TalentJR apps
Textbook: Philosophy – Class 12 (Balbharati, official free PDF) · pages 40–58
What counts as knowledge, how do we get it, and how do we test whether it is true? This chapter covers Indian epistemology — prama, pramata, pramana and prameya; Nyaya's four pramanas (perception, inference, comparison, testimony) with the five-step argument and the four conditions of a meaningful sentence; Mimamsa's arthapatti and anupalabdhi — and Western epistemology: scepticism and relativism, knowledge as justified true belief, the correspondence, coherence and pragmatic theories of truth, rationalism versus empiricism, and Kant's synthesis, ending with the scientific view. Every exercise is answered.
Humans are aware that they know, so knowledge itself becomes something to study. In Indian thought, any cognition is jnana (dnyana); a cognition tested and found true is prama. The knower of prama is the pramata, the means is the pramana and the object known is the prameya. Only humans can check truth, so only they are pramatas.
Nyaya accepts four pramanas: pratyaksha (perception, ordinary and extraordinary), anumana (inference — paksha, hetu, sadhya, vyapti; for oneself or for others in five steps), upamana (knowing a new thing through a described likeness) and shabda (the word of a reliable person, an apta). A sentence gives meaning only with akanksha, yogyata, sannidhi and tatparya. Mimamsa adds arthapatti (postulation) and anupalabdhi (non-perception).
Western epistemology largely grew as an answer to the sophists' scepticism and relativism ('man is the measure of all things'). Plato tied knowledge to unchanging forms and analysed it as justified true belief: one must believe it, it must be true, and it must be justified objectively.
Three theories of truth: correspondence (matches the facts), coherence (fits with other accepted truths) and pragmatic (works in practice). Each catches one aspect and each has weaknesses, so truth is best judged as a whole.
Rationalists (Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz) said knowledge begins with reason, innate ideas and a priori truths; empiricists (Locke, Berkeley, Hume) said it begins with sense experience and the mind is a blank slate. Kant combined them: reason gives form, experience gives content. Science treats knowledge as collective, instrument-based and probabilistic.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “How do we know?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Your friend's bike is not in the parking area, so you conclude she has not come to college. Identify paksha, hetu, sadhya and vyapti, and say whether the vyapti is reliable.
Answer: Paksha — today's college attendance of the friend (the college); hetu — her bike is absent; sadhya — she has not come; vyapti — 'whenever her bike is absent, she is absent'. This vyapti is weak: she could have come by bus. A valid inference needs an invariable link, like smoke and fire.
Check these sentences against the four conditions: (a) 'Bring the' (b) 'The stone sang a song' (c) 'Meet me at the bank'.
Answer: (a) Fails akanksha — 'bring the what?'. (b) Fails yogyata — a stone cannot sing. (c) Meets akanksha, yogyata and sannidhi, but needs tatparya: in a city it means a money bank; on a river trip it may mean the river bank — context decides.
| Term / thinker | Key idea | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Prama / pramata / pramana / prameya | True knowledge / knower / means / object | Indian terms |
| Pratyaksha | Sense–object contact; ordinary and extraordinary | Seeing a rose |
| Anumana | From hetu to sadhya through vyapti | Smoke → fire |
| Upamana | Knowing the new through described likeness | Giant squirrel |
| Shabda | Word of an apta | A good doctor's advice |
| Arthapatti / Anupalabdhi | Postulation / non-perception (Mimamsa) | Studies at night / friend absent |
| Protagoras (sophist) | Man is the measure of all things | Relativism, scepticism |
| Plato | Knowledge = justified true belief | Linked to the forms |
| Correspondence / coherence / pragmatic | Fits facts / fits other truths / works | Gangtok; X × 0; litmus |
| Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz | Rationalism, innate ideas, a priori | Maths as model |
| Locke, Berkeley, Hume | Empiricism, tabula rasa, a posteriori | Science as model |
| Kant | Reason gives form, experience content | Critical philosophy |
Solve each one in your notebook first. Then open the solution and compare every step.
1. Q.1 Fill in the blanks: (1) In Indian philosophy, knowledge that qualifies the test of truth is called ___ (dharana / prama / smruti). (2) According to Nyaya, human ___ is the knower (atma / jiva / experience). (3) According to relativism, knowledge is ___ (real / subjective / illusionary). (4) Descartes wanted to prove that ___ is wrong (rationalism / pragmatism / scepticism).
Answer: (1) Prama. (2) Atma. (3) Subjective. (4) Scepticism.
