is the basis of consciousness; and computers now separate intelligence from awareness, raising new questions about the self.

Key points to remember

  • Philosophy's question 'Who am I?' (ko'ham) is about the human self shared by all, not one individual
  • Charvaka: 'chaitanya-vishishta deha eva atma' — the conscious body is the self (bhutachaitanyavada / dehatmavada)
  • Jaina: jivas classified by movement, number of senses (one to five) and bound or liberated
  • Jaina path to liberation: right faith, right knowledge and right conduct
  • Buddhism: self = five aggregates — rupa, vedana, sanjna, samskara, vijnana; no permanent soul
  • Sankhya: self = Purusha — knower but not doer or enjoyer; many Purushas
  • Advaita: 'I am Brahman' — one self, the same pure consciousness in all
  • Plato: three parts of the embodied soul — reason, spirit, appetite; reason should rule
  • Aristotle: soul is the form of the body; plant, animal and human souls; not immortal
  • Descartes — interactionism; Hume — the self is a bundle of perceptions
Want a teacher to explain Who am I?.... What am I??

Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “Who am I?.... What am I?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.

Get a tutor for this chapter →

👩‍🏫 Class 12 Philosophy classes — live online, request a call back

Prefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.

Live online classesSmall groups or 1:1 with a teacher, from home, any city.
We call you backOur team asks what your child needs, then shares timings and fees.
Home tutor?We are still building our list of home tutors — ask on the call if there is one near you.

Keep learning