2. Q.2 Give the philosophical term: (1) that which is known (2) a person who is knowledgeable and trustworthy (3) determinate, non-erroneous and true knowledge from contact between sense organs and objects (4) inference used to prove a conclusion to someone else.
Answer: (1) Prameya. (2) Apta. (3) Pratyaksha (perception). (4) Pararthanumana.
3. Q.3 Complete the concept maps: (1) criteria of knowledge (2) conditions of meaningfulness of a sentence.
Answer: (1) Belief, truth, justification (knowledge = justified true belief). (2) Akanksha (expectancy), yogyata (compatibility), sannidhi (proximity), tatparya (intended meaning).
4. Q.4 Explain with examples: (1) Clarity and distinctness are the attributes of a true proposition. (2) Without sense experience knowledge is not possible. (3) Belief is not knowledge.
Answer: (1) Descartes held that a proposition is true when we grasp it clearly (its meaning is fully present to the mind) and distinctly (it is sharply marked off from everything else). 'I think, therefore I am' is grasped this way. 'All sides of a square are equal' gives a clear idea of a square and also distinguishes it from a rectangle. (2) This is the empiricist view. Locke said the mind at birth is a blank slate; all ideas come from sensation and reflection. A person born blind cannot form the idea of red; a child gets the idea of God only through upbringing. Reason can only work on material that experience supplies. (3) Knowledge needs belief, but belief is not enough: it must also be true and justified. Someone may believe Saturn is the planet nearest Earth — that is false, so not knowledge. Someone may believe Saturn has rings because he dreamt it — true, but not justified, so still not knowledge.
5. Q.5 True or false, with reason: (1) Only human beings can be called pramata. (2) An inference used as an argument for others is called svarthanumana. (3) According to the correspondence theory all propositions are consistent with one another. (4) According to the correspondence theory all statements are coherent with each other. (5) Berkeley denies the existence of matter.
Answer: (1) True — all beings have jnana, but only humans can test whether knowledge is true, so only they attain prama. (2) False — inference for others is pararthanumana; svarthanumana is inference for oneself. (3) False — that is the coherence theory; the correspondence theory says a proposition is true if it matches the facts. (4) False — for the same reason: coherence among statements is the coherence theory's test, not the correspondence theory's. (5) True — Berkeley held that even primary qualities are known through secondary ones, so only minds and ideas exist; there is no material substance.
6. Q.6 Distinguish between: (1) svarthanumana and pararthanumana (2) rationalism and empiricism (3) primary and secondary qualities.
Answer: (1) Svarthanumana is inference for oneself — a source of knowledge, done mentally without formal steps. Pararthanumana is inference for others — used as an argument, set out in five steps (pratijna, hetu, udaharana, upanaya, nigamana) to convince someone. (2) Rationalism: knowledge begins with reason; innate ideas exist; a priori knowledge is possible; mathematics is the model; certainty is the aim (Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz). Empiricism: knowledge begins with sense experience; the mind is a blank slate; all knowledge of the world is a posteriori; science is the model; its knowledge is probable (Locke, Berkeley, Hume). (3) For Locke, primary qualities — solidity, size (extension), shape, motion and number — exist in the object itself whether or not anyone perceives them, and can be known objectively. Secondary qualities — colour, taste, smell, sound, felt warmth — depend on a perceiver and vary from person to person. We reach primary qualities only through secondary ones.
7. Q.7 Discuss in detail inference in Nyaya darshana.
Answer: Anumana literally means knowledge that follows other knowledge: from what is perceived we know what is not perceived — smelling wet earth inside a hall we know it is raining; pug marks tell us an animal passed. It has three parts: the paksha (the place about which we infer — the hill), the hetu (the mark or reason — smoke) and the sadhya (what is proved — fire). Pakshadharmata is the presence of the hetu in the paksha; vyapti is the invariable relation between hetu and sadhya ('wherever there is smoke there is fire'). Inference needs both: we perceive smoke on the hill, remember the vyapti learnt in the kitchen, and conclude that the hill has fire. Nyaya treats inference both as a source of knowledge and as a method of argument. Svarthanumana is inference for oneself. Pararthanumana is inference for others, stated in five members: pratijna (the hill has fire), hetu (because it has smoke), udaharana (wherever there is smoke there is fire, as in a kitchen), upanaya (this hill has smoke), nigamana (therefore the hill has fire). If the vyapti is not invariable, the inference fails.
8. Q.8 State the pragmatic theory of truth and explain its drawbacks with examples.
Answer: The pragmatic theory says a proposition is true if action based on it succeeds — if it produces the expected, useful result. 'This colourless liquid is water' is true if drinking it quenches thirst; 'this liquid is an acid' is true if blue litmus turns red. It values knowledge for its use in life and fits the experimental method of science. Drawbacks: (1) success does not prove truth. A tired student on a trek is told 'wild animals come here often' and keeps walking — the action succeeds, yet the statement may be a lie. (2) The same statement would count as true when the trick works and false when it fails, so truth becomes relative to person and situation, not objective. (3) Many truths, such as facts about the distant past, have no practical consequences to test. So pragmatism shows one aspect of truth — usefulness — but cannot be the whole account.
9. Q.11 Write a dialogue on logical consistency in fictional works such as a movie or fairy tale vis-à-vis objective reality.
Answer: Kabir: The Harry Potter books are so well planned — every spell and rule fits. Isn't that a kind of truth? Meera: It is coherent — the statements agree with each other inside the story. Kabir: So by the coherence theory it is true? Meera: Coherence alone isn't enough. Does Hogwarts correspond to anything in the real world? Kabir: No, there's no such school. Meera: Then statements like 'Hogwarts is in Scotland' fail the correspondence test. Kabir: But a science paper must be both — consistent and matching experiments. Meera: Exactly. Fiction can be consistent and still false about the world; knowledge needs coherence and correspondence. Kabir: Then I'll enjoy the story as a story, not as facts.
10. Extra (from the chapter): What is the difference between upamana and inference? Give an example of each.
Answer: Upamana: told that a gaur looks like a cow but is huge and dark with white 'socks', you recognise a gaur in the forest — the new object is known through its likeness to a known one. Inference: seeing wet roads and dripping trees in the morning, you conclude it rained at night — the unseen is known through an invariable link (vyapti) with what is seen. Upamana connects a word with its object; inference connects a mark with what it marks.
Read the question, answer it in your head, then tap the card to check. 20 cards.
15 questions. Tap an option — you will see at once if it is right and why.
1. In Indian philosophy, knowledge that passes the test of truth is called…
Answer: A. Smriti is memory.
2. According to Nyaya, the knower is the…
Answer: C. The mind is only an inner organ.
3. According to relativism, knowledge is…
Answer: D. It depends on the individual.
4. Descartes wanted to prove that … is wrong.
Answer: A. He sought an indubitable truth.
5. In 'the hill has fire because it has smoke', the hetu is…
Answer: D. Hill = paksha; fire = sadhya.
6. Inference used to convince another person is…
Answer: A. Svartha = for oneself.
7. 'Fire is cool like ice' fails the condition of…
Answer: C. The words do not fit together.
8. Knowing a friend is absent because you do not see him is…
Answer: B. Non-perception gives knowledge of absence.
9. Which theory calls a proposition true if it matches the facts?
Answer: D. 'Venus is a star' fails it.
10. A fairy tale can satisfy which test while still being untrue?
Answer: A. Internally consistent but not matching reality.
11. The litmus test for an acid illustrates the … theory.
Answer: D. True if the expected result follows.
12. Who called the mind at birth a tabula rasa?
Answer: B. A blank slate.
13. Who denied material substance altogether?
Answer: B. Objects are collections of ideas.
14. For Hume, scientific truths about matters of fact are…
Answer: B. Only relations of ideas are certain.
15. Which of these is a primary quality for Locke?
Answer: A. Shape, size, solidity, motion and number are primary.
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “How do we know?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Done with the notes? Revise How do we know? the fun way: match key terms, beat the 60-second lightning round and spot true or false facts. Every game uses only this lesson, so each round is real exam revision.
⭐ 0 XP⏱ About 55 minutes
Get a ✓ Verified tutor for “How do we know?” — live online or at home. We aim to suggest up to 3 tutors within 24 hours.
Sign in free to see the answers to the textbook exercise of How do we know?.
Sign in to see solutionsStuck on a question? Type it, 🎤 speak it or 📷 snap a photo of it and get simple, step-by-step help with “How do we know?” — important questions, a quick quiz, revision notes — in English, मराठी or हिंदी.
Sign in with Google to ask the AI tutor. It's free — 20 questions a day, one TalentJR account.
Sign in to askPrefer a real teacher? TalentJR teachers take live online classes anywhere in India. Tell us what you need and our team will call you with timings and fees